In the traditional historiography of the Enlightenment, the relationship between Voltaire and the French Parlements (sovereign courts) is often depicted as a binary struggle between progress and reaction. Voltaire is cast as the "defender of the oppressed" and a staunch advocate for absolute monarchy, while the Parlements are seen as obscurantist bodies that usurped royal authority and executed scandalous sentences. However, in his book Voltaire and the Parlements of France (2009), James Hanrahan challenges this monolithic view. Reviewed by Peter Balazs in Studi Francesi, Hanrahan’s work provides a necessary nuance to our understanding of the philosopher’s political and legal evolution.
The Problem of Anachronism
The central problem Hanrahan identifies in existing scholarship is one of anachronism. Historians have frequently projected Voltaire’s intense anti-parliamentary fervor of the 1760s and 1770s backward across his entire career. This retrospective lens obscures the reality of Voltaire’s earlier years, where his relationship with the courts was far more cooperative, or at least less antagonistic. Hanrahan seeks to dismantle the "convenient dichotomy" that pits the philosopher against the courts by examining how Voltaire’s thought evolved in response to specific historical contexts.
Methodological Approach
Hanrahan employs a contextualized historical and textual analysis, dividing Voltaire’s career into three distinct chronological units:
- Pre-1760: An examination of early works like La Henriade and Voltaire’s personal relationships with magistrates.
- The 1760s: An analysis of the famous "causes célèbres"—the Calas, Sirven, and La Barre affairs—alongside the writing of the Histoire du Parlement de Paris.
- Post-1771: A study of Voltaire’s reaction to the Maupeou judicial reforms and his major historical texts from this period.
By comparing contradictions between Voltaire’s public histories and his private correspondence, Hanrahan uncovers a perspective that was often more pragmatic than ideological.
Key Insights: From Alignment to Opposition
Early Alignment and Gallicanism
Contrary to the image of a lifelong rebel, Hanrahan finds that in his youth, Voltaire shared the "Gallican" convictions of many parliamentary magistrates. These convictions—favoring the independence of the French church from Roman papal authority—meant that Voltaire and the Parlements were often on the same side of religious-political debates. Furthermore, Hanrahan notes that royal and papal censors were historically more obstructive to Voltaire’s early work than the Parlements themselves.
Fanaticism as the True Enemy
During the 1760s, a decade marked by the infamous execution of Jean Calas, Voltaire’s rhetoric against the Parlements sharpened. However, Hanrahan argues that Voltaire’s primary target was not the institution of the Parlement as a legal body, but rather the abstract concept of religious fanaticism. The courts were the vehicle for this fanaticism, but they were not yet the sole focus of his political ire.
Pragmatism and the Maupeou Reforms
Voltaire’s eventual support for Chancellor Maupeou’s 1771 abolition of the Parlements is often cited as proof of his devotion to enlightened absolutism. Hanrahan nuances this by showing that Voltaire’s stance was heavily influenced by practical considerations. As the "Seigneur of Ferney," Voltaire had personal business interests and humanitarian goals that were better served by a centralized royal authority than by the localized, often obstructive power of the sovereign courts. His support for the crown was as much a tactical maneuver as it was a philosophical commitment.
Conclusion
Hanrahan’s research successfully recontextualizes Voltaire’s Histoire du Parlement de Paris not merely as a polemic, but as a sophisticated response to the growing national interest in French history. The book provides a more human and contradictory portrait of Voltaire—one whose political philosophy was fluid, reactive, and deeply rooted in the complexities of 18th-century French law. While some inconsistencies between Voltaire’s various historical works remain a subject for future study, Hanrahan has provided an essential critique of the "absolutist" interpretations of the Enlightenment.
Summary updated