In his comprehensive study, Vauvenargues ou le séditieux. Entre Pascal et Spinoza. Une philosophie pour la seconde nature, Laurent Bove offers a profound re-evaluation of Luc de Clapiers, Marquis de Vauvenargues (1715–1747). Long relegated to the status of a minor 18th-century moralist, Vauvenargues is here recast as a pivotal figure of the "Radical Enlightenment." Peter Balazs’ review of Bove’s work highlights how this new interpretation positions Vauvenargues as a sophisticated bridge between the metaphysical determinism of Baruch Spinoza and the socio-political realism of Blaise Pascal.
The Philosophical Challenge: Necessity vs. Action
The central problem Bove addresses is the historical classification and perceived depth of Vauvenargues. How can a thinker maintain a strictly deterministic view of the world—where every event is governed by necessity—while simultaneously advocating for human virtue, the "power to act," and social change? This tension often led earlier scholars to dismiss Vauvenargues as an inconsistent or superficial thinker.
Bove argues that Vauvenargues successfully navigates the "double nihilism" of his era: the rigid dogmatism of traditional theology on one side and the absolute skepticism (pyrrhonism) on the other. By grounding his thought in a "philosophy of the real," Vauvenargues avoids these pitfalls, focusing instead on the practical "power to act" (puissance d’agir).
A Synthesis of Giants: Spinoza and Pascal
The core of Bove’s thesis lies in Vauvenargues’ unique synthesis of two seemingly irreconcilable thinkers.
The Spinozism of Necessity
Vauvenargues aligns with Spinoza by rejecting the traditional concept of "free will." In his less-studied works, such as the Traité sur le libre arbitre and Discours sur la liberté, he posits that human actions are part of a deterministic metaphysical chain. This rejection of the "liberty of indifference" places him firmly within the radical camp of the Enlightenment, prioritizing natural laws and necessity over divine intervention or abstract human autonomy.
The Pascalian "Second Nature"
While his metaphysics are Spinozist, Vauvenargues’ social observations are deeply Pascalian. He adopts Pascal’s concept of "custom" or "habit" to explain human behavior. However, he performs a radical inversion: where Pascal used the malleability of human nature to argue for the necessity of divine grace and the truth of religion, Vauvenargues uses it to critique social oppression.
He posits a "second nature"—a layer of habits, social forces, and customs that define human existence. This allows him to argue that while we are determined by our environment, we still possess a "productive power" that allows for the development of "living virtue" and the reshaping of social reality.
Sedition as a Philosophical System
The title of Bove’s work characterizes Vauvenargues as "the séditieux" (the seditious). This is not merely a political label but a systematic philosophical one. It describes a transition from intellectual rebellion to social action:
- Intellectual Sedition: A rebellion against the idealistic prejudices of "cabinet philosophers" and the dogmas of the Church. Vauvenargues, influenced by the practical realism of Machiavelli, critiques those who ignore the reality of human passions.
- Social Sedition: The move toward a "common liberty" grounded in a new ontological system. By understanding the deterministic laws of "second nature," individuals can act collectively to overcome the state of oppression.
Conclusion: A New Philosophical System
Laurent Bove’s analysis demonstrates that Vauvenargues was not just a collector of maxims but the architect of a coherent philosophical system. This system is ontologically grounded in the reality of being and power, yet it remains dynamic. It reconciles the "logic of productive power" (Spinoza) with the "logic of second nature" (Pascal) to move from individual libertinism toward a robust concept of common liberty. For researchers in the history of ideas, this work suggests that the synthesis of Spinoza and Pascal may be a more significant, though previously under-recognized, trend in 18th-century radical thought.
Summary updated