Knowledge-based Economy as a Form of Noonomy and its Socio-Economic Impact

Enfu Cheng, Siyang GaoNoonomy 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper re-evaluates the "intellectual economy"—the AI-driven shift in global production—through the lens of Marxist political economy and the concept of "Noonomy." The authors argue that while AI appears to automate away the need for human labor, it actually creates new, subtler forms of exploitation and that a truly human-centric transition to a knowledge-based society requires a socialist framework to prevent technology from being monopolized by capital.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As Artificial Intelligence (AI) and big data become the primary drivers of economic growth, a rift has opened in academic circles. Some Western theorists argue that we have entered a "post-work" era where the traditional proletariat has disappeared and the "Law of Value" (the idea that labor creates value) is dead.

The authors, Cheng Enfu and Gao Siyang, tackle the question: Does the rise of AI actually liberate humanity from exploitation, or does it just hide the gears of capital? They address the theoretical gap between rapid technological change and the socio-economic structures that govern it, specifically critiquing the idea that "immaterial labor" (like data generation or emotional work) is somehow outside the realm of traditional economic exploitation.

Methods

This is a theoretical and comparative study. The authors employ Marxist political economy as their primary analytical framework to critique contemporary Western economic theories (such as those by Negri, Hardt, and Rifkin).

Key conceptual tools include:

  • Noonomy: A term coined by S.D. Bodrunov describing a post-industrial stage where production is integrated with knowledge, moving beyond traditional "economic" constraints.
  • Organic Composition of Capital: Analyzing the ratio between "dead labor" (machines/AI) and "living labor" (humans) to see how profit and value are maintained.
  • Dialectical Materialism: Used to explain how data acts simultaneously as a "raw material" and a "means of production."

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a theoretical treatise, the work relies on literature review, policy documents (like China’s "New Generation AI Development Plan"), and economic philosophy rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data as the "New Oil": The authors describe data as both the "raw material" (object of labor) and the "fuel" (means of labor) for AI. In this economy, the digital platform becomes the core infrastructure that coordinates resources and extracts value.
  • The Myth of the "End of Exploitation": Even when users "voluntarily" provide data to platforms in exchange for services, the authors argue this is a "digital enclosure." Capital appropriates the "immaterial labor" of users (emotions, social interactions, data) to create massive value that the workers/users never see.
  • The Law of Value Persistence: Critics argue that if machines do all the work, labor no longer creates value. The authors counter that capital compensates for automation in high-tech sectors by constantly creating new, low-tech, labor-intensive industries. This "polarization of labor" ensures that "living labor" remains the ultimate source of profit.
  • The "Winner-Takes-All" Effect: The intellectual economy naturally trends toward monopoly. Giant corporations use AI to monopolize data and platforms, effectively controlling the "real economy" (manufacturing and services) from a digital height.

Key Results

The paper concludes that the "intellectual economy" is not a neutral technological phase but a deeply political one.

  • Immaterial Labor is Material: The authors demonstrate that emotional and cognitive labor fits Marx’s definition of "productive labor" because it is used to produce commodities (data/software) and expand capital.
  • The Proletariat has Evolved, Not Vanished: Instead of disappearing, the working class has transformed into a "mass" of exploited individuals whose "entire life" is now subject to capital through digital monitoring and data extraction.
  • Socialist Noonomy: The authors argue that for a country like China, the intellectual economy must be steered by "state capital" and "human-centric development." This ensures that AI leads to the "free and comprehensive development of people" rather than just a "monopoly oligopoly."

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the intellectual economy is still in a state of "rapid development," meaning its ultimate essence is not yet fully demonstrated.

A significant limitation mentioned is the geopolitical context: the authors call for Russia and China to develop independent, collaborative strategies for the intellectual economy to resist "neo-imperialism" and the technological dominance of the United States. Future research is suggested in the area of how to practically coordinate the relationship between capital and labor in a way that prevents the "formal absorption" of human life by intelligent machines.

Summary updated

Abstract

the article defines intellectual economy as an economic activity based on artificial intelligence technologies and explores its specifics in the field of economic relations. It is noted that even seemingly equal relations of participants in intellectual activity to capitalist firms-customers conceal exploitation, since workers receive nothing but wages, and the effect of using intellectual products is appropriated by capital. The process of displacement of living labor by artificial intelligence does not mean the disappearance of value creation by labor, because in the process of value creation, capital compensates for the reduction of living labor in sectors with a high organic composition of capital by constantly creating new industries with a low organic composition of capital. The article emphasizes that only by returning to Marx’s system of political economy will we be able to understand the dialectical relationship between intangible labor, intellectual technologies and capital and provide a theoretical basis for the qualitative and effective development of the intellectual economy. The intellectual economy arises and develops in a certain social context and is limited by the existing social system. For the Chinese social system, the discussion of the intellectual economy and its social impact should take into account the requirements of the socialist system, for example, the ownership platform in the form of state capital, the coordination of relations between capital and labor, the free and comprehensive development of people, the direct unification of people and means of production
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2022knowledge,
  author = {Enfu Cheng and Siyang Gao},
  title = {{Knowledge-based Economy as a Form of Noonomy and its Socio-Economic Impact}},
  booktitle = {Noonomy},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.37930/2782-618x-2022-1-3-124-137},
}
Figure