Human-Machine Relationship from the Perspective of Labor Market Under the Background of Human-Machine Symbiosis

Yihan Zhang, Guiqing Li, Rongjian MaoAdvances 2021 · DOI

Abstract The purpose of the work is to find a more objective human-machine relationship. Through the theoretical analysis of the relevant literature at home and abroad, the characteristics of humans and machines in their respective work are summarized and compared. From the above analysis results, it is concluded that there is indeed a relationship of competition and cooperation between humans and computers, and a human-machine relationship model of "development power transfer" is proposed, possible methods to deal with the impact of the machine on the labor market are also given.

Introduction

As artificial intelligence (AI) transitions from a specialized tool to a pervasive presence in daily life and industry, the traditional paradigm of machines as mere "servants" is becoming obsolete. This shift toward "human-machine symbiosis" introduces significant friction into the labor market, characterized by a dual dilemma: AI's potential to drive economic growth through "creative destruction" versus its tendency to cause structural unemployment and devalue labor income. This paper explores this evolving relationship, proposing a "development power transfer" model to define a more objective framework for cooperation and competition.

The Development Power Transfer Model

The core contribution of this research is the conceptual "Development Power Transfer" model. This framework treats humans and AI as two interconnected modules within a feedback loop. It posits that the "power source" for AI development is the existing human knowledge base. As AI evolves and begins to replace procedural tasks, it effectively "transfers" the pressure of development back to humans.

The Development Power Transfer Model illustrating the cyclical relationship between human knowledge and AI progress.

In this cycle, AI displacement acts as a catalyst for human self-improvement. By automating low-level, repetitive tasks, AI forces humans to enhance their own "quality"—focusing on high-level skills and innovation. This human progress, in turn, enriches the knowledge base that feeds the next generation of AI, creating a continuous upward spiral of technological and human capability.

Comparative Advantages and the Labor Market

To understand this symbiosis, the authors categorize the distinct strengths of both parties. Humans excel in creativity, experience-based intuition, and the "internalization" of knowledge—the ability to turn information into wisdom. AI, conversely, dominates in the speed of knowledge reception, raw computing power, and objective environmental adaptation.

However, a major hurdle for true symbiosis is the "intentionality gap." While AI can determine "optimal decisions" based on data, it struggles to align with human intentions or navigate the often irrational, emotion-driven conflicts of interest found in organizational settings. Furthermore, the impact of AI is not uniform. In China, for instance, AI is more prevalent in developed regions with labor oversupply, increasing unemployment risks, whereas in underdeveloped regions, it serves to alleviate labor shortages.

Structural Impacts and Feedback Loops

The relationship between humans and machines is not a zero-sum game but a complex cooperation-competition mode. While AI competes for procedural cognitive jobs, it simultaneously drives a feedback loop where human skill upgrades lead to better AI.

The interaction between AI development power sources and human development power sources within the labor market.

As shown in the structural analysis, job substitution leads to temporary and structural unemployment, which then pressures the labor force to improve its quality structure. This increase in high-quality labor leads to progress in the overall knowledge level, which then feeds back into the development of the AI knowledge base. This mutual promotion ensures that while obsolete technologies are eliminated, the overall technical support and development power of both humans and machines are improved.

Policy Recommendations and Future Outlook

The paper concludes with several strategic recommendations. Policymakers should focus on a "Reasonable Improvement of Education Mode," shifting from training for repetitive labor to cultivating comprehensive, creative talents. Additionally, "Technical Constraints" are necessary—embedding ethical systems directly into AI hardware and software to ensure safety as AI's "power" grows.

The authors acknowledge that this model is primarily focused on the pre-AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) era. The arrival of AGI would introduce uncertainties that may require a fundamental reassessment of this framework. Future research should also aim to empirically validate the "development power transfer" model using longitudinal labor market data to determine if human quality improvement can truly keep pace with AI-driven displacement.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of the work is to find a more objective human-machine relationship. Through the theoretical analysis of the relevant literature at home and abroad, the characteristics of humans and machines in their respective work are summarized and compared. From the above analysis results, it is concluded that there is indeed a relationship of competition and cooperation between humans and computers, and a human-machine relationship model of "development power transfer" is proposed, possible methods to deal with the impact of the machine on the labor market are also given.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2021human,
  author = {Yihan Zhang and Guiqing Li and Rongjian Mao},
  title = {{Human-Machine Relationship from the Perspective of Labor Market Under the Background of Human-Machine Symbiosis}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2991/aebmr.k.210218.011},
}
Figure