Philosophical Thinking on the Revolution of the Relationship Between Human and Machine in the Era of Artificial Intelligence

Jiahao Zhu, Guiqing Li, Huijun XiaAdvances 2021 · DOI

Abstract

With the improvement of the intelligence level of artificial intelligence, the distinction between human and machine has become more and more blurred, which has caused a great impact on the traditional human-machine relationship. This paper considers the relationship between human and machine in the era of artificial intelligence from a philosophical point of view, and concludes that the relationship between human and machine in the era of artificial intelligence is still a subject-object relationship, a division of labor and cooperation relationship, and the relationship between man and machine is affected by social attributes, which provides certain insights for establishing a new type of human-machine relationship. After studying the specific content of the impact of AI on human society, it is concluded that the way of thinking, production and labor, and lifestyle of people will be changed in the era of artificial intelligence. Finally, it points out the challenges of traditional job substitution, increased social inequality, and ethical destruction in the development of AI, and it also gives some strategies to promote the development and application of AI, to promote the development of service industry and create new working forms, and to design AI that in line with human ethics, which provides effective social governance measures about AI for all social parties.

Introduction

The rapid integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into agriculture, industry, and daily life has disrupted traditional views of technology. We are moving past the era where machines were simple, mindless tools. Today, AI can perform tasks once thought uniquely human—such as medical diagnosis or artistic creation—leading to a "blurring" of identities. This evolution sparks both excitement for productivity and existential dread regarding the future of human agency. This paper addresses the fundamental question: How should we philosophically categorize our relationship with AI in this new era?

The Philosophical Nature of the Human-Machine Relationship

Despite AI’s increasing sophistication, a philosophical analysis—rooted in Marxist theory and the Moravec Paradox—suggests that the fundamental relationship remains one of subject and object.

While AI can simulate high-level reasoning and perform complex calculations (the "principle of optimization"), it lacks subjective initiative, genuine emotion, and normative values. Humans remain the subjects who define goals, while AI serves as the object—an advanced tool designed to augment human capability. Even as biotechnology and brain-computer interfaces raise "Ship of Theseus" style paradoxes regarding the physical boundaries of the human body, the core of human essence remains tied to social attributes and conscious intent that machines cannot replicate.

Socio-Economic Impact: The Rise of the Smart Economy

The AI revolution is driving a transition from a "capital economy" to a "smart economy." In this new paradigm, intellectual capital replaces financial capital as the primary driver of value. This shift is already reflected in global markets: the smart economy now accounts for nearly one-third of China's GDP and over 50% in countries like the United States and Germany.

This transition redefines production relations, leading to a "New Labor Dualism." The rise of gig workers on AI-driven platforms creates a hybrid labor relationship that is neither traditional employment nor true self-employment, requiring entirely new legal and social frameworks to ensure worker protection.

Human-AI Synergy and Labor Efficiency

Rather than total replacement, the most effective model for the future is human-AI synergy. Humans excel at coordinating perception and qualitative judgment (the "principle of satisfaction"), while machines excel at pure calculation.

Evidence of this synergy is compelling:

  • Medical Diagnostics: Harvard pathologists using AI identified breast cancer cells with 99.5% accuracy, significantly higher than humans alone (96%) or AI alone (92%).
  • Industrial Productivity: Automated factories, such as Volkswagen’s facility in Slovakia, can now produce a car every 50 seconds, demonstrating a level of efficiency humans cannot achieve without machine partnership.

Challenges and Ethical Considerations

The development of AI is not without significant risks that require proactive social governance:

  1. Labor Displacement: The World Economic Forum predicts that approximately 5.1 million jobs will disappear due to AI, primarily in labor-intensive sectors.
  2. Social Polarization: There is a risk of creating a permanent underclass of "information refugees" who lack the resources to participate in the data-rich smart economy.
  3. Ethical and Privacy Crises: AI systems still struggle with algorithmic bias and "hallucinations." Furthermore, massive data collection has led to a serious privacy crisis that current legal systems are unprepared to handle.

Conclusion

To navigate the AI revolution, we must expand our "ethical circle" to include the governance of AI products. This requires cross-disciplinary research involving brain science and psychology to design AI that conforms to human ethics. By fostering new working forms in the service and creative industries and implementing practical laws to govern AI-human interactions, society can ensure that AI remains a tool for human progress rather than a source of social destabilization.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the improvement of the intelligence level of artificial intelligence, the distinction between human and machine has become more and more blurred, which has caused a great impact on the traditional humanmachine relationship. This paper considers the relationship between human and machine in the era of artificial intelligence from a philosophical point of view, and concludes that the relationship between human and machine in the era of artificial intelligence is still a subject-object relationship, a division of labor and cooperation relationship, and the relationship between man and machine is affected by social attributes, which provides certain insights for establishing a new type of human-machine relationship. After studying the specific content of the impact of AI on human society, it is concluded that the way of thinking, production and labor, and lifestyle of people will be changed in the era of artificial intelligence. Finally, it points out the challenges of traditional job substitution, increased social inequality, and ethical destruction in the development of AI, and it also gives some strategies to promote the development and application of AI, to promote the development of service industry and create new working forms, and to design AI that in line with human ethics, which provides effective social governance measures about AI for all social parties.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2021philosophical,
  author = {Jiahao Zhu and Guiqing Li and Huijun Xia},
  title = {{Philosophical Thinking on the Revolution of the Relationship Between Human and Machine in the Era of Artificial Intelligence}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.2991/aebmr.k.210218.005},
}
Figure