The Internal Logic of Capital Metaphysics

Feng Shi, Jiang Bian2020 · DOI

Abstract

Capital contains a "double logic": the generating logic of the "physical" and the operating logic of the "metaphysical." Rooted in Marxist critique, this paper explores how capital, when transformed into "capital metaphysics," poses a significant threat to the real economy and national security. By analyzing the transition from capital as a tool for production to an abstract, dominating force, we propose a framework for re-anchoring financial systems to socialist values and tangible economic output.

Introduction: The Duality of Capital

In the contemporary global landscape, the relationship between the "virtual economy"—comprising finance, credit, and speculation—and the "real economy" of manufacturing and services has become increasingly strained. This paper investigates the philosophical and economic underpinnings of this disconnect through the lens of "capital metaphysics."

Capital is not a monolithic entity; it operates under a dual logic. Its "physical" logic is grounded in the support of production and the fulfillment of human needs. Conversely, its "metaphysical" logic represents an abstract, spiritualized power that seeks to generate value independently of physical constraints. When the metaphysical logic eclipses the physical, capital ceases to be a servant of society and instead becomes its ruler, leading to systemic instability and "capital fetishism."

Theoretical Framework: From Commodity to Abstraction

The analysis is rooted in Marxist Political Economy, specifically the evolution of exchange cycles. In a traditional productive economy, the cycle follows the $W-G-W$ (Commodity-Money-Commodity) pattern, where money serves as a mere medium to facilitate the exchange of useful goods.

However, as capital develops, the logic shifts to $G-W-G'$ (Money-Commodity-More Money), where the primary objective is the accumulation of surplus value. The final stage of "metaphysical" transition occurs when the cycle is truncated to $G-G'$ (Money-More Money), where credit and financial instruments appear to generate wealth out of thin air. This "financial deepening" or virtualization detaches asset prices from cost and technology, relying instead on speculative capitalization and psychological expectations.

The Two Transformations of Capital Metaphysics

The transition into capital metaphysics occurs through two distinct stages of alienation:

  1. From Means to End: Originally, capital and credit were tools designed to bridge gaps in production cycles. In the metaphysical stage, the accumulation of abstract wealth becomes the ultimate goal of social activity, subordinating the production of use-values to the pursuit of exchange-value.
  2. From Appurtenance to Ruler: As capital becomes metaphysical, it is no longer a secondary service for the real economy. It evolves into a primary force that dictates social values, influences policy, and "rules" over the populace. This creates a state of "spiritual emptiness," where material desire and capital appreciation replace human-centered development.

National Security and the Real Economy

The "metaphysical" path is an inherent tendency within capitalist systems, often leading to "de-realization"—the hollowing out of domestic manufacturing in favor of high-leverage financial activities. This shift poses a direct threat to national security by creating volatile economic bubbles and extreme wealth inequality.

To mitigate these risks, the paper advocates for a three-pronged strategy:

  • Institutional Safeguards: Leveraging the socialist system to ensure that financial mechanisms are directed toward the majority's welfare rather than the appreciation of minority capital.
  • Prioritizing the Real Economy: Explicitly rejecting high-leverage speculation and focusing state resources on maintaining a robust manufacturing and service base.
  • Cultural Resistance: Promoting core values that combat the "fetishism" of capital, re-centering social progress on human development rather than abstract financial metrics.

Conclusion

The internal logic of capital metaphysics reveals a trajectory toward abstraction that threatens the stability of the real economy. By understanding this "double logic," policymakers can better implement strategies to "abandon" the metaphysical trap. Re-anchoring finance to the physical realities of production and socialist principles is essential for ensuring long-term economic security and social harmony.

Summary updated

Abstract

Capital contains "double logic", the generating logic of "physical" and the operating logic of "metaphysical". Marxism attacked the capital metaphysics, He believed, if capital becoming capital metaphysics, who would have a great harm to the real economy. This paper discusses the possible way to abandon capital metaphysics from the point of national security.
BibTeX
@misc{shi2020internal,
  author = {Feng Shi and Jiang Bian},
  title = {{The Internal Logic of Capital Metaphysics}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2991/assehr.k.200801.048},
}
Figure