Abstract
We study the shape of the flux tube in lattice Yang-Mills theories and in particular its intrinsic width. In the framework of the Effective String Theory description of the confining flux tube this intrinsic width has no measurable effects on the inter-quark static potential, but it can be precisely detected looking at the profile of the flux tube. We address this problem with a set of high precision simulations in the (2+1) dimensional SU(2) model. We find two different behaviours as a function of the temperature. In the low temperature regime ($T \ll T_c$) we find a good agreement with an expression inspired by the dual superconductive model of confinement. In the high temperature regime ($T \lesssim T_c$) our data agree with a model based on the Svetitsky-Yaffe mapping. All our data in this regime can be described in terms of only one length scale, the intrinsic width, which turns out to be the same scale appearing in the confining inter-quark static potential.
Introduction
In quantum chromodynamics (QCD) and related confining gauge theories, quarks are bound together by a "flux tube" of chromoelectric field. While Effective String Theory (EST) models this tube as a vibrating 1D string, it primarily accounts for an "effective width" that grows with the separation distance between quarks due to quantum fluctuations. However, EST often neglects the intrinsic width—a fundamental, baseline thickness of the tube itself. Measuring this intrinsic width is challenging because it does not affect the static energy potential between quarks. To isolate it, researchers must analyze the transverse cross-sectional profile of the flux tube. This paper presents high-precision measurements of this profile in (2+1) dimensional SU(2) lattice gauge theory to understand the physical mechanisms governing the flux tube's structure across different thermal regimes.
Methodology
The study utilizes Monte Carlo simulations of the (2+1) dimensional SU(2) Yang-Mills model. To map the flux tube profile, the authors calculate a 3-point correlation function involving two Polyakov loops, representing a static quark-antiquark pair separated by distance $d$, and a plaquette probe placed at a transverse distance $y$.
Two distinct temperature regimes are investigated:
- Low Temperature ($T \ll T_c$): The Lüscher-Weisz multilevel algorithm is used to achieve the necessary precision. The data is fitted using the Clem model, which describes magnetic vortices in Type-II superconductors, aligning with the dual superconductor model of confinement.
- High Temperature ($T \lesssim T_c$): Near the deconfinement transition, the authors apply a model derived from the Svetitsky-Yaffe (SY) mapping, which relates the 3D SU(2) theory to the 2D Ising model.
Key Insights and Results
Deviation from Gaussian Behavior
While basic string models predict a Gaussian distribution for the flux tube profile, high-precision data reveals significant deviations. The profile exhibits exponentially decaying tails at large transverse distances, a feature captured by the Clem model but missed by simple Gaussian fits.
The Nature of Intrinsic Width
The simulations demonstrate that the length scale $\lambda$ governing these exponential tails—the intrinsic width—is independent of the inter-quark distance $d$. This confirms it as a fundamental property of the flux tube rather than a result of string vibrations.
Temperature Dependence and Scale Unification
As the temperature approaches the critical deconfinement temperature ($T_c$), the intrinsic width grows substantially. At $T = 0.70 T_c$, the dimensionless width $\lambda \sqrt{\sigma_0}$ is approximately 0.60, increasing to 1.30 by $T = 0.87 T_c$. Remarkably, in the high-temperature regime, the intrinsic width $\lambda$ is found to be exactly half the decay length of the Polyakov loop correlator ($\lambda = T / 2\sigma(T)$), indicating that the flux tube profile and the confining potential are governed by the same physical scale.
Discussion and Limitations
While the Clem model provides an excellent fit at low temperatures, the authors note that the physical interpretation of its "variational length" parameter remains unclear within the context of dual superconductivity. Additionally, extracting the intrinsic width at low temperatures involves systematic uncertainties due to the subtlety of the exponential tails. Future work is required to develop a rigorous theoretical framework that smoothly interpolates between the Gaussian core and the exponential tails across all temperature regimes.
Conclusion
This research provides a precise characterization of the flux tube's intrinsic width in SU(2) gauge theory. By identifying distinct behaviors in the low and high-temperature regimes, the study highlights the limitations of simple string models and underscores the importance of dual superconductivity and critical phenomena in describing the fundamental structure of confinement.
Summary updated