Abstract
We study the profile of the flux tube in the SU(2) gauge model in (2 + 1) dimensions, with a particular attention to the so called "intrinsic width" which drives the exponential decay of the flux density at large transverse distances and represents a new physical scale of the model. This quantity is directly related to the confining mechanism which generates the flux tube and can be used to test its properties. We study a wide range of different values of lattice spacing, temperature and flux tube lengths and show that our data are precise enough to distinguish between different confining models. In particular we show that at high temperatures (just below the deconfinement transition) the data are perfectly described by an Ising-like effective model based on the Svetitsky-Yaffe mapping. At lower temperatures this approximation does not hold anymore. In this regime (which is the most interesting one from a physical point of view) we test several alternative proposals and show that the dual superconductor model is the one which better fits the data. However, this proposal is not fully satisfactory, because the values of the Ginzburg-Landau parameter extracted from the fits increase with the length of the flux tube, which is not a feature predicted by the model. This suggests that a more sophisticated model is needed to explain confinement in non-abelian gauge theories and, at the same time, that our data on the intrinsic width may be a powerful tool to benchmark these candidates.
Introduction
In quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the phenomenon of confinement ensures that quarks are never found in isolation. When two quarks are separated, the color field between them does not spread out spherically but instead collapses into a narrow "flux tube" or string. While Effective String Theory (EST) models this flux tube as a vibrating 1D string—predicting a Gaussian cross-sectional profile—real flux tubes in gauge theories exhibit exponentially decaying tails at large transverse distances.
These tails define an "intrinsic width" ($\lambda$) of the flux tube. This width arises from the interaction between massless string fluctuations and the massive, non-stringy excitations of the underlying gauge theory. Because the microscopic mechanism of confinement remains one of the most significant unsolved problems in physics, precisely measuring this intrinsic width provides a diagnostic tool to benchmark theoretical models of confinement.
Methodology
This study focuses on the SU(2) pure gauge theory in (2+1) dimensions. This model serves as a computationally efficient laboratory that shares the same infrared physics as 4D non-abelian theories.
Simulations and Measurement
Data were generated using Monte Carlo lattice gauge theory simulations, specifically employing the Lüscher-Weisz multilevel algorithm to achieve high precision across various lattice spacings, temperatures, and flux tube lengths. The primary observable is the transverse profile of the chromoelectric field between two static color sources.
As shown in the figure above, the measurement involves a three-point correlation function of two Polyakov loops (representing the static quarks) and a plaquette (representing the field probe). By varying the transverse distance $y$, the authors map the flux tube's cross-section.
Theoretical Modeling
To extract the intrinsic width, the non-Gaussian tails were fitted to several models:
- Low Temperature: The authors tested model-independent exponential fits and the Clem ansatz, derived from the dual superconductor model of confinement.
- High Temperature: The Svetitsky-Yaffe (SY) mapping was used, which relates the 3D gauge theory near its deconfinement transition to a 2D Ising model.
Key Results and Insights
Intrinsic Width as a Fundamental Scale
The parameter $\lambda$ driving the exponential tails was found to be independent of the flux tube's length and stable at low temperatures. This confirms it is a true physical characteristic of the gauge theory. The authors extracted a highly precise value at low temperatures: $\lambda\sqrt{\sigma} = 0.244(4)$, where $\sigma$ is the string tension.
The Dual Superconductor Challenge
While the Clem formula fits the low-temperature data well, it yields a Ginzburg-Landau parameter that varies with the flux tube length. This contradiction with the standard dual superconductor picture suggests the model is incomplete or requires refinement to account for the dynamical nature of the flux tube.
High-Temperature Ising Behavior
Just below the deconfinement temperature ($T \approx 0.68 T_c$), the flux tube profile is perfectly described by the Svetitsky-Yaffe mapping. The intrinsic width diverges exactly as predicted as the system approaches the critical temperature, demonstrating the power of universality in these systems.
Holographic and Glueball Connections
A significant finding is the relationship between the intrinsic width and the mass gap of the theory. The measured width is remarkably close to the inverse of the lightest glueball mass ($M_0$), with $\lambda M_0 = 1.16(3)$. This aligns with predictions from holographic duality (AdS/CFT), linking the thickness of the flux tube directly to the theory's mass spectrum.
Conclusion
The intrinsic width of the flux tube is a robust physical scale that provides deep insights into the confining vacuum. While high-temperature behavior is well-understood through Ising-like mappings, low-temperature results challenge existing phenomenological models like the dual superconductor. These high-precision results serve as a benchmark for future theoretical developments, including extensions to SU(N) theories and refined models of monopole condensation.
Summary updated