Intrinsic width of the flux tube in 2+1 dimensional Yang-Mills theories

Lorenzo Verzichelli, M. Caselle, Elia Cellini, Alessandro Nada, Dario Panfalone

Abstract

We study the shape of the flux tube in lattice Yang-Mills theories and in particular its intrinsic width. In the framework of the Effective String Theory description of the confining flux tube this intrinsic width has no measurable effects on the inter-quark static potential, but it can be precisely detected looking at the profile of the flux tube. We address this problem with a set of high precision simulations in the (2+1) dimensional $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ model. We find two different behaviours as a function of the temperature. In the low temperature regime ($T \ll T_c$) we find a good agreement with an expression inspired by the dual superconductive model of confinement. In the high temperature regime ($T \lesssim T_c$) our data agree with a model based on the Svetitsky-Yaffe mapping. All our data in this regime can be described in terms of only one length scale, the intrinsic width, which turns out to be the same scale appearing in the confining inter-quark static potential.

Introduction: The Search for Intrinsic Width

In Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the confinement of quarks is mediated by flux tubes—narrow regions where gluon fields are concentrated. While Effective String Theory (EST) often treats these tubes as infinitely thin vibrating strings, physical intuition suggests they possess an "intrinsic width" ($\lambda$). This width represents the fundamental thickness of the tube, independent of its quantum fluctuations (the "effective width").

Detecting this intrinsic width is notoriously difficult because it has negligible effects on the inter-quark static potential. Instead, researchers must probe the transverse profile of the flux tube. This study utilizes high-precision lattice simulations in (2+1)-dimensional SU(2) Yang-Mills theory to measure this width and its temperature dependence.

Methodology: High-Precision Lattice Profiling

The (2+1)-dimensional SU(2) model serves as an ideal laboratory, capturing essential infrared physics while remaining computationally manageable. The researchers employed cubic lattices and the standard Wilson action, utilizing the Lüscher-Weisz multilevel method to achieve high signal-to-noise ratios, particularly at low temperatures.

Diagram of the lattice setup used to measure the flux tube profile, showing the placement of Polyakov loops and the probe plaquette.

To map the flux tube's shape, the team measured the correlation between a quark-antiquark pair (represented by two Polyakov loops separated by distance $d$) and a plaquette probe placed at a transverse distance $y$ from the axis connecting the quarks. This allows for a precise determination of the field strength distribution $\rho(y)$.

Key Insights: Beyond the Gaussian Approximation

A significant finding of this work is the inadequacy of simple Gaussian models. While the Nambu-Goto string model predicts a Gaussian profile, lattice data reveals "fatter" tails that decay exponentially rather than quadratically.

Comparison of the flux tube profile with Gaussian and Clem model fits, highlighting the failure of the Gaussian model in the tails.

At low temperatures ($T \ll T_c$), the flux tube profile is remarkably well-described by the Clem formula, a model borrowed from dual superconductivity where the flux tube is analogous to an Abrikosov vortex. In this regime, the intrinsic width $\lambda$ acts as the "London length" of the dual superconductor.

Temperature Dependence and Scaling

The behavior of the flux tube changes as the system approaches the deconfinement temperature ($T_c$):

  • Low Temperature Regime: The intrinsic width remains relatively constant when scaled by the string tension ($\lambda\sqrt{\sigma_0} \approx 0.25$).
  • High Temperature Regime ($T \lesssim T_c$): As the system nears the phase transition, the intrinsic width grows significantly. By $0.87 T_c$, the width more than doubles compared to its low-temperature value.

In the high-temperature regime, the data aligns with the Svetitsky-Yaffe (SY) mapping, which relates (2+1)D gauge theories to 2D Ising models. The researchers found that the intrinsic width in this regime is directly linked to the string tension through the relation $2\lambda = T/\sigma(T)$, suggesting a deep universal connection between the tube's physical thickness and the confining force.

Conclusion

This study provides robust evidence for a non-zero intrinsic width of the confining flux tube. By moving beyond the static potential and analyzing the field profile, the authors demonstrated that the flux tube is more than just a vibrating line; it is a physical object with a temperature-dependent thickness that scales predictably with the theory's fundamental parameters. Future work will aim to extend these findings to (3+1)-dimensional QCD and explore the universality of these results across different gauge groups.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the shape of the flux tube in lattice Yang-Mills theories and in particular its intrinsic width. In the framework of the Effective String Theory description of the confining flux tube this intrinsic width has no measurable effects on the inter-quark static potential, but it can be precisely detected looking at the profile of the flux tube. We address this problem with a set of high precision simulations in the (2+1) dimensional $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ model. We find two different behaviours as a function of the temperature. In the low temperature regime ($T \ll T_c$) we find a good agreement with an expression inspired by the dual superconductive model of confinement. In the high temperature regime ($T \lesssim T_c$) our data agree with a model based on the Svetitsky-Yaffe mapping. All our data in this regime can be described in terms of only one length scale, the intrinsic width, which turns out to be the same scale appearing in the confining inter-quark static potential.
BibTeX
@misc{verzichelli2026intrinsic,
  author = {Lorenzo Verzichelli and M. Caselle and Elia Cellini and Alessandro Nada and Dario Panfalone},
  title = {{Intrinsic width of the flux tube in 2+1 dimensional Yang-Mills theories}},
  year = {2026},
  eprint = {2603.05323},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05323},
}
Figure