Abstract
We develop and test a simple model of limited attention in intertemporal choice. The model posits that individuals fully attend to consumption in all periods but fail to attend to some future lumpy expenditure opportunities. This asymmetry generates some predictions that overlap with models of present-bias. Our model also generates the unique predictions that reminders may increase saving, and that reminders will be more effective when they increase the salience of a specific expenditure. We find support for these predictions in three field experiments that randomly assign reminders to new savings account holders.
Introduction: The Challenge of Undersaving
Traditional economic theory often attributes undersaving to a lack of willpower or "present bias"—the tendency to prioritize immediate gratification over long-term goals. However, Karlan et al. propose an alternative cognitive bottleneck: limited attention. They argue that individuals are fully aware of current consumption needs but often fail to attend to future "lumpy" expenditures, such as school fees or insurance premiums. This "top of mind" asymmetry leads to suboptimal saving behavior.
Theoretical Framework: Modeling Limited Attention
The authors develop a model of intertemporal choice where individuals maximize utility but overlook future expenditure opportunities with a certain probability. Unlike models of self-control, this framework suggests that the primary issue isn't a lack of discipline, but a failure to forecast future needs. This model yields two unique predictions:
- Reminders can increase saving by bringing future needs back to the "top of mind."
- Reminders are most effective when they increase the salience of a specific, tangible expenditure.
Methodology and Data
To test these predictions, the researchers conducted three large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs) across diverse geographic and economic contexts:
- Philippines (First Valley Bank): 2,314 clients with "Dream Savings" accounts.
- Peru (Caja de Ica): 2,968 clients with "Plan Ahorro" accounts.
- Bolivia (Ecofuturo): 9,652 clients signed up for the "Ecoaguinaldo" year-end bonus product.
In total, the study tracked over 14,000 real-world bank clients. After opening goal-oriented accounts, participants were randomly assigned to receive monthly reminders (via SMS or letter) or a control group with no reminders. The experiments varied the framing (gain vs. loss), timing, and content (generic vs. goal-specific) of the messages.
Key Insights and Results
The field experiments provided strong evidence for the limited attention hypothesis.
Overall Impact of Reminders
Receiving any form of reminder increased total bank savings by 6% and improved the likelihood of achieving a specific savings goal by 3 percentage points. Notably, the impact of a simple SMS reminder was comparable to more intrusive "commitment" features, such as accounts that restrict withdrawals.
The Power of Salience
The content of the reminder mattered significantly. In Peru, reminders that mentioned the client's specific goal (e.g., "Save for your home repair") were twice as effective as generic reminders. In fact, generic messages in that context had no statistically significant effect, suggesting that the reminder must successfully trigger the specific mental account associated with the saving goal.
Reconciling Time Inconsistency
The study found that reminders were particularly effective for individuals who appeared "time-inconsistent" in baseline surveys. This suggests that what is often diagnosed as a lack of self-control may actually be a manifestation of inattention and credit constraints.
Framing and Cost-Effectiveness
Interestingly, the framing of the message (gain vs. loss) and the timing (regular vs. late) did not significantly alter the outcomes. From a policy perspective, the cost-effectiveness of these interventions is high. While physical mail in Peru cost nearly $1 per letter, SMS reminders in Bolivia and the Philippines had negligible marginal costs, offering banks a high return on investment for improving client outcomes.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the results are promising, several questions remain:
- Selection: The study focused on individuals who had already initiated a savings plan. It remains unclear if reminders can motivate "non-savers" to begin.
- Substitution: The data tracks specific bank accounts; it is possible that some "increased saving" represents a shift of funds from other sources rather than a net increase in total wealth.
- Habituation: Long-term effects are unknown, as individuals might eventually ignore repetitive notifications.
- Market Dynamics: Future research should explore how lenders might use similar "top of mind" tactics to encourage high-interest borrowing, potentially counteracting the benefits of savings reminders.
Conclusion
By identifying limited attention as a microfoundation for undersaving, this research offers a low-cost, scalable solution for financial institutions and policymakers. Simple reminders serve as a cognitive "prod," helping individuals align their current actions with their long-term financial goals.
Summary updated