Getting to the Top of Mind: How Reminders Increase Saving

Dean Karlan, Margaret McConnell, Sendhil Mullainathan, Jonathan Zinman

TL;DR

This paper argues that undersaving isn't just a failure of willpower, but a failure of attention. By modeling "limited attention" in intertemporal choice, the authors show that simple reminders can increase total savings by 6% and are twice as effective when they highlight a specific future goal.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional economic models assume "Homo Economicus" has perfect foresight and infinite attention. Behavioral models often refine this by suggesting we have "present bias"—a lack of self-control that makes us value today's consumption over tomorrow's.

The authors propose a different cognitive bottleneck: limited attention. They suggest that while we are fully aware of what we want to buy today, we frequently "underforecast" future "lumpy" expenditures (like school fees, insurance premiums, or car repairs). Because these future needs aren't "top of mind," we spend money now that we should be saving. The paper seeks to prove that if inattention is the culprit, then simple, low-cost reminders should be a powerful tool to correct saving behavior.

Methods

The researchers combined theoretical modeling with large-scale field evidence:

  1. Theoretical Model: They developed a model where individuals maximize utility over time but overlook future lumpy expenditure opportunities with some probability. This model predicts that reminders increase the probability of "attending" to the future, thereby increasing current savings.
  2. Field Experiments (RCTs): They conducted three randomized controlled trials with banks in Bolivia (Ecofuturo), Peru (Caja de Ica), and the Philippines (First Valley Bank).
  3. Variations: After clients opened goal-oriented savings accounts, they were randomly assigned to receive monthly reminders (via SMS or letter) or no reminders. The researchers tested different "frames" (gain vs. loss), timing (regular vs. late), and content (generic vs. mentioning the client's specific goal).

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data from over 14,000 bank clients across three countries:

  • Philippines: 2,314 individuals who opened "Dream Savings" accounts.
  • Peru: 2,968 individuals who opened "Plan Ahorro" accounts.
  • Bolivia: 9,652 individuals who signed up for the "Ecoaguinaldo" year-end bonus product.

Unlike many lab-based behavioral studies, these datasets represent real-world financial decisions among the working poor and lower-middle class in emerging markets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Attention as a Microfoundation for Mental Accounting: Why do people label savings accounts (e.g., "For my daughter's wedding")? The paper suggests this works because the label creates a strong association between today's saving and a specific future event, increasing the "salience" of that event and making it harder to ignore when choosing to spend today.
  • The "Planning Fallacy" in Finance: Much like people underestimate how long a task will take, they underestimate how many expenses they will face in the future. Reminders act as a cognitive "prod" to correct this underestimation.
  • Reminders vs. Commitment: Interestingly, the effect of a simple SMS reminder was comparable in size to more "heavy-duty" commitment features (like accounts that block withdrawals) found in previous studies.
  • Reconciling Time Inconsistency: The authors show that people who appear "time-inconsistent" (choosing $100 today over $110 tomorrow, but $110 in a year and a day over $100 in a year) might actually just be credit-constrained and inattentive. Reminders were found to be significantly more effective for this specific group.

Key Results

  • Overall Impact: Receiving any reminder increased the total amount saved in the bank by 6% and increased the likelihood of reaching a specific savings goal by 3 percentage points.
  • Salience Matters: In Peru, reminders that mentioned the client's specific goal (e.g., "Save for your home repair") were twice as effective as generic reminders. In fact, generic reminders in that context had almost no statistically significant effect.
  • Framing and Timing: Surprisingly, whether a message was framed as a "gain" (save to make your dream come true) or a "loss" (don't fail to reach your goal) made little difference. Similarly, "late" reminders (sent only if a deposit was missed) weren't significantly better than regular monthly ones.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: While direct mail reminders in Peru cost nearly $1 per letter (making them barely cost-effective for small balances), SMS reminders in Bolivia and the Philippines had near-zero marginal cost, representing a massive ROI for banks.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Selection Bias: The study only looked at people who had already decided to open a savings account. It doesn't tell us if reminders can turn "non-savers" into "savers."
  • Substitution Effects: The researchers could only see the balance in the specific bank account studied. They couldn't determine if people were actually saving more overall, or just moving money from under a mattress or another bank into the "reminded" account.
  • Habituation: The study doesn't address whether people eventually "tune out" reminders if they receive them for years.
  • Market Competition: The authors suggest future work should look at how lenders might exploit limited attention by providing "on-demand" credit (like credit cards or payday loans) that arrives exactly when a lumpy expenditure is at the "top of mind," potentially out-competing the "save-first" reminders.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop and test a simple model of limited attention in intertemporal choice. The model posits that individuals fully attend to consumption in all periods but fail to attend to some future lumpy expenditure opportunities. This asymmetry generates some predictions that overlap with models of present-bias. Our model also generates the unique predictions that reminders may increase saving, and that reminders will be more effective when they increase the salience of a specific expenditure. We find support for these predictions in three field experiments that randomly assign reminders to new savings account holders.
BibTeX
@misc{karlan2010getting,
  author = {Dean Karlan and Margaret McConnell and Sendhil Mullainathan and Jonathan Zinman},
  title = {{Getting to the Top of Mind: How Reminders Increase Saving}},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.1652784},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}

Loading related content...

Figure