Electromagnetic corrections to light hadron masses

Antonin Portelli, Stephan Dürr, Z. Fodor, Julien Frison, Christian Hoelbling, S. D. Katz, Stefan Krieg, Thorsten Kurth, Laurent Lellouch, Thomas Lippert, Kata Szabó, Alberto Ramos

Abstract: At the precision reached in current lattice QCD calculations, electromagnetic effects are becoming numerically relevant. We will present preliminary results for electromagnetic corrections to light hadron masses, based on simulations in which a $\mathrm{U}(1)$ degree of freedom is superimposed on $N_f=2+1$ QCD configurations from the BMW collaboration.

Introduction

In the study of subatomic particles, isospin symmetry assumes that up and down quarks are nearly identical. However, this symmetry is fundamentally broken by two factors: the difference in quark masses and their distinct electric charges ($+2/3e$ for up, $-1/3e$ for down). While electromagnetic (QED) effects were historically negligible compared to the strong nuclear force (QCD), modern lattice simulations have reached a level of precision where these corrections—approximately 1% of the total mass—represent a dominant source of uncertainty.

A primary goal of this research is to quantify the violation of Dashen’s theorem. This theorem predicts that electromagnetic mass splittings for pions and kaons should be equal in certain theoretical limits. Determining the extent of this violation is essential for the precise determination of individual up and down quark masses.

Methodology

The study employs a Lattice QCD+QED approach using high-quality gauge configurations from the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal (BMW) Collaboration. The simulations utilize $N_f = 2+1$ QCD configurations, incorporating two light quarks and one strange quark as dynamic degrees of freedom.

Quenched QED and Mass Retuning

To manage computational costs, the researchers utilized "quenched" QED, superimposing a non-compact $U(1)$ electromagnetic field onto existing QCD vacuum snapshots. This formulation prevents unphysical photon self-interactions.

Because the Wilson fermions used in these simulations break specific symmetries, the introduction of electromagnetism leads to mathematical divergences in quark masses. To address this, a mass retuning method was developed using a parameter $\delta$. As shown in the tuning analysis, the PCAC (Partially Conserved Axial Current) masses exhibit a robust linear relationship with this tuning parameter, allowing for the accurate subtraction of lattice-induced artifacts.

Mass isospin tuning showing the linear dependence of PCAC masses on the tuning parameter $\delta$.

Results and Discussion

The results indicate that QED can be effectively treated as a perturbation on top of QCD. By applying random Gaussian electromagnetic fields to existing QCD data, the team extracted electromagnetic effects with high efficiency.

Dashen’s Theorem Violation

The preliminary findings reveal a significant violation of Dashen’s theorem. The electromagnetic corrections to kaon masses are substantially larger than those for pions. The study calculated the following mass splittings:

  • Pion Splitting: $\Delta_{EM} M_\pi^2 = 1380 \pm 50 \text{ MeV}^2$
  • Kaon Splitting: $\Delta_{EM} M_K^2 = 2200 \pm 180 \text{ MeV}^2$

The Dashen violation parameter ($\Delta_A D$) was found to be $830 \pm 180 \text{ MeV}^2$, a stark contrast to the zero value predicted by the original theorem. The relative correction ($\Delta_R D$) of $0.60 \pm 0.14$ suggests a 60% deviation from simple theoretical expectations. These results are compared with various phenomenological and other lattice estimates in the literature.

Comparison of lattice results for Dashen violation parameters $\Delta_A D$ and $\Delta_R D$ with various phenomenological estimates.

Conclusion

This preliminary report demonstrates a viable path for incorporating electromagnetic corrections into high-precision lattice QCD. While the current results use a quenched approximation for QED and a single lattice spacing ($a \approx 0.116$ fm), they provide a critical baseline for future calculations. Subsequent work will focus on unquenching the QED effects, performing continuum extrapolations across multiple lattice spacings, and including "disconnected" diagrams to further refine the precision of light hadron mass determinations.

Summary updated

Abstract

At the precision reached in current lattice QCD calculations, electromagnetic effects are becoming numerically relevant. We will present preliminary results for electromagnetic corrections to light hadron masses, based on simulations in which a $\mathrm{U}(1)$ degree of freedom is superimposed on $N_f=2+1$ QCD configurations from the BMW collaboration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{portelli2011electromagnetic,
  author = {Antonin Portelli and Stephan Dürr and Z. Fodor and Julien Frison and Christian Hoelbling and S. D. Katz and Stefan Krieg and Thorsten Kurth and Laurent Lellouch and Thomas Lippert and Kata Szabó and Alberto Ramos},
  title = {{Electromagnetic corrections to light hadron masses}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of The XXVIII International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory — PoS(Lattice 2010)},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.22323/1.105.0121},
}
Figure