Electromagnetic corrections to light hadron masses

Antonin Portelli, Stephan Dürr, Z. Fodor, Julien Frison, Christian Hoelbling, S. D. Katz, Stefan Krieg, Thorsten Kurth, Laurent Lellouch, Thomas Lippert, K. K. Szabó, Alberto Ramos

Abstract

At the precision reached in current lattice QCD calculations, electromagnetic effects are becoming numerically relevant. We present preliminary results for electromagnetic corrections to light hadron masses, based on simulations in which a U(1) degree of freedom is superimposed on $N_f = 2 + 1$ QCD configurations from the Budapest-Marseille-Wuppertal (BMW) collaboration.

Introduction: Breaking Isospin Symmetry

In subatomic physics, isospin symmetry assumes that up ($u$) and down ($d$) quarks are essentially identical. However, this symmetry is broken by two primary factors: the difference in their intrinsic masses and their distinct electric charges ($+2/3e$ and $-1/3e$, respectively). As lattice QCD simulations reach higher levels of precision, these electromagnetic (EM) effects can no longer be neglected.

A central focus of this research is Dashen’s theorem, which historically predicted that electromagnetic mass splittings for kaons and pions should be related in a specific way in the chiral limit. Previous studies have shown widely varying results for how much this theorem is violated. This paper aims to provide a more consistent calculation using high-quality ensembles.

Methodology: Quenched QED and Mass Retuning

The authors employ a "quenched QED" approach, superimposing electromagnetic fields onto existing $N_f = 2+1$ flavor QCD configurations. This method avoids the high computational cost of full dynamical QED+QCD simulations while capturing the essential isospin-breaking effects.

Key technical implementations include:

  • Non-compact Lattice QED: Formulated to prevent artificial photon self-interactions.
  • Lagrange Multipliers: Used to maintain charge neutrality on a finite 4-dimensional torus by introducing a background current density.
  • Mass Retuning: Because the addition of EM effects causes an additive shift in quark masses, the bare masses must be "retuned." This ensures that $u$ and $d$ quarks remain degenerate in the absence of EM effects, allowing for the isolation of specific isospin-breaking signals.
Figure 4: Mass isospin tuning showing the linear relationship between PCAC mass and the tuning parameter δ.

Key Insights

Linearity of Renormalization

The relationship between the Partially Conserved Axial Current (PCAC) mass and the tuning parameter $\delta$ was found to be strictly linear. This linearity ensures that the subtraction of EM-induced mass shifts is highly reliable and numerically stable.

Volume Resilience

Through semi-analytical calculations of the "plaquette" (a fundamental loop on the lattice), the study demonstrated that for lattice extents $L > 10$, finite-volume effects on the electromagnetic field become negligible. This confirms that the chosen lattice sizes are sufficient to suppress artificial boundary effects.

Results: Violating Dashen's Theorem

The preliminary results confirm a significant violation of Dashen's theorem. The absolute correction, $\Delta_A D$, is found to be non-zero and positive, which has major implications for accurately determining the individual masses of the up and down quarks.

Figure 6: Comparison of Dashen's theorem violation parameters (Δ_A D and Δ_R D) across various phenomenological and lattice studies.

The quantitative findings (statistical errors only) include:

  • Pion EM mass splitting: $\Delta_{EM} M_\pi^2 = 1380 \pm 50 \text{ MeV}^2$
  • Kaon EM mass splitting: $\Delta_{EM} M_K^2 = 2200 \pm 180 \text{ MeV}^2$
  • Dashen's theorem violation ($\Delta_A D$): $830 \pm 180 \text{ MeV}^2$
  • Relative correction ($\Delta_R D$): $0.60 \pm 0.14$

These values indicate that EM effects contribute more significantly to the kaon mass difference than to the pion mass difference, proving that the Dashen limit is an insufficient approximation for high-precision physics.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While these results are promising, they currently utilize the quenched approximation for QED and a single lattice spacing. Future work will involve extending the simulations to lower quark masses, multiple lattice spacings, and larger volumes. Incorporating the electromagnetic charges of "sea quarks" will be a critical step toward a full determination of the fundamental $u$ and $d$ quark masses with fully controlled systematic uncertainties.

Summary updated

Abstract

At the precision reached in current lattice QCD calculations, electromagnetic effects are becoming numerically relevant. We will present preliminary results for electromagnetic corrections to light hadron masses, based on simulations in which a U(1) degree of freedom is superimposed on N f = 2 + 1 QCD configurations from the BMW collaboration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{portelli2011electromagnetic,
  author = {Antonin Portelli and Stephan Dürr and Z. Fodor and Julien Frison and Christian Hoelbling and S. D. Katz and Stefan Krieg and Thorsten Kurth and Laurent Lellouch and Thomas Lippert and K. K. Szabó and Alberto Ramos},
  title = {{Electromagnetic corrections to light hadron masses}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of The XXVIII International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory — PoS(Lattice 2010)},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.22323/1.105.0121},
}
Figure