Update on pi and K Physics

Milc Collaboration, C. Bernard, Pietro Butti, Steven Gottlieb, Urs M. Heller, J. E. Hetrick, L. Levkova, F. Maresca, J. D. Osborn, Dru B. Renner, Robert Sugar, D. ToussaintarXiv 2005 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We present an update of the MILC studies of the physics of light pseudoscalars using improved staggered fermions. New runs at lighter quark mass, as well as increased statistics for older sets, are enabling us to improve the results for decay constants in full QCD. In addition, we have analyzed quenched runs at two different lattice spacings. This makes possible a test of the applicability of staggered chiral perturbation theory in a different context.

Introduction: Probing the Non-Perturbative Strong Force

Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) is the fundamental theory of the strong force, yet it presents immense computational challenges at the low energies where pions ($\pi$) and kaons ($K$) reside. In this non-perturbative regime, standard analytical approximations fail, necessitating the use of Lattice QCD—a method that discretizes spacetime into a four-dimensional grid to simulate particle interactions numerically.

A primary challenge in this field is the "chiral extrapolation." Because simulating quarks at their physical masses is computationally expensive, researchers typically simulate heavier quarks and extrapolate to the physical point. This paper provides an update on the MILC collaboration's efforts to reduce systematic errors in these extrapolations by incorporating new, lighter-mass data and higher statistics to precisely determine decay constants ($f_\pi, f_K$) and CKM matrix elements.

Methodology

The study utilizes improved staggered fermions (the Asqtad action) with $N_f = 3$ flavors of dynamical quarks. Key methodological components include:

  • Lattice Spacing Control: Comparison between "coarse" ($a \approx 0.12$ fm) and "fine" ($a \approx 0.086$ fm) lattices to mitigate discretization errors.
  • Staggered Chiral Perturbation Theory (S$\chi$PT): This framework accounts for "taste-splitting," a lattice artifact where a single physical quark flavor appears as multiple "tastes."
  • Complex Fitting Strategy: The team performed joint fits for decay constants and meson masses using up to 56 free parameters, including high-order (NNNLO) analytic terms to match the increased data precision.
  • Quenched Comparison: Analysis of "quenched" data (ignoring vacuum quark fluctuations) served as a control to test the robustness of S$\chi$PT in describing lattice artifacts.

Results and Discussion

By introducing data with varying strange sea-quark masses ($m'_s$), the authors successfully decoupled sea-quark mass dependence from lattice spacing effects. A critical finding was that quenched results for $f_\pi$ diverged significantly from experimental values after continuum extrapolation, reinforcing the necessity of dynamical quark simulations for high-precision physics.

Chiral extrapolation for the pion decay constant $f_\pi$.
Chiral extrapolation for the kaon decay constant $f_K$.

The study yielded several high-precision preliminary values:

  • Decay Constants: $f_\pi = 128.1 \pm 0.5 (\text{stat}) \pm 2.8 (\text{syst})$ MeV and $f_K = 153.5 \pm 0.5 (\text{stat}) \pm 2.9 (\text{syst})$ MeV.
  • Ratio: $f_K/f_\pi = 1.198(3)(^{+16}_{-5})$, a vital input for CKM matrix constraints.
  • CKM Matrix Element: The extracted $|V_{us}| = 0.2242(^{+11}_{-31})$ is consistent with world averages and provides a competitive alternative to traditional experimental methods.
  • Lattice Scale: The $r_1$ physical length was refined to $0.318(7)$ fm.

Conclusion and Future Work

While these results represent a significant step forward, several "fine" lattice runs with very light quarks were only partially complete at the time of publication. Completing these will further reduce statistical errors. Additionally, the observed divergence in the quenched theory for $f_K$ in the chiral limit indicates that even finer lattice spacings are required to fully understand non-physical behaviors. The collaboration plans to leverage these refined light-quark parameters to improve calculations in the heavy-quark sector (B and D mesons), where systematic errors currently remain a bottleneck.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present an update of the MILC studies of the physics of light pseudoscalars using improved staggered fermions. New runs at lighter quark mass, as well as increased statistics for older sets, are enabling us to improve the results for decay constants in full QCD. In addition, we have analyzed quenched runs at two different lattice spacings. This makes possible a test of the applicability of staggered chiral perturbation theory in a different context.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2005update,
  author = {MILC Collaboration and C. Bernard and Pietro Butti and Steven Gottlieb and Urs M. Heller and J. E. Hetrick and L. Levkova and F. Maresca and J. D. Osborn and Dru B. Renner and Robert Sugar and D. Toussaint},
  title = {{Update on pi and K Physics}},
  year = {2005},
  eprint = {hep-lat/0509137},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/0509137},
}
Figure