Effects of sound source visibility on sound perception in living room environment

kang ki sun, Bert De Coensel, Gemma Sánchez, Timothy Van Renterghem, Dick BotteldoorenGhent 2016

Abstract

Due to urban sprawl and rural urbanization, an increasing number of dwellings and offices are subjected to high levels of traffic noise, which might disturb people's daily life and activities, ultimately leading to noise annoyance. Although the relation between sound exposure and noise annoyance has been investigated thoroughly during the last decades, the influence of visual factors on sound perception is not completely understood. In this paper, the effects of sound source visibility on sound perception in living room environment are studied. For this purpose, 4 window-sight video sceneries, which contain a mixture of different nature and man-made landscape elements are combined with different sound levels and presented to the participants in the experiment in a mockup living room using a surround system and a large television screen. To explore individual differences in attention focusing, a series of scenarios, in which either the audio or visual parts of the videos are subtly altered are used. Results of the experiment are used to investigate the mechanisms explaining the influence of sound source visibility on audiovisual perception.

Introduction

As urban sprawl intensifies, more people are living in "noise-polluted" environments. While decibel levels are known to correlate with annoyance, the "cross-modal" effects—how visual stimuli influence auditory perception—remain under-explored. Sound perception is not merely a physical phenomenon but a psychological one influenced by attention. This study investigates whether seeing a noise source, such as a highway, makes the noise feel more intrusive compared to when the source is obscured by greenery. The goal is to quantify the "visual bonus" or penalty to assist in urban design that improves inhabitant well-being.

Experimental Methodology

The researchers established a controlled "mockup living room" at Ghent University to simulate a realistic domestic environment.

Mockup living room setup including (a) interior view and (b) floor plan.

The setup featured:

  • The "Window": A 60-inch television integrated into a wall cabinet to simulate an external view.
  • The Soundscape: A surround sound system with hidden speakers and a subwoofer reproduced traffic noise, including low-frequency rumbles.
  • Experimental Design: Participants visited the room four times. Each session presented a different video scenery paired with the same four audio tracks (simulating single, double, and triple-glazed windows at 45, 50, 55, and 60 dB(A)). Participants were led to believe the sounds varied daily, while only the visual scenery changed, allowing researchers to isolate visual impact.

Visual and Acoustic Stimuli

The study utilized four distinct visual sceneries recorded in Ghent, Belgium, to represent varying degrees of sound source visibility and natural elements.

The four visual sceneries used in the experiment: (a) open highway, (b) partial greenery, (c) full greenery, and (d) traditional buildings.

Acoustic profiles were created by recording traffic noise in B-format and applying frequency attenuation curves that represent real-world window insulation standards.

Key Insights and Results

The preliminary findings highlight several critical aspects of audiovisual perception:

  • The Attention Trap: Scenery (a)—the open highway—naturally draws the eye to the moving sound source. This visual "lock-on" makes it harder for the brain to ignore the noise, effectively increasing annoyance.
  • Greenery and Attention: While "green" elements generally reduce annoyance, partial concealment (Scenery B) might actually increase focus on the noise as participants attempt to "spot" the source through the foliage.
  • Subconscious Dominance: Visual systems often dominate environmental perception. A "tranquil" visual scene can subconsciously lower the perceived "loudness" or annoyance, even when sound levels are identical.
  • Statistical Significance: The view from the window had a significant effect on the relationship between sound exposure and annoyance. Scenery (a) attracted the most attention to the sound source, while Sceneries (c) and (d) resulted in the lowest attention to noise.

Conclusion and Future Work

This pilot study demonstrates that sound source visibility significantly alters noise annoyance levels. Future research aims to complete the study with a larger participant pool to quantify the "noise reduction equivalent" of a high-quality view—essentially determining the decibel value of a forest view. Additionally, researchers plan to investigate individual differences in "attention focusing" to see if certain individuals are more susceptible to visual influence on their auditory environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Due to urban sprawl and rural urbanization, an increasing number of dwellings and offices are subjected to high levels of traffic noise, which might disturb people's daily life and activities, ultimately leading to noise annoyance. Although the relation between sound exposure and noise annoyance has been investigated thoroughly during the last decades, the influence of visual factors on sound perception is not completely understood. In this paper, the effects of sound source visibility on sound perception in living room environment are studied. For this purpose, 4 window-sight video sceneries, which contain a mixture of different nature and man-made landscape elements are combined with different sound levels and presented to the participants in the experiment in a mockup living room using a surround system and a large television screen. To explore individual differences in attention focusing, a series of scenarios, in which either the audio or visual parts of the videos are subtly altered are used. Results of the experiment are used to investigate the mechanisms explaining the influence of sound source visibility on audiovisual perception.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2016effects,
  author = {kang ki sun and Bert De Coensel and Gemma Sánchez and Timothy Van Renterghem and Dick Botteldooren},
  title = {{Effects of sound source visibility on sound perception in living room environment}},
  booktitle = {Ghent},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure