Abstract
This study analyzes the relationship between visual landscape and soundscape factors in the public spaces of old residential areas and their attention restoration benefits. Using virtual reality (VR) environments, subjective evaluations, and attention testing in six typical sites in Tianjin, China, the research demonstrates that central squares offer superior restoration compared to street-side spaces. Key factors such as greenery satisfaction, environmental cleanliness, and soundscape pleasantness significantly correlate with restoration levels. A structural equation model reveals that while both visual and auditory factors contribute to mental recovery, visual elements exert a more substantial influence.
Introduction: Addressing Urban Mental Fatigue
Urban residents frequently experience "directed attention fatigue" (DAF) due to the constant cognitive demands of city environments. While Attention Restoration Theory (ART) posits that natural settings facilitate recovery, less is known about the restorative potential of "old residential areas"—neighborhoods built before 2000 characterized by high density and aging infrastructure. This research quantifies how the visual and auditory layers of these specific urban typologies impact mental recovery, offering data-driven insights for urban renewal.
Methodology: VR Immersion and Attention Testing
The study utilized a multi-stage experimental design:
- Site Selection: Six sites in Tianjin were chosen: three central squares (R1–R3) and three roadside public spaces (R4–R6).
- Data Capture: 360-degree 5.6K video and 4-channel binaural audio were recorded to create immersive digital twins.
- Stress Induction: 200 participants completed a 25-minute English listening test to induce mental fatigue.
- VR Exposure: Participants spent 3 minutes immersed in one of the six VR scenes.
- Measurement: Attention restoration was measured using Schultz Tables (number-finding tasks) before and after exposure. The metric $\Delta At$ (time difference) indicated the level of restoration.
Key Findings: The Power of Place
A critical discovery was the stark difference in restorative capacity between space types. Central squares (R1–R3) successfully facilitated recovery, shortening task completion times by an average of 2.0 seconds. Conversely, roadside spaces (R4–R6) actually increased completion times by 0.8 seconds, suggesting that poor-quality urban environments can exacerbate mental fatigue rather than alleviate it.
Subjective evaluations further highlighted that greenery satisfaction had the strongest positive correlation with restoration (0.358), followed by soundscape pleasantness (0.288). Interestingly, environmental cleanliness was found to improve the perception of quietness, indicating that physical order reduces "mental noise."
Modeling the Restorative Experience
To understand the complex interplay of these factors, the researchers constructed a Structural Equation Model (SEM). The model confirmed that both visual landscape and soundscape factors directly impact attention restoration.
The SEM revealed that visual factors (path coefficient 0.372) have a significantly greater impact on restoration than soundscape factors (0.176). This suggests that in resource-constrained urban renewal projects, prioritizing visual improvements—specifically greenery—may yield the highest mental health benefits for residents.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The study provides a framework for designing restorative urban spaces. While central squares are inherently more restorative, their effectiveness is heavily dependent on high-quality visual and auditory features.
Future research should address current limitations, such as the focus on college-aged participants and data collection during autumn/winter. Investigating the needs of elderly residents and the seasonal variability of greenery will be essential for a comprehensive understanding of urban attention restoration.
Summary updated