Examining the audiovisual therapy effects on hospital groups of varying linear canopy landscapes and those with hydrodynamic forces

Ping Zhang, Yixin Cui, Ke Luo, Tongyao Zhang, Yanbin Yang, Jinpeng Li, Mingze Chen, Hao Chen, Qianyi He, Yu Zheng, Guangyu Wang, Xiaohua Wang, W. Grace Guo, Xi Li, Jun MaFrontiers in Public Health 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Recent research has highlighted the beneficial effects of urban green spaces on physical and mental health. This study focused on the hospital population and innovatively subdivided the population into four groups: doctors, caregivers, patients, and nurses. A total of 96 volunteers participated in this virtual reality experiment to assess the restoration of a linear canopy landscape and a landscape with different levels of hydrodynamics through interactive audiovisual immersion. Utilizing brainwave monitoring, psychological scales, and qualitative interviews, the research identified that linear canopy landscapes and those with low to medium hydrodynamic forces significantly enhance physiological and psychological restoration. This study advocates for the integration of natural blue and green elements into hospital environments as complementary therapeutic interventions.

Introduction

Hospitals are inherently high-stress environments. Overworked medical staff, anxious patients, and exhausted caregivers often lack the time or physical mobility to access restorative natural spaces. While the health benefits of nature are well-documented via Attention Restoration Theory (ART) and Stress Reduction Theory (SRT), granular data on which specific landscape features—such as canopy density or water flow—provide the most relief for different hospital subgroups has been lacking. This study bridges that gap by using Virtual Reality (VR) as a proxy for nature, testing how specific "audiovisual doses" of forest and water affect recovery.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a controlled VR experiment with 96 participants, categorized into four distinct groups: doctors, nurses, patients, and caregivers.

Map of data collection points in Jiuzhaigou Valley and the broader regional context.

Stimulus Creation and Variables

Using 360-degree panoramic videos captured in the Jiuzhaigou Valley, the team developed six distinct landscape scenarios. To ensure scientific precision, the ADE20K semantic segmentation model was employed to quantify the ratios of trees, sky, and water in each scene. The variables focused on:

  • Linear Canopy: The tree-to-sky ratio.
  • Hydrodynamic Forces: The sound and visual flow of water, ranging from 30dB to 70dB.
Example panoramic images used as VR stimuli, showing varying canopy densities and water features.

Measurement Tools

Restoration was measured through a multi-modal approach:

  • Physiological: Heart rate (HR), blood pressure (BP), and electroencephalogram (EEG) monitoring of theta, alpha, and beta brainwaves.
  • Psychological: Validated scales including the Self-Rating Restoration Scale (SRS) and the Anxiety Measurement Scale (AMS).
  • Qualitative: Semi-structured interviews and eye-tracking observation.

Key Findings

1. Role-Specific Restoration

The study revealed that different groups respond uniquely to environmental stimuli. Caregivers experienced the most significant psychological relief, likely due to the emotional nature of their stress. Conversely, doctors and patients showed the most substantial physiological improvements, including significant drops in heart rate and blood pressure.

2. The Vitality of Water

Landscapes with medium hydrodynamic forces (51–70 dB water sounds) were found to be more effective than those with low forces. Researchers suggest that individuals in hospital settings, often surrounded by illness, have a subconscious desire for the "vitality" represented by active, moving water.

3. The Canopy Density Paradox

While dense forests are traditionally viewed as highly aesthetic, patients in this study preferred medium-to-low density canopies. High-density foliage can feel oppressive in a clinical context, whereas open skies and light foliage trigger feelings of prosperity and intimacy.

4. Physiological Impact

  • Heart Rate: Doctors’ heart rates decreased by an average of 7.625 bpm.
  • Blood Pressure: Patients saw a significant drop in diastolic blood pressure (12.62 mmHg).
  • Brainwaves: Exposure led to a notable increase in alpha and theta waves, indicating a shift from high-stress alertness to deep relaxation and "flow" states.

Discussion and Conclusion

Surprisingly, the inclusion of bird songs did not markedly affect physiological restoration across most groups, suggesting that the visual landscape and the sound of water are the primary drivers of recovery for high-stress populations. Landscapes incorporating elements of water dynamics, open skies, and lightly foliated canopies drew the most significant interest.

This research advocates for "blue-green" VR interventions as a low-cost, accessible adjunct therapy. By integrating these natural elements into hospital design or providing them via immersive technology, healthcare facilities can better support the mental and physical health of their entire community.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent research has highlighted the beneficial effects of urban green spaces on physical and mental health. This study focused on the hospital population and innovatively subdivided the population into four groups: doctors, caregivers, patients and nurses. A total of 96 volunteers participated in this virtual reality experiment to assess the restoration of a linear canopy landscape and a landscape with different levels of hydrodynamics through interactive audiovisual immersion. We utilized pre-research method, brainwave monitoring technique, psychological scales, observation and interviews in this experiment. The research identified five key findings. First, both linear canopy landscapes and those with low to medium hydrodynamic forces significantly enhance physiological and psychological restoration for all groups, with the most substantial physiological benefits observed in doctors and patients, and the greatest psychological relief noted in caregivers. Second, landscapes with medium hydrodynamic forces yield higher restorative effects than those with low forces in hospital settings. Third, green landscapes with medium and low-density canopies prove more conducive to patient recovery compared to those with high-density canopies. Fourth, the inclusion of bird songs does not markedly affect physiological restoration across the hospital groups. Finally, landscapes that incorporate elements of water dynamics, open skies, and lightly foliated canopies draw significant interest from all groups involved. This study advocates for the integration of natural blue and green elements into hospital environments as complementary therapeutic interventions, aiming to alleviate stress and promote health recovery among hospital communities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024examining,
  author = {Ping Zhang and Yixin Cui and Ke Luo and Tongyao Zhang and Yanbin Yang and Jinpeng Li and Mingze Chen and Hao Chen and Qianyi He and Yu Zheng and Guangyu Wang and Xiaohua Wang and W. Grace Guo and Xi Li and Jun Ma},
  title = {{Examining the audiovisual therapy effects on hospital groups of varying linear canopy landscapes and those with hydrodynamic forces}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2024.1324260},
}
Figure