Case-study evaluation of a low and vegetated noise barrier in an urban public space

Maria Rådsten-Ekman, Bruno Vincent, Céline Anselme, Agnès Mandon, René Rohr, Jérôme Defrance, Dirk Van Maercke, Dick Botteldooren, Mats E. NilssonGhent 2011

Abstract

To improve the sound environment along a popular esplanade in Lyon, France, a 1-meter-high vegetated noise barrier was installed to mitigate noise from an adjacent busy road. This case study evaluates the barrier's performance through physical acoustic measurements and psychoacoustic surveys of 349 pedestrians. While the barrier achieved a significant 5 dB reduction in sound levels and doubled the perceived sound quality, the environment remained "annoying" to many, highlighting the limitations of low-height interventions in high-traffic urban areas.

Introduction

Urban planners face a persistent challenge: mitigating the health-eroding effects of traffic noise while maintaining the aesthetic and social appeal of public spaces. Traditional noise barriers—often tall, concrete, or transparent walls—can be visually intrusive or create "canyon" effects that disconnect pedestrians from their surroundings. This study investigates whether a "low and vegetated" barrier can provide a meaningful improvement in both acoustic performance (decibel reduction) and psychoacoustic perception (how people feel about the sound).

Methods

The researchers employed a "before-and-after" experimental design at a popular esplanade in Lyon. The intervention consisted of a barrier 14m long, 1m high, and 40cm thick, featuring a metallic frame filled with substrate and planted with 40 plants per square meter on both sides.

Acoustic measurements and surveys were conducted at two locations: Spot A (directly behind the barrier) and Spot B (20 meters to the side, acting as an unprotected control). A total of 349 pedestrians completed questionnaires assessing the environment across eight attributes (e.g., Pleasant, Chaotic, Calm, Annoying) and road-traffic annoyance on a five-point scale.

Experimental setup showing the esplanade with the vegetated barrier (left) and the unprotected control area (right).

Key Results and Insights

Acoustic Performance

The barrier successfully reduced the sound pressure level from approximately 67 dB to 62 dB (LAeq) at a distance of 3.5m from the road. In acoustics, a 5 dB drop is considered significant, as 3 dB is the smallest change perceptible to the human ear. However, because the barrier was only 1 meter high, its effectiveness was limited by "diffraction," where sound waves bend over the top of the structure, primarily protecting pedestrians in a sitting position.

Psychoacoustic Perception

The study found that the barrier's impact was most noticeable when pedestrians could immediately compare the protected and unprotected areas (within-subject analysis).

  • Annoyance Reduction: The proportion of respondents who felt "extremely" or "very" annoyed by traffic dropped from 63% to 47% behind the barrier.
  • Quality Improvement: The percentage of people rating the sound environment as "good" or "very good" doubled from 10% to 20%.
  • Attribute Shifts: Statistically significant improvements were observed in "pleasantness" and "calmness," alongside a decrease in perceived "annoyance" when moving behind the barrier.
Attribute difference scale showing significant improvements in perceived pleasantness, calmness, and peacefulness at Spot A compared to Spot B after barrier installation.

The "Better but Not Good" Threshold

Despite these improvements, the environment remained challenging. While the barrier made the space "better," it did not necessarily make it "good." The researchers noted an "aesthetic buffering" effect, where the visual presence of greenery likely contributed to the feeling of calmness by hiding the visual chaos of traffic, even when noise levels remained relatively high.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that a 1m barrier is quite low for substantial acoustic shielding. Furthermore, it is difficult to isolate the acoustic benefit from the visual benefit of the vegetation. Future work will involve laboratory listening experiments using binaural recordings to more precisely quantify the psychoacoustic impact in a controlled environment and correlate individual survey responses with specific momentary acoustic conditions.

Conclusion

Low and vegetated noise barriers offer a promising tool for urban planners to improve the quality of public spaces without the negative impacts of traditional tall barriers. While they may not transform a noisy roadside into a quiet sanctuary, they provide a perceptible and psychologically significant improvement in pedestrian comfort.

Summary updated

Abstract

To improve the sound environment along a popular esplanade in Lyon, France, a 1 m high vegetated noise barrier was erected to protect against noise from an adjacent road. The barrier was made of a ...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{radstenekman2011case,
  author = {Maria Rådsten-Ekman and Bruno Vincent and Céline Anselme and Agnès Mandon and René Rohr and Jérôme Defrance and Dirk Van Maercke and Dick Botteldooren and Mats E. Nilsson},
  title = {{Case-study evaluation of a low and vegetated noise barrier in an urban public space}},
  booktitle = {Ghent},
  year = {2011},
}
Figure