Doping a spin-orbit Mott Insulator: Topological Superconductivity from the Kitaev-Heisenberg Model and possible application to (Na2/Li2)IrO3

Yi‐Zhuang You, Itamar Kimchi, Ashvin Vishwanath

Abstract

We study the effects of doping a Mott insulator on the honeycomb lattice where spins interact via direction dependent Kitaev couplings $J_K$, and weak antiferromagnetic Heisenberg couplings $J$. This model is known to have a spin liquid ground state and may potentially be realized in correlated insulators with strong spin orbit coupling. The effect of hole doping is studied within a $t-J-J_K$ model, treated using the $SU(2)$ slave boson formulation, which correctly captures the parent spin liquid. We find superconductor ground states with spin triplet pairing that spontaneously break time reversal symmetry. Interestingly, the pairing is qualitatively different at low and high dopings, and undergoes a first order transition with doping. At high dopings, it is smoothly connected to a paired state of electrons propagating with the underlying free particle dispersion. However, at low dopings the dispersion is strongly influenced by the magnetic exchange, and is entirely different from the free particle band structure. Here the superconductivity is fully gapped and topological, analogous to spin polarized electrons with $p_x+ip_y$ pairing. These results may be relevant to honeycomb lattice iridates such as $A_2IrO_3$ ($A=Li$ or $Na$) on doping.

Introduction

In condensed matter physics, Mott insulators are materials that should conduct electricity according to standard theory but don't because of strong electron-electron repulsions. When these insulators also have strong spin-orbit coupling (SOC), they can host exotic magnetic states like the "Kitaev spin liquid." While the insulating properties of these materials are well-studied, a major open question is: What happens when we dope them with holes? In high-temperature superconductors (like cuprates), doping a Mott insulator leads to d-wave superconductivity. This study investigates if the unique, direction-dependent interactions of the Kitaev model lead to even more exotic superconducting states, specifically those with topological properties useful for quantum computing.

The honeycomb lattice model with direction-dependent Kitaev bonds (a) and the corresponding Brillouin zone (b).

Theoretical Framework

The authors model the system using a $t-J-J_K$ model on a honeycomb lattice. This model accounts for electron hopping ($t$), standard Heisenberg antiferromagnetic exchange ($J$), and anisotropic Kitaev exchange ($J_K$). To solve this, they employ the $SU(2)$ slave boson formalism, which mathematically "splits" an electron into a spinon (carrying spin) and a holon (carrying charge). This approach naturally captures the physics of the parent spin liquid state. They also use Projective Symmetry Group (PSG) analysis to classify possible phases and ensure consistency with lattice symmetries.

Key Insights

A central finding is "Spin-Gauge Locking": the quantum order of the Kitaev spin liquid locks spin and gauge degrees of freedom together. Consequently, when holons condense (leading to superconductivity), the resulting electron pairing is forced to be purely spin-triplet.

The paper identifies two distinct superconducting regimes:

  1. $SC_1$ (Low Doping): Dominated by magnetic exchange, where electronic dispersion differs significantly from free electrons.
  2. $SC_2$ (High Doping): Dominated by kinetic energy, behaving more like a conventional triplet BCS superconductor.

Notably, this system spontaneously breaks time-reversal symmetry upon entering the superconducting state. The low-doping $SC_1$ phase is a topological superconductor with a non-zero Chern number ($C=1$), making it a Majorana version of the Haldane model, featuring chiral edge states and Majorana zero modes.

Results and Phase Diagram

The study maps out a temperature-vs-doping phase diagram, illustrating the transition from a Kitaev Spin Liquid (KL) to the $SC_1$ phase, and eventually to a Fermi Liquid (FL) or $SC_2$ phase at higher dopings.

Phase diagram as a function of temperature $T/J_K$ and doping $\delta t/J_K$, showing the various phases including the topological $SC_1$ state.

The $SC_1$ phase is fully gapped, with the gap arising from a third-order perturbation process where Majorana fermions "hop" around the honeycomb lattice, creating a topological mass term. These results are specifically linked to honeycomb iridates like $Na_2IrO_3$ and $Li_2IrO_3$. The authors estimate a maximum superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) of roughly 15–20 K, assuming a Kitaev coupling ($J_K$) of about 100–150 K.

Discussion and Future Directions

While the model focuses on nearest-neighbor interactions, real materials like $Li_2IrO_3$ likely have further-neighbor interactions that could complicate the phase diagram. Additionally, doping these specific iridate materials in a controlled way remains a significant experimental challenge. The slave boson approach is a mean-field theory; fluctuations in 2D could lower the predicted $T_c$. Future research should seek experimental signatures of broken time-reversal symmetry and predicted Majorana edge states in doped iridates.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the effects of doping a Mott insulator on the honeycomb lattice where spins interact via direction dependent Kitaev couplings J_K, and weak antiferromagnetic Heisenberg couplings J. This model is known to have a spin liquid ground state and may potentially be realized in correlated insulators with strong spin orbit coupling. The effect of hole doping is studied within a t-J-J_K model, treated using the SU(2) slave boson formulation, which correctly captures the parent spin liquid. We find superconductor ground states with spin triplet pairing that spontaneously break time reversal symmetry. Interestingly, the pairing is qualitatively different at low and high dopings, and undergoes a first order transition with doping. At high dopings, it is smoothly connected to a paired state of electrons propagating with the underlying free particle dispersion. However, at low dopings the dispersion is strongly influenced by the magnetic exchange, and is entirely different from the free particle band structure. Here the superconductivity is fully gapped and topological, analogous to spin polarized electrons with px+ipy pairing. These results may be relevant to honeycomb lattice iridates such as A2IrO3 (A=Li or Na) on doping.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{you2012doping,
  author = {Yi‐Zhuang You and Itamar Kimchi and Ashvin Vishwanath},
  title = {{Doping a spin-orbit Mott Insulator: Topological Superconductivity from the Kitaev-Heisenberg Model and possible application to (Na2/Li2)IrO3}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.86.085145},
}
Figure