Abstract
We study the effects of doping a Mott insulator on the honeycomb lattice where spins interact via direction-dependent Kitaev couplings $J_K$, and weak antiferromagnetic Heisenberg couplings $J$. This model is known to have a spin-liquid ground state and may potentially be realized in correlated insulators with strong spin-orbit coupling. The effect of hole doping is studied within a $t-J-J_K$ model, treated using the SU(2) slave boson formalism, which correctly captures the parent spin liquid. We find superconductor ground states with spin triplet pairing that spontaneously break time-reversal symmetry. Interestingly, the pairing is qualitatively different at low and high dopings, and undergoes a first-order transition with doping. At high dopings, it is smoothly connected to a paired state of electrons propagating with the underlying free particle dispersion. However, at low dopings the dispersion is strongly influenced by the magnetic exchange, and is entirely different from the free-particle band structure. Here the superconductivity is fully gapped and topological, analogous to spin polarized electrons with $p_x+ip_y$ pairing. These results may be relevant to honeycomb lattice iridates such as $A_2IrO_3$ ($A$ = Li or Na) on doping.
Introduction
In condensed matter physics, doping a Mott insulator—a material that should conduct electricity but remains insulating due to strong electron-electron repulsion—is a classic recipe for discovering high-temperature superconductivity. While most studied Mott insulators are governed by simple Heisenberg exchange, this research explores Spin-Orbit Mott Insulators like the honeycomb iridates ($Na_2IrO_3$). In these materials, strong spin-orbit coupling leads to direction-dependent "Kitaev interactions." The undoped version of this model is a quantum spin liquid; this paper investigates whether adding mobile charge carriers (holes) to this state triggers superconductivity and how the underlying quantum order shapes the resulting phase.
Theoretical Framework and Methods
The authors employ a $t-J-J_K$ model on a honeycomb lattice, solved using the SU(2) slave boson formalism. This sophisticated technique treats the electron as a composite of two fictional particles: a spinon (carrying spin) and a holon (carrying charge).
This approach is uniquely suited to capture the fractionalized nature of the parent Kitaev spin liquid. To ensure the model respects physical constraints, the authors utilize Projective Symmetry Group (PSG) analysis to classify how these fractionalized particles transform under lattice symmetries.
Key Insights: Spin-Gauge Locking and Topological Phases
A primary discovery is the concept of spin-gauge locking: in the Kitaev spin liquid, spin rotations and gauge rotations are mathematically coupled. Consequently, when the charge-carrying holons condense to form a superconductor, they must spontaneously break time-reversal symmetry.
The study identifies a first-order phase transition between two distinct superconducting regimes:
- SC1 (Low Doping): A "magnetic" phase dictated by Kitaev exchange. It is fully gapped and topological, behaving like a Majorana version of the Haldane model.
- SC2 (High Doping): A "kinetic" phase where the electrons' movement dominates. This is a more conventional, though still spin-triplet, superconductor.
Because the SC1 phase is topological (with a Chern number of +1), it is predicted to host chiral edge states and isolated Majorana zero modes in its vortex cores—key components for topological quantum computing.
Key Results and Experimental Predictions
The authors mapped a comprehensive phase diagram showing the transition from a Kitaev Spin Liquid (KL) to a Fermi Liquid (FL), and the emergence of the SC1 and SC2 phases as a function of temperature and doping ($\delta$).
For iridates like $A_2IrO_3$, the authors estimate a superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) of roughly 15–20 K. While these materials currently exhibit magnetic order, they are "proximate" to the spin liquid phase, suggesting that doping could successfully trigger these exotic topological states.
Limitations and Future Work
The results rely on mean-field theory, which may ignore certain fluctuations important in 2D materials. Additionally, real-world iridates have complexities like trigonal distortions and further-neighbor interactions omitted here for clarity. Experimentally doping these specific honeycomb iridates without destroying the crystal structure remains a significant chemical challenge for future verification of these predictions.
Summary updated