Does corruption produce unsafe drivers

Marianne Bertrand, Simeon Djankov, Rema Hanna, Sendhil Mullainathan

TL;DR

This paper uses a randomized controlled trial in New Delhi to demonstrate that corruption in driver licensing doesn't just "grease the wheels" of bureaucracy—it completely subverts the social goal of road safety. By tracking applicants, the authors found that while the system is responsive to those who pay for speed, it is almost entirely indifferent to actual driving skill, resulting in a flood of licensed but dangerously unqualified drivers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Economists have long debated whether corruption is a "grease" or a "sand" in the gears of development. The "grease the wheels" hypothesis suggests that bribes allow individuals to bypass inefficient "red tape," potentially increasing economic efficiency. Conversely, the "sand" view argues that corruption undermines essential regulations and encourages bureaucrats to create even more hurdles to extract bribes.

The authors test these theories in the context of obtaining a driver’s license in India. The core question is: Does the corrupt system merely help people get licenses faster (an administrative shortcut), or does it allow people who cannot drive to get on the road (a failure of safety regulation)?

Methods

The researchers conducted a field experiment with 822 license applicants in New Delhi, randomly assigning them to one of three groups:

  1. Bonus Group: Offered a large financial reward (roughly 1/3 of an average monthly salary) if they could obtain their license within 31 days. This tested the bureaucracy's sensitivity to an individual's "willingness to pay" for speed.
  2. Lesson Group: Offered free, high-quality driving lessons. This tested whether the bureaucracy rewards actual skill.
  3. Comparison Group: A control group that received no special incentives or training.

Crucially, the researchers administered a surprise independent road test to all participants after they obtained their licenses to measure their actual driving ability, regardless of whether they passed the official government test. They also conducted an audit study, sending trained actors to "agents" (intermediaries) to see which rules could be bent and at what price.

Datasets

The study relies on a primary dataset collected by the International Finance Corporation (IFC) between 2004 and 2005. It includes:

  • Socioeconomic data: Demographics, income, and past driving experience.
  • Process logs: Detailed tracking of every trip to the Regional Transport Office (RTO), time spent, number of officials spoken to, and total expenditures.
  • Experimental outcomes: Official licensing status and the results of the independent "surprise" road test.
  • Audit data: Quotes and feasibility reports from 224 private agents in New Delhi.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Endogenous Red Tape: Bureaucrats don't just wait for bribes; they actively create "red tape" to force applicants into the corrupt system. The authors found that bureaucrats arbitrarily fail applicants on the official driving test—even those who are demonstrably good drivers—to encourage them to hire "agents."
  • The "Agent" System as a Buffer: Corruption in New Delhi isn't a direct hand-off of cash to an official. Instead, it's mediated by a professionalized system of agents. These agents handle the bribes, which minimizes the risk of detection for the bureaucrat and the "hassle" for the applicant.
  • Verifiability is the Constraint: The audit study revealed that bureaucrats can't bend every rule. They are strict about things that are easily "verifiable" by their superiors, like age or residency documents. However, they easily bypass driving tests because a supervisor cannot easily verify if a 5-minute road test actually happened or was performed well.
  • Indifference to Skill: The most striking insight is that the system is almost entirely "skill-blind." Being a better driver does not significantly increase your chances of getting a license through the official channels.

Key Results

  • Speed vs. Safety: The Bonus group got their licenses 40% faster and at a 28% higher rate than the control group. However, they were terrible drivers: 69% of them failed the surprise independent driving test.
  • Skill doesn't pay: Participants in the Lesson group became much better drivers (only 11% failed the surprise test), yet they were no more likely to get a license than the comparison group.
  • Bypassing the Exam: Among those who used an agent, only 12% actually took the official driving test. In contrast, 94% of those who didn't use an agent were forced to take the test.
  • The Cost of Corruption: On average, participants paid Rs 1,127 to get a license—more than double the official fee of Rs 450. Most of this extra cost went to agents.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few limitations:

  • Selective Attrition: Some participants dropped out of the study, particularly in the comparison and lesson groups. While the authors provide statistical bounds to show this doesn't invalidate the results, it is a common challenge in field experiments.
  • External Validity: The study is specific to the institutional environment of New Delhi in the mid-2000s. The "agent" system might look different in other countries or regulatory sectors.
  • Future Directions: The paper opens the door for research into how to design "corruption-proof" regulations. If verifiability is the main constraint on corruption, can we improve safety outcomes by making the testing process more transparent or technologically verifiable (e.g., using dashcams or automated testing tracks)?

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We follow 822 applicants through the process of obtaining a driver’s license in New Delhi, India. To understand how the bureaucracy responds to individual and social needs, participants were randomly assigned to one of three groups: bonus, lesson, and comparison groups. Participants in the bonus group were offered a financial reward if they could obtain their license fast; participants in the lesson group were offered free driving lessons. To gauge driving skills, we performed a surprise driving test after participants had obtained their licenses. Several interesting facts regarding corruption emerge. First, the bureaucracy responds to individual needs. Those who want their license faster (e.g. the bonus group), get it 40 % faster and at a 20 % higher rate. Second, the bureaucracy is insensitive to social needs. The bonus group does not learn to drive safely in order to obtain their license: in fact, 69 % of them were rated as “failures ” on the independent driving test. Those in the lesson group, despite superior driving skills, are only slightly more likely to obtain a license than the comparison group and far less likely (by 29 percentage points) than the bonus group. Detailed surveys allow us to document the mechanisms of corruption. We find that bureaucrats arbitrarily fail drivers at a high rate during the driving exam, irrespective of their ability to drive. To overcome this, individuals pay informal “agents ” to bribe the bureaucrat and avoid taking the exam altogether. An audit study of agents further highlights the insensitivity of agents ’ pricing to driving skills. Together, these results
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bertrand2006does,
  author = {Marianne Bertrand and Simeon Djankov and Rema Hanna and Sendhil Mullainathan},
  title = {{Does corruption produce unsafe drivers}},
  booktitle = {Natural},
  year = {2006},
}

Loading related content...

Figure