Abstract
The presented literature review is devoted to such a pressing problem as distal radius fracture. The relevance of the review is due to the high prevalence and increasing frequency of this type of fractures, as well as a large number of controversies accompanying almost every aspect of this pathology. Despite the impressive amount of data devoted to distal radius fractures, modern scientific literature shows the absence of generally accepted algorithms for the treatment of this pathology of the upper extremity. The overwhelming majority of scientific articles on this problem have a low degree of scientific evidence. All this suggests the need for further studies with sufficient scientific evidence, primarily randomized controlled trials. Systematization and comprehension of the already known information are equally important, and this review is devoted to it. This review is analytical in nature and was conducted using medical literature databases and search resources PubMed (MEDLINE), Google Scholar and eLibrary. The following aspects are covered: anatomy, diagnosis, classification, conservative and surgical treatment, and postoperative management of fractures of the distal metaepiphysis of the radius. Special attention is paid to various surgical treatment techniques, and the advantages and disadvantages of the most common surgical methods are described.
Introduction
Distal radius fractures (DRF) represent one of the most frequent injuries encountered in orthopedic practice, accounting for a significant portion of emergency department visits. Nearly half of these injuries occur in the active, working-age population, yet the medical community still lacks a definitive "gold standard" for treatment. This review synthesizes current literature to address the controversies surrounding classification, diagnostic protocols, and the choice between conservative and surgical management.
Anatomical Considerations and Diagnostics
A key development in surgical planning is the "three-column model" (radial, intermediate, and ulnar), which allows for fragment-specific fixation. Central to successful surgical outcomes is the recognition of the "Watershed Line" (WS).
As shown in Figure 2, the Watershed Line is a critical anatomical landmark. Hardware protruding beyond this line significantly increases the risk of flexor tendon irritation or rupture. Furthermore, while standard radiography remains the first-line diagnostic tool, the review emphasizes that Computed Tomography (CT) is essential for intra-articular fractures. X-rays often underestimate joint surface displacement; given that displacement exceeding 2mm is strongly associated with post-traumatic arthrosis, CT is non-negotiable for accurate preoperative planning.
Treatment Modalities and Surgical Trends
There has been a marked global shift toward internal fixation. The rate of surgical intervention for DRFs rose from approximately 8.75% in 2005 to over 20% by 2014. Volar plating has emerged as a preferred method due to better hardware tolerance compared to dorsal plates, which often require removal due to tendon irritation.
Meta-analyses indicate that patients treated with volar plates (Figure 4) typically achieve better functional scores and grip strength in the early postoperative period (3 to 6 months) compared to those treated with percutaneous pinning. However, a "long-term leveling effect" is observed: at one and five years post-injury, the functional differences between various surgical methods—and even conservative treatment in specific cohorts—largely disappear.
Clinical Outcomes and Complications
The choice of treatment must be tailored to the patient profile. For elderly patients (over 65), conservative management (closed reduction and casting) often yields functional results comparable to surgery but with a significantly lower complication rate. Conversely, while percutaneous pinning is a cost-effective surgical alternative, it carries a higher risk of superficial pin-tract infections compared to internal plating.
Despite the technological advancement in plating systems, the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) notes that no single surgical method has been proven definitively superior in long-term follow-ups. This highlights an "evidence paradox" where increased surgical complexity does not always correlate with superior long-term patient-reported outcomes.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The primary challenge in managing DRFs remains the lack of high-quality Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs). Current decision-making is often based on retrospective data or clinical tradition. Future research should focus on:
- Standardization: Developing a universally accepted classification system that directly informs treatment algorithms.
- Robust Comparative Studies: Conducting large-scale RCTs comparing surgical versus non-surgical methods with a focus on long-term quality of life.
- Personalized Protocols: Integrating patient age, functional demands, and fracture geometry to optimize the balance between stability and invasiveness.
Summary updated