Evaluation of the effectiveness of ankle arthrodesis options

Ran Wang, И. Ф. Ахтямов, Jianfei Cai, Б. Г. Зиатдинов, E. S. SchigaevGenij 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Introduction: Treatment methods for late stages of ankle osteoarthritis are varied, but the issue of assessing the long-term results of various fixation methods has not yet been studied, and this issue is of great importance in clinical practice. Purpose: To compare the effectiveness of the fixation methods commonly used for ankle arthrodesis in patients with advanced ankle osteoarthritis. Materials and methods: Eighty-two patients with advanced ankle osteoarthritis were treated with ankle fusion between 2019 and 2023 at three major medical institutions. All patients underwent 12-month follow-ups. The patients were divided into four groups depending on the method of surgical fixation of bone fragments. Results: Most patients showed a significant improvement in the function and a decrease in pain intensity after the arthrodesis operation. The comparison of the effectiveness of various surgical fixation methods found that external apparatus screw fixation is characterized by lower blood loss and a relatively short duration of the operation. Plate and screw fixation resulted in higher AOFAS and VAS scores at 3 months postoperatively. However, by the 12th month after surgery, the differences in these two indicators were insignificant. Discussion: Despite the various complications that occur in ankle arthrodesis, it remains effective for most patients. Among them, the Ilizarov apparatus is more suitable for patients with compromised conditions in the surgical area. Each method of surgical fixation has its own advantages and shortcomings, but the difference in long-term effectiveness is small. Conclusion: Ankle arthrodesis is an effective treatment for advanced ankle osteoarthritis. The choice of surgical method is still subject to the principle of individual approach.

Introduction

Late-stage ankle osteoarthritis (OA) is a debilitating condition often resulting from prior trauma, rheumatoid arthritis, or chronic infection. When conservative treatments fail to provide relief, ankle arthrodesis—the surgical fusion of the joint—is considered the "gold standard" for eliminating pain and restoring stability.

Despite its widespread use, the surgical community lacks a consensus on the optimal method for bone fixation during the fusion process. Surgeons typically choose between external fixation frames, internal cannulated screws, plates, or intramedullary nails. Each method presents unique trade-offs regarding biomechanical stability, infection risk, and ease of application. This study aims to evaluate the comparative effectiveness and long-term outcomes of these four primary fixation strategies.

Materials and Methods

This prospective multi-center cohort study involved 82 patients (34 men, 48 women; mean age 55.6 years) treated across three major medical centers in Wuhan, China, and Kazan, Russia, between 2019 and 2023. Patients were categorized into four groups based on the fixation method employed:

  1. External Fixation (EF/AVF): Utilization of the Ilizarov apparatus (n=21), often reserved for patients with compromised soft tissues or a history of infection.
  2. Screw Fixation (VF): Fixation using 2–3 cannulated screws (n=23).
  3. Plate Fixation (PF): Application of anterior or lateral plates (n=20).
  4. Intramedullary Nail (IMN/IMSH): Insertion of a retrograde rod through the heel into the tibia (n=18).
External fixation using the Ilizarov apparatus for ankle arthrodesis.

Clinical performance was evaluated using the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score for functional assessment and the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain intensity. Surgical efficiency was quantified through intraoperative blood loss and total operation time. Patients were followed for a minimum of 12 months post-operation.

Radiographs showing internal fixation methods using screws for ankle fusion.

Results

The study achieved an overall fusion success rate of 93.9% (77 out of 82 cases). Analysis of surgical efficiency revealed that external fixation (~118 ml) and intramedullary nails (~115 ml) resulted in significantly less intraoperative blood loss compared to plate fixation (~130 ml).

In the early postoperative phase (3 months), patients in the plate and screw fixation groups demonstrated significantly better functional recovery, with higher AOFAS scores and lower VAS pain scores. However, by the 12-month follow-up, these differences were no longer statistically significant. AOFAS scores across all four groups converged between 77.6 and 80.6, indicating that long-term functional outcomes are comparable regardless of the hardware used. The overall complication rate was 12.2%, with no statistically significant difference between the groups ($p > 0.05$).

Discussion

The findings suggest that while internal hardware (plates and screws) may offer a faster functional "head start" in the first few months, the ultimate biological outcome of joint fusion is consistent across methods. A key insight from this study is the continued relevance of the Ilizarov apparatus (EF). It serves as a vital "safety net" for high-risk patients—those with poor skin quality, rheumatoid arthritis, or previous infections—where internal metal hardware would pose a high risk of failure or secondary infection.

Limitations of this study include a relatively short follow-up period of 12 months. While sufficient to confirm bone union, longer-term studies are required to assess the impact of ankle fusion on adjacent joint degeneration. Additionally, larger patient cohorts would enhance the statistical power to detect subtle differences in complication profiles.

Conclusion

Ankle arthrodesis remains a highly effective treatment for advanced osteoarthritis. The choice of surgical fixation method should be individualized, taking into account the patient's specific anatomy, bone quality, and soft tissue condition. No single method is universally superior; rather, each offers specific advantages that can be tailored to the clinical scenario.

Summary updated

Abstract

Introduction Treatment methods for late stages of ankle osteoarthritis are varied, but the issue of assessing the long-term results of various fixation methods has not yet been studied, and this issue is of great importance in clinical practice. Purpose To compare the effectiveness of the fixation methods commonly used for ankle arthrodesis in patients with advanced ankle osteoarthritis. Materials and methods Eighty-two patients with advanced ankle osteoarthritis were treated with ankle fusion between 2019 and 2023 at three major medical institutions. All patients underwent 12-month follow-ups. The patients were divided into four groups depending on the method of surgical fixation of bone fragments. Results Most patients showed a significant improvement in the function and a decrease in pain intensity after the arthrodesis operation. The comparison of the effectiveness of various surgical fixation methods found that external apparatus screw fixation is characterized by lower blood loss and a relatively short duration of the operation. Plate and screw fixation resulted in higher AOFAS and VAS scores at 3 months postoperatively. However, by the 12th month after surgery, the differences in these two indicators were insignificant. Discussion Despite the various complications that occur in ankle arthrodesis, it remains effective for most patients. Among them, the Ilizarov apparatus is more suitable for patients with compromised conditions in the surgical area. Each method of surgical fixation has its own advantages and shortcomings, but the difference in long-term effectiveness is small. Conclusion Ankle arthrodesis is an effective treatment for advanced ankle osteoarthritis. The choice of surgical method is still subject to the principle of individual approach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024evaluation,
  author = {Ran Wang and И. Ф. Ахтямов and Jianfei Cai and Б. Г. Зиатдинов and E. S. Schigaev},
  title = {{Evaluation of the effectiveness of ankle arthrodesis options}},
  booktitle = {Genij},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.18019/1028-4427-2024-30-2-210-220},
}
Figure