Abstract: ChiCTR2100042960, registered 1 February 2021, http://www.chictr.org.cn
Introduction
Femoral neck fractures in patients under 65 typically result from high-energy trauma, such as traffic accidents. Unlike elderly patients who often undergo hip replacement, the clinical priority for younger patients is "head preservation"—stabilizing the fracture to allow natural bone healing. However, high shear forces at the hip often lead to failure with standard cannulated screws, resulting in nonunion or avascular necrosis (bone death).
This prospective multicenter randomized controlled trial (RCT) compares two advanced internal fixation strategies: the Femoral Neck System (FNS), a newer integrated dynamic system designed for minimally invasive insertion, and Cannulated Screws (CS) combined with a medial buttress plate, which adds a small plate to provide extra mechanical support against sliding.
Methods
The study was conducted across six general hospitals in China, enrolling 334 patients aged 18–65 with fresh femoral neck fractures. Participants were randomized 1:1 to receive either FNS fixation or CS with a medial reconstruction plate. Clinical outcomes, including bone union, pain (VAS), and hip function (Harris Hip Score), were tracked over a 2-year follow-up period.
Key Results and Insights
The trial revealed a distinct trade-off between surgical efficiency and long-term structural stability:
- Surgical Efficiency: The FNS procedure was significantly faster, averaging 65 minutes compared to 131 minutes for the CS+plate group ($P < 0.001$). It also required significantly less intraoperative radiation exposure (fluoroscopy).
- Early Recovery: FNS patients reported lower pain levels and higher functional scores (HHS) in the first three months post-operation. This is likely due to the minimally invasive nature of the FNS compared to the more extensive soft tissue dissection required for medial plate placement.
- Structural Stability: While FNS was more efficient, the CS+medial plate group showed a significantly lower incidence of coxa vara (3 cases vs. 10 in the FNS group, $P < 0.05$). The medial plate acts as a physical buttress, preventing the femoral neck from collapsing into a varus deformity.
- Long-term Outcomes: By 6 months and through the 2-year mark, no significant differences were found in bone union rates (~80-83%), gait analysis, or overall quality of life between the two groups.
Conclusion
Both the Femoral Neck System and cannulated screws with a medial plate are effective for treating femoral neck fractures in young and middle-aged patients. The FNS is superior for surgical speed and early-stage recovery, making it an attractive option for streamlined care. Conversely, the addition of a medial plate provides superior mechanical resistance against coxa vara. Surgeons should consider the specific fracture geometry and the patient's functional needs when selecting the optimal implant.
Summary updated