Design for Hope: Cultivating Deliberate Hope in the Face of Complex Societal Challenges

JaeWon Kim, Jiaying Liu, Lindsay Popowski, Cassidy Pyle, Ahmer Arif, Gillian R. Hayes, Alexis Hiniker, Wendy Ju, Florian Mueller, Hua Shen, Sowmya Somanath, Casey Fiesler, Yasmine Kotturi

TL;DR

This paper proposes a workshop for the CSCW 2025 conference aimed at shifting the research community from a "reactive" mindset to a "proactive" one. By integrating Hope Theory into design methodologies, the authors provide a framework for researchers to move beyond mere harm reduction and toward cultivating "deliberate hope" when tackling complex societal challenges like misinformation and mental health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In fields like Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) and Social Computing, researchers often find themselves in a defensive crouch. We spend significant energy on "harm reduction"—trying to fix broken systems, mitigate online abuse, or curb misinformation. While essential, the authors argue that this reactive approach can unintentionally narrow our collective imagination, making it difficult to envision transformative, positive futures.

The "gap" here is methodological: we lack a rigorous, shared framework for designing for hope. Researchers often feel "stuck" or overwhelmed by the scale of societal problems. This paper addresses that paralysis by framing hope not as a vague emotion or blind optimism, but as a disciplined cognitive process that can be intentionally designed into research and technology.

Methods

As this is a workshop proposal, the "methods" focus on the conceptual framework and the planned activities for participants:

  • Hope Theory Integration: The authors lean on the psychology of hope (specifically C.R. Snyder’s work), which defines hope as the interplay of three components:
  • Goals: Setting ambitious but reachable targets.
  • Pathways Thinking: Generating multiple routes to reach those goals.
  • Agentic Thinking: Cultivating the motivation to pursue those routes.
  • Collaborative Reframing: The workshop uses design thinking to "reframe" problems. Instead of asking "How do we stop X?", researchers are encouraged to ask "What would a flourishing version of Y look like?"
  • Taxonomy Building: Participants will work to identify and categorize existing design methods (like speculative design, participatory design, and critical design) that align with the components of Hope Theory.
  • Reflective Practice: The workshop emphasizes "deliberate hope," which requires sitting with complexity and discomfort rather than turning away from it.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a workshop proposal, this document does not present an empirical study or a new dataset. Instead, it outlines a plan to gather qualitative insights from the research community to build a future taxonomy of methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hope is a Cognitive Tool, Not Just a Feeling: One of the most important takeaways is that hope can be "deliberate." By breaking hope down into pathways and agency, it becomes a functional part of the design process rather than a byproduct of success.
  • The "Positech" Movement: This work builds on the "Positech" (Positive Technology) workshop series, signaling a growing trend in the CSCW community to move toward "prosocial" and "flourishing-oriented" technology.
  • Design as a Practice of Resilience: The authors argue that the act of designing—sketching, prototyping, and iterating—is inherently hopeful because it forces the creator to generate "pathways" where none currently exist.
  • Balancing Ambition and Feasibility: A "hopeful" goal isn't a pipe dream; it’s a target that strikes a balance between being challenging enough to matter and attainable enough to sustain motivation.

Key Results

Because this is a proposal for a future event, the "results" are the intended outcomes:

  • A Shared Taxonomy: The primary goal is to produce a comprehensive taxonomy of generative and iterative design research methods that foster hope.
  • Community Building: The workshop aims to sustain the "Positech" community, providing a space for researchers working on "wicked" societal problems to find solidarity and shared methodologies.
  • Methodological Innovation: The paper suggests that by the end of the workshop, participants will have concrete strategies to embed hopeful trajectories into their own specific research lifecycles.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several challenges in this approach:

  • Institutional Constraints: They note that prevailing publication norms, scarce resources, and limited student time can make it difficult to conduct "hopeful" research, which often requires longer-term engagement and more speculative thinking.
  • Measurement: A key question for future work is: "What would it look like to measure or actively nurture hope across research lifecycles?"
  • Inclusivity: The authors emphasize the need to ensure that stakeholders and communities are "co-creators" in this process, rather than just subjects of a researcher's hopeful vision.
  • Sustainability: The "Post-Workshop Plan" involves moving these discussions to a dedicated website to ensure the taxonomy of methods evolves beyond a single day-long event.

Summary updated

Abstract

Design has the potential to cultivate hope in the face of complex societal challenges. These challenges are often addressed through efforts aimed at harm reduction and prevention -- essential but sometimes limiting approaches that can unintentionally narrow our collective sense of what is possible. This one-day, in-person workshop builds on the first Positech Workshop at CSCW 2024 by offering practical ways to move beyond reactive problem-solving toward building capacity for proactive goal setting and generating pathways forward. We explore how collaborative and reflective design methodologies can help research communities navigate uncertainty, expand possibilities, and foster meaningful change. By connecting design thinking with hope theory, which frames hope as the interplay of ``goal-directed,'' ``pathways,'' and ``agentic'' thinking, we will examine how researchers might chart new directions in the face of complexity and constraint. Through hands-on activities including problem reframing, building a shared taxonomy of design methods that align with hope theory, and reflecting on what it means to sustain hopeful research trajectories, participants will develop strategies to embed a deliberately hopeful approach into their research.
BibTeX
@misc{kim2025design,
  author = {JaeWon Kim and Jiaying Liu and Lindsay Popowski and Cassidy Pyle and Ahmer Arif and Gillian R. Hayes and Alexis Hiniker and Wendy Ju and Florian Mueller and Hua Shen and Sowmya Somanath and Casey Fiesler and Yasmine Kotturi},
  title = {{Design for Hope: Cultivating Deliberate Hope in the Face of Complex Societal Challenges}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2503.07586},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.07586},
}
Figure