Capital and CHI: Technological Capture and How It Structures CHI Research

Eric GilbertarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Introduction

Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) research is often presented as a neutral academic endeavor focused on the relationship between people and technology. However, this paper argues that the field is fundamentally structured by "technological capture"—a process where capital interests, such as venture capital and Big Tech, dictate which technological futures are explored and which are foreclosed. By mapping CHI subcommunities to market-driven goals, the research reveals how the field’s core values are often inherited from the need to create, expand, or protect commercial markets.

The Mechanism of Technological Capture

The concept of technological capture is analogous to "regulatory capture," where an industry exerts undue influence over the agencies meant to regulate it. In the context of CHI, capital interests shape the field through specific "vectors," including industry funding, the faculty-to-industry "revolving door," and the standard requirement for "Implications for Design" in research papers. These vectors ensure that research remains "tightly coupled" with the tech industry's needs, effectively acting as an "invisible hand" that guides academic inquiry toward profit-aligned outcomes.

The flow of technological capture from capital growth to the specific forms of research alignment within the CHI community.

The Four Forms of Capture

Through a frame analysis of CHI 2025 subcommittee descriptions and exemplar papers, the research decomposes CHI work into four distinct forms of technological capture:

  • Market-creating: Research that transforms raw technology (e.g., drones, novel sensors) into viable products. CHI provides the "human" layer necessary to turn a prototype into a startup.
  • Market-expanding: UX and user-understanding research that increases engagement, reduces churn, and adapts products for global markets—essentially helping firms find more customers.
  • Market-aligned: Research that follows high-profit sectors. The heavy focus on health and aging in CHI mirrors the fact that these are some of the most lucrative and fastest-growing markets in the global economy.
  • Externality-reducing: Research on "fairness," "safety," or "misinformation" often serves to mitigate the negative side effects of platforms. This work is frequently "sold" to companies as a way to avoid costly government regulation.

Evidence and Implications

The paper highlights several indicators of this capture. The "100x Rule" of venture capital logic dictates that technologies which cannot scale to billions of users are often ignored by the research-to-startup pipeline. Furthermore, a bibliometric comparison reveals a significant gap: CHI research mentions "Facebook" (a captured commercial system) 2,760 times, while "Wikipedia" (an open-source, non-profit system) appears only 795 times. This suggests a field-wide preference for studying systems aligned with capital.

The standard "Implications for Design" section in CHI papers is identified as a direct vector for capture, as it forces researchers to justify their work based on its utility for (usually commercial) product development. This mandate effectively forecloses on research that might be socially valuable but commercially inert.

Conclusion and Future Directions

To decouple CHI from capital, the author suggests shifting research norms. Replacing the "Implications for Design" mandate with "Implications for Society" could broaden the field's impact beyond commercial utility. Additionally, the paper calls for "socialist pitches"—technologies designed for open culture and collective ownership that exist entirely outside the shadow of technological capture. By acknowledging the influence of capital, the CHI community can begin to imagine technological futures that prioritize human well-being and collective benefit over profit accumulation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper advances a theoretical argument about the role capital plays in structuring CHI research. We introduce the concept of technological capture to theorize the mechanism by which this happens. Using this concept, we decompose the effect on CHI into four broad forms: technological capture creates market-creating, market-expanding, market-aligned, and externality-reducing CHI research. We place different CHI subcommunities into these forms -- arguing that many of their values are inherited from capital underlying the field. Rather than a disciplinary- or conference-oriented conceptualization of the field, this work theorizes CHI as tightly-coupled with capital via technological capture. The paper concludes by discussing some implications for CHI.
BibTeX
@misc{gilbert2025capital,
  author = {Eric Gilbert},
  title = {{Capital and CHI: Technological Capture and How It Structures CHI Research}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2501.14092},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.14092},
}
Figure