Design as Hope: Reimagining Futures for Seemingly Doomed Problems

Hua Shen, JaeWon Kim, Jiaying, Cassidy Pyle, Sowmya Somanath, Lindsay Popowski, Hua Shen 0005, Casey Fiesler, Gillian R. Hayes, Alexis Hiniker, Wendy Ju, Florian 'Floyd' Müller, Ahmer Arif, Yasmine KotturiarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Researchers addressing complex societal challenges—from online toxicity to systemic inequality—often operate within a paradigm of harm reduction, focusing on preventing negative outcomes rather than envisioning positive futures. This paper introduces a framework for "Design for Hope," which integrates psychological hope theory with design thinking to move beyond reactive stances. By framing hope as a cognitive discipline involving goal-directed thinking, pathway generation, and agentic motivation, the authors propose a methodological shift for the Computer-Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW) community. This approach aims to foster researcher resilience and expand the collective imagination when tackling seemingly "doomed" problems.

Introduction: The Crisis of Possibility

In the current research landscape, scholars tackling "wicked" problems—such as the mental health impacts of social media or the spread of misinformation—frequently find themselves in a "defensive crouch." The prevailing methodology is one of harm reduction and prevention: a constant effort to stop bad things from happening. While this work is vital, a purely reactive stance can unintentionally narrow the collective imagination, leading to a sense of "stuckness" or despair.

When the primary focus is fixing what is broken, researchers may lose the capacity to imagine entirely new, better systems. This paper addresses this "crisis of possibility" by asking how the research community can cultivate deliberate hope. Rather than treating hope as a vague emotion, the authors define it as a rigorous, cognitive tool essential for navigating uncertainty and maintaining agency in difficult problem spaces.

Theoretical Framework: Hope as a Design Practice

The proposed framework grounds design practice in Snyder’s Hope Theory, a psychological model that defines hope through the interplay of three specific components:

  1. Goal-directed thinking: The ability to set ambitious yet reachable targets.
  2. Pathways thinking: The capacity to generate multiple, flexible routes to reach those goals.
  3. Agentic thinking: The motivation and perceived capacity to pursue those routes, even in the face of obstacles.

By mapping standard design practices—such as sketching, prototyping, and reframing—onto these components, the authors argue that design is inherently a practice of hope. For instance, iterative prototyping serves as a mechanism for building "agentic thinking" by making incremental progress tangible and visible. Similarly, the act of reframing a problem allows researchers to move from "how do we fix X" to "what if X looked like Y," opening new pathways for exploration.

Methodology: The Positech Workshop

As a workshop proposal for the CSCW community, the paper outlines a collaborative approach to developing these "hopeful" methodologies. The proposed activities include:

  • Problem Reframing: Challenging default assumptions about existing systems to identify generative alternatives.
  • Taxonomy Development: Creating a shared language and set of methods that specifically foster hope within the research lifecycle.
  • Reflective Practice: Encouraging researchers to evaluate their own work through the lens of hope, asking whether their goals strike the right balance between ambition and feasibility.

Case Study: The Social Media Litmus Test

The paper uses the current state of social media as a prime example of a problem space often viewed as "doomed." A traditional research approach might focus on optimizing existing interfaces to marginally reduce misinformation. In contrast, a hope-oriented approach asks more fundamental questions: Does social media have to be two-dimensional? What if we let go of default assumptions and built alternatives from the ground up? By engaging with "critical hope"—a concept that requires facing the messiness of reality rather than turning away from it—designers can explore radical alternatives that go beyond mere optimization.

Discussion: Research as a Practice of Resilience

A central insight of this framework is that hope is a discipline, not an emotion. "Deliberate hope" requires the intentional work of questioning assumptions and continuously reassessing directions. This shift is not just about the outcomes of research, but about the sustainability of the researchers themselves. By focusing on generative practices rather than purely reactive problem-solving, researchers can build the resilience necessary to avoid burnout in high-stress fields.

Conclusion and Future Work

The "Design for Hope" framework represents a shift from "Positive Technology" (Positech) as a niche field to a broader methodological requirement for the CSCW community. While the paper provides a robust theoretical foundation, the authors acknowledge the "implementation gap"—the challenge of measuring and nurturing hope across long-term research lifecycles. Future work will focus on developing a comprehensive, public-facing taxonomy of generative design methods to help researchers embed these practices into their daily work, ensuring that the pursuit of better futures remains a central tenet of the design discipline.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{shen2025design,
  author = {Hua Shen and JaeWon Kim and Jiaying and Cassidy Pyle and Sowmya Somanath and Lindsay Popowski and Hua Shen and Casey Fiesler and Gillian R. Hayes and Alexis Hiniker and Wendy Ju and Florian 'Floyd' Müller and Ahmer Arif and Yasmine Kotturi},
  title = {{Design as Hope: Reimagining Futures for Seemingly Doomed Problems}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2503.07586},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.07586},
}
Figure