Defining Security Requirements with the Common Criteria: Applications, Adoptions, and Challenges

Nan Sun, Chang-Tsun Li, Hin Chan, Ba Dung Le, Md Zahidul Islam, Leo Yu Zhang, Warren Armstrong

Abstract

Advances in emerging Information and Communications Technology (ICT) push the boundaries of what is possible, opening new markets for innovative products and services. However, the adoption of these systems depends heavily on consumer confidence and market trust in their security functionalities. This trust is primarily gained through rigorous development of security requirements, validation criteria, evaluation, and certification. The Common Criteria for Information Technology Security Evaluation (CC), or ISO/IEC 15408, is the international standard for such certification. This paper conducts a systematic review of CC standards and their adoption, investigating barriers such as cost and complexity. Drawing on lessons from the Australian Cyber Criteria Assessment (DACCA) project, the authors provide best practices for developing Protection Profiles and recommendations for future cybersecurity advancement.

Introduction: The Gold Standard of Trust

In the cybersecurity landscape, "trust" is frequently used as a marketing term. For critical infrastructure and government systems, however, trust must be procedurally and mathematically verified. The Common Criteria (CC) serves as the international "gold standard" for certifying that IT products meet their security claims. Despite its rigor, the CC faces significant adoption hurdles in a fast-paced commercial market. A recent study published in IEEE Access by Nan Sun and colleagues explores these challenges and proposes a roadmap for modernizing the framework for the era of AI and IoT.

The Adoption Gap: Cost, Complexity, and Time

While the CC is the most robust security certification available, it is notoriously difficult to navigate. Vendors often face a "barrier to entry" characterized by high costs—averaging $250,000 USD—and lengthy evaluation cycles of 6 to 12 months. This timeline often clashes with the rapid release cycles of modern software and the short market lifespan of low-cost IoT devices. The research investigates this "adoption gap," specifically looking at why innovative ICT firms and startups often bypass the most rigorous standards in favor of faster, less comprehensive alternatives.

The study utilizes a dual approach to analyze the CC landscape:

  1. Systematic Review: The authors analyzed data from the official Common Criteria Portal, covering 1,619 certified products and 3,226 archived products as of late 2021.
  2. Case Study (DACCA Project): The authors shared practical experiences from the Development of Australian Cyber Criteria Assessment (DACCA) project, which focused on creating a Protection Profile (PP) for encryption key management.

The data reveals that Integrated Circuits (ICs) and Smart Cards are the leading categories for certification, driven by their long lifecycles and critical roles in banking and identification. Geographically, while the US leads in certifications against specific Protection Profiles, European nations like France, Germany, and the Netherlands produce the highest volume of certificates overall.

The Conceptual Framework of CC

At its core, the CC is a risk management framework rather than a simple checklist. It requires developers to define a Target of Evaluation (TOE) and map specific Security Functional Requirements (SFRs) directly to identified threats.

The conceptual framework of Common Criteria security evaluation, mapping threats and countermeasures to risk management.

As shown in the conceptual model, security evaluation is a process of gaining confidence that countermeasures are both sufficient and correct in reducing the risks posed by threat agents to valuable assets.

Key Insights: Modular and Collaborative Assurance

A significant trend identified in the paper is the shift from traditional Evaluation Assurance Levels (EAL 1-7) toward collaborative Protection Profiles (cPPs). In this model, assurance is derived from exact compliance with technology-specific testing activities.

The authors advocate for a "PP-Module" approach. Instead of drafting monolithic security specifications, developers can build modular components that plug into a "Base-PP" (such as a Network Device cPP). This modularity reduces redundancy and allows complex devices, like key managers, to inherit the security requirements of the underlying network infrastructure.

Future Directions: Agile Certification

To remain relevant, the CC must evolve to address emerging technologies and modern development practices. The authors highlight several challenges:

  • Linguistic Expressiveness: The need for better ways to describe nuances in Blockchain or Quantum-resistant cryptography.
  • Automation: A dire need for formal tools to assist vendors in writing security specifications, potentially using mathematical formalization like the "B-method."
  • Agility: Moving toward a "security-by-design" model that integrates certification with modern DevOps processes.

Conclusion

The Common Criteria remains the most comprehensive product-level security evaluation framework with international mutual recognition. However, for it to survive the transition to an AI-driven, IoT-saturated world, it must become more accessible and agile. By adopting modular development and iterative processes, the CC can bridge the gap between rigorous government requirements and the practical needs of the commercial ICT market.

Summary updated

Abstract

Advances of emerging Information and Communications Technology (ICT) technologies push the boundaries of what is possible and open up new markets for innovative ICT products and services. The adoption of ICT products and systems with security properties depends on consumers' confidence and markets' trust in the security functionalities and whether the assurance measures applied to these products meet the inherent security requirements. Such confidence and trust are primarily gained through the rigorous development of security requirements, validation criteria, evaluation, and certification. Common Criteria for Information Technology Security Evaluation (often referred to as Common Criteria or CC) is an international standard (ISO/IEC 15408) for cyber security certification. In this paper, we conduct a systematic review of the CC standards and its adoptions. Adoption barriers of the CC are also investigated based on the analysis of current trends in security evaluation. Specifically, we share the experiences and lessons gained through the recent Development of Australian Cyber Criteria Assessment (DACCA) project that promotes the CC among stakeholders in ICT security products related to specification, development, evaluation, certification and approval, procurement, and deployment. Best practices on developing Protection Profiles, recommendations, and future directions for trusted cybersecurity advancement are presented.
BibTeX
@article{sun2022defining,
  author = {Nan Sun and Chang-Tsun Li and Hin Chan and Ba Dung Le and Md Zahidul Islam and Leo Yu Zhang and Md. Rafiqul Islam and Warren Armstrong},
  title = {{Defining Security Requirements with the Common Criteria: Applications, Adoptions, and Challenges}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2022.3168716},
}
Figure