Navigating the road to automotive cybersecurity compliance

Franco Oberti, Fabrizio Abrate, Alessandro Savino, Filippo Parisi, Stefano Di CarloarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Modern vehicles have evolved into complex nodes within a digital ecosystem, making them prime targets for cyber-attacks. This paper provides a comprehensive roadmap of the shifting regulatory landscape—specifically UNR155, UNR156, and the Cyber Resilience Act—and highlights the engineering hurdles manufacturers face when trying to secure a vehicle's entire lifecycle.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The transition from purely mechanical machines to "computers on wheels" powered by AI and cloud connectivity has vastly increased the automotive attack surface. While these technologies improve safety and efficiency, they also expose vehicles to data breaches and unauthorized remote access.

The core challenge is that cybersecurity can no longer be a "bolt-on" feature; it must be integrated into the very fabric of the vehicle's design and maintained throughout its operational life. However, the industry faces a fragmented landscape of regional regulations (EU, US, China) and a complex supply chain where responsibility for security is often opaque. The authors aim to clarify these regulatory requirements and identify the practical gaps in achieving compliance.

Methods

This paper is a regulatory and technical review. The authors analyze the intersection of international legislation and engineering standards:

  • Legislative Analysis: A deep dive into UNR155 (Cyber Security Management Systems) and UNR156 (Software Update Management Systems), alongside the EU’s NIS2 directive and the Cyber Resilience Act (CRA).
  • Regional Comparison: An overview of the U.S. NHTSA’s "Best Practices" versus China’s mandatory national standards and their specific implementation timelines.
  • Standard Mapping: Examining how engineering standards like ISO/SAE 21434 (Cybersecurity Engineering) and ISO 24089 (Software Update Engineering) provide the technical framework to meet legal mandates.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a regulatory review and position paper, it does not utilize empirical training or evaluation datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Domain Overlap: Cybersecurity isn't just about the car; it’s about the infrastructure. The authors distinguish between "On-Board" security (the vehicle itself) and "Off-Board" security (IT infrastructure and smart city integration). Fig.

  • The figure illustrates the cybersecurity focus areas of UNR-155, NIS2, and UNR-156 within the context of vehicle functionality.

  • The Responsibility Gap: Under UNR155, Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) are solely responsible for the product's security. However, the emerging Cyber Resilience Act (CRA) might shift some of this burden, requiring component suppliers to certify their own digital elements.
  • Governance Conflicts: A significant challenge arises when a single Electronic Control Unit (ECU) is used across different domains. An ECU used in both a passenger car (governed by UNR155) and an industrial application (governed by CRA) must navigate two different governance frameworks simultaneously.
  • The TARA Bottleneck: Effective vulnerability disclosure is currently hindered because vehicle architectures are proprietary. Without uniform sharing of Threat Analysis and Risk Assessment (TARA) details across the supply chain, responding to new threats remains slow and inefficient.

![Fig.

  1. The figure illustrates the cybersecurity focus areas of UNR-155, NIS2, and UNR-156 within the context of vehicle functionality.](/figures/art_c43a8d90bfd844dba9794b47c782e610)

Key Results

  • Compliance Deadlines: The paper notes that under UNR155, all new vehicle types had to comply by July 2022, and all vehicles produced must comply by July 2024.
  • Certification Cycles: Cybersecurity Management System (CSMS) certifications are not permanent; they require re-certification every three years to ensure manufacturers adapt to evolving threats.
  • Chinese Market Timelines: The authors highlight that China’s mandatory standards (aligned with UNR155/156) are expected to be in force by November 2024, applying to all vehicle models by January 2026.
  • Economic Efficiency: The authors argue that adopting a "secure by design" approach—incorporating security at the earliest design stages—significantly reduces long-term costs compared to retrofitting security measures post-production.

![Fig.

  1. The figure illustrates the impact of cybersecurity regulations (UNR-155, NIS2, UNR-156, and CRA) on the automotive industry and related sectors.](/figures/art_d8bd8e05647d4d1dabd062f6693c1924)

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that current frameworks are still maturing. A major limitation is the lack of transparency in the supply chain; OEMs often lack full visibility into the sub-components provided by Tier 1 and Tier 2 suppliers.

Future work and industry evolution will likely focus on:

  • Expanding regulations to include agricultural and off-road vehicles.
  • Developing more agile organizational structures within automotive companies to enable rapid response to "zero-day" exploits.
  • Refining the intersection between automotive-specific rules (UNR155) and horizontal digital rules (CRA) to avoid redundant or conflicting certifications.

Summary updated

Abstract

The automotive industry has evolved significantly since the introduction of the Ford Model T in 1908. Today's vehicles are not merely mechanical constructs; they are integral components of a complex digital ecosystem, equipped with advanced connectivity features powered by Artificial Intelligence and cloud computing technologies. This evolution has enhanced vehicle safety, efficiency, and the overall driving experience. However, it also introduces new challenges, notably in cybersecurity. With the increasing integration of digital technologies, vehicles have become more susceptible to cyber-attacks, prompting significant cybersecurity concerns. These concerns include securing sensitive data, protecting vehicles from unauthorized access, and ensuring user privacy. In response, the automotive industry is compelled to adopt robust cybersecurity measures to safeguard both vehicles and data against potential threats. Legislative frameworks such as UNR155 and UNR156 by the United Nations, along with other international regulations, aim to establish stringent cybersecurity mandates. These regulations require compliance with comprehensive cybersecurity management systems and necessitate regular updates and testing to cope with the evolving nature of cyber threats. The introduction of such regulations highlights the growing recognition of cybersecurity as a critical component of automotive safety and functionality. The future of automotive cybersecurity lies in the continuous development of advanced protective measures and collaborative efforts among all stakeholders, including manufacturers, policymakers, and cybersecurity professionals. Only through such concerted efforts can the industry hope to address the dual goals of innovation in vehicle functionality and stringent security measures against the backdrop of an increasingly interconnected digital landscape.
BibTeX
@misc{oberti2024navigating,
  author = {Franco Oberti and Fabrizio Abrate and Alessandro Savino and Filippo Parisi and Stefano Di Carlo},
  title = {{Navigating the road to automotive cybersecurity compliance}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.00483},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00483},
}
Figure