Abstract
The functionality of atomic quantum emitters is intrinsically linked to their host lattice coordination. Structural distortions that spontaneously break the lattice symmetry strongly impact their optical emission properties and spin-photon interface. Here we report on the direct imaging of charge state-dependent symmetry breaking of two prototypical atomic quantum emitters in mono- and bilayer MoS$_2$ by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and non-contact atomic force microscopy (nc-AFM). By substrate chemical gating different charge states of sulfur vacancies (Vac$_\text{S}$) and substitutional rhenium dopants (Re$_\text{Mo}$) can be stabilized. Vac$_\text{S}^{-1}$ as well as Re$_\text{Mo}^{0}$ and Re$_\text{Mo}^{-1}$ exhibit local lattice distortions and symmetry-broken defect orbitals attributed to a Jahn-Teller effect (JTE) and pseudo-JTE, respectively. By mapping the electronic and geometric structure of single point defects, we disentangle the effects of spatial averaging, charge multistability, configurational dynamics, and external perturbations that often mask the presence of local symmetry breaking.
Introduction
Atomic defects in two-dimensional (2D) transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) have emerged as leading candidates for "artificial atom" qubits and quantum light sources. The performance of these quantum emitters is fundamentally dictated by their local symmetry. While theoretical models have long predicted that these defects should undergo spontaneous structural distortions to lower their energy—a phenomenon known as the Jahn-Teller Effect (JTE)—experimental verification has remained elusive. These distortions occur on the scale of picometers and are typically masked by thermal vibrations or spatial averaging in bulk measurements.
This study provides a direct look at the sub-atomic "shudder" that occurs when defects in MoS$_2$ change their charge state. By combining ultra-high-resolution microscopy with quantum mechanical simulations, we demonstrate how the capture or loss of a single electron fundamentally reshapes the atomic architecture of the host material.
Experimental Methodology
To resolve these minute distortions, the research team employed a multi-modal scanning probe approach. The electronic wavefunctions (orbitals) surrounding the defects were mapped using Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM). To observe the physical displacement of atoms, non-contact Atomic Force Microscopy (nc-AFM) was utilized with a CO-functionalized tip, providing sub-atomic spatial resolution.
Rather than using physical gate electrodes, the charge states of the defects were controlled via chemical gating. By utilizing different substrates—specifically, different types of epitaxial graphene (Quasi-freestanding epitaxial graphene and epitaxial graphene on SiC)—the material's Fermi level was shifted. This allowed for the stabilization of sulfur vacancies (Vac$_\text{S}$) and rhenium dopants (Re$_\text{Mo}$) in specific positive, neutral, or negative charge states. These experimental observations were further validated by Density Functional Theory (DFT) simulations to calculate potential energy surfaces and confirm the energetically favorable distorted states.
Symmetry Breaking and the Jahn-Teller Effect
The study reveals that symmetry breaking is not a static property of the defect but is dependent on its charge state.
Sulfur Vacancies (Vac$_\text{S}$)
A neutral sulfur vacancy maintains the three-fold ($C_{3v}$) symmetry of the MoS$_2$ lattice. However, the addition of a single electron to create Vac$_\text{S}^{-1}$ triggers a classic Jahn-Teller Effect. This lifts the orbital degeneracy and causes the symmetry to collapse into a two-fold ($C_{2v}$) configuration. This structural relaxation provides a substantial energy gain of approximately 116 meV.
Rhenium Dopants (Re$_\text{Mo}$)
Rhenium dopants exhibit a more complex behavior categorized as a pseudo-JTE, where the distortion arises from the mixing of non-degenerate electronic states. The researchers successfully stabilized Rhenium in three distinct charge states ($+1, 0, -1$). While Re$_\text{Mo}^{+1}$ remains symmetric, the neutral and negative states exhibit significant distortions. In the case of Re$_\text{Mo}^{-1}$, the Rhenium atom physically shifts approximately 25 pm away from the center of the lattice site, resulting in an energy gain of 38 meV.
Global Alignment and Dynamics
An unexpected finding was the alignment of these local distortions across large areas of the sample. Rather than being randomly oriented, the defects often "pointed" in the same direction. This suggests that residual mesoscale strain within the MoS$_2$ lattice acts as a global signal that aligns local atomic distortions.
Furthermore, Rhenium dopants displayed unusually broad electronic resonances. This is attributed to a "dynamic JTE," where the atom is not fixed in a single distorted position but exists within a continuum of configurations due to a very flat potential energy landscape. This "configurational continuum" highlights the fluid nature of atomic-scale geometry in 2D systems.
Conclusion and Outlook
By disentangling the effects of charge multistability and external perturbations, this work provides a roadmap for tuning the electronic and optical properties of 2D quantum emitters. The ability to toggle the symmetry of a defect by adjusting its charge state opens new avenues for quantum sensing and information processing.
Future research may focus on moving from static chemical gating to dynamic electrical gating, potentially allowing for real-time control of an emitter's symmetry. Additionally, the sensitivity of these Jahn-Teller distortions to lattice strain suggests that these defects could be utilized as high-precision, atomic-scale strain sensors to map the mechanical landscape of 2D materials.
Summary updated