Can Quadruped Navigation Robots be Used as Guide Dogs?

Qihe Chen, Luyao Wang, Yan Zhang, Ziang Li, Tingmin Yan, Fan Wang, Guyue Zhou, Jiangtao Gong

Abstract

Quadruped robots have the potential to guide blind and low vision (BLV) people due to their highly flexible locomotion and emotional value provided by their bionic forms. However, the development of quadruped guide robots rarely involves BLV users' participatory designs and evaluations. In this paper, we conducted two empirical experiments both in indoor controlled and outdoor field scenarios, exploring the benefits and drawbacks of quadruped guide robots. The results show that the nowadays commercial quadruped robots exposed significant disadvantages in usability and trust compared with wheeled robots. It is concluded that the moving gait and walking noise of quadruped robots would limit the guiding effectiveness to a certain extent, and the empathetic effect of its bionic form for BLV users could not be fully reflected. Based on the findings of wheeled robots and quadruped robots' advantages, we discuss the design implications for the future guide robot design for BLV users. This paper reports the first empirical experiment about quadruped guide robots with BLV users and preliminary explores their potential improvement space in substituting guide dogs, which can inspire the further specialized design of quadruped guide robots.

Introduction

While quadruped robots are often touted as the "bionic" successor to guide dogs, this empirical study reveals that current commercial models actually underperform compared to simple wheeled robots. Issues with jerky gait movements, high motor noise, and a lack of perceived emotional connection suggest that "looking like a dog" is less important to blind and low-vision (BLV) users than smooth, quiet, and reliable functionality. While guide dogs offer unparalleled independence and emotional support, they are expensive to train and in short supply globally. Quadruped robots have emerged as a high-tech alternative because they mimic a dog’s form and can navigate complex terrains, but most development has focused on robotics rather than the user experience.

Methods

The researchers conducted two empirical experiments (indoor and outdoor) using a within-subjects design, comparing a quadruped robot to a wheeled robot baseline. To ensure the study tested the form of the robot rather than the current state of autonomous navigation AI, a "Wizard-of-Oz" approach was used where a human operator remotely controlled the robots.

The study compared a quadruped robot (left) with a custom-built wheeled robot (right) to evaluate user experience.

Both robots were equipped with a standard guide dog harness and tie rod to provide kinesthetic feedback. The study involved 23 individuals (15 BLV users and 8 sighted participants simulating blindness). Evaluation metrics included the NASA-TLX (workload), System Usability Scale (SUS), and the QUEST (satisfaction) scale, alongside acoustic data and trajectory tracking.

Key Insights and Results

The findings were surprising and somewhat counter-intuitive for those expecting "high-tech" to mean "better":

  • The "Gait" Problem: Unlike the smooth roll of a wheeled robot, quadrupeds move by shifting their weight between legs. Participants described this motion as "hesitating" or "anxious-inducing," making it harder to sense a clear direction of travel.
  • Noise as a Barrier: Hearing is a vital "secondary eye" for BLV individuals. The quadruped robots were significantly louder (~80 dBA) than wheeled robots (~65 dBA), masking environmental cues like traffic and causing social embarrassment.
  • Function over Form: BLV users prioritized safety, stability, and quietness over the robot's resemblance to a dog. Wheeled robots were better at transmitting subtle ground information through the handle.
Trajectory data comparing human and robot paths across four navigation tasks, illustrating the differences in movement patterns.

Quantitative results supported these observations: wheeled robots received significantly higher SUS scores, while the quadruped robot imposed higher mental and temporal demands. Ultimately, 64.29% of participants trusted the wheeled robot more than the quadruped.

Discussion and Future Work

The study highlights that for a robot to truly replace a guide dog, engineers must focus less on bionic appearance and more on smooth, quiet reliability. The authors suggest that the future of guide robots might lie in a wheel-legged hybrid. This would allow for smooth, quiet rolling on flat sidewalks while retaining the ability to "step" over obstacles or climb stairs when necessary. Future research should also consider the long-term effects of familiarity to see if the anxiety caused by the quadruped's gait diminishes over time.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quadruped robots have the potential to guide blind and low vision (BLV) people due to their highly flexible locomotion and emotional value provided by their bionic forms. However, the development of quadruped guide robots rarely involves BLV users' participatory designs and evaluations. In this paper, we conducted two empirical experiments both in indoor controlled and outdoor field scenarios, exploring the benefits and drawbacks of quadruped guide robots. The results show that the nowadays commercial quadruped robots exposed significant disadvantages in usability and trust compared with wheeled robots. It is concluded that the moving gait and walking noise of quadruped robots would limit the guiding effectiveness to a certain extent, and the empathetic effect of its bionic form for BLV users could not be fully reflected. Based on the findings of wheeled robots and quadruped robots' advantages, we discuss the design implications for the future guide robot design for BLV users. This paper reports the first empirical experiment about quadruped guide robots with BLV users and preliminary explores their potential improvement space in substituting guide dogs, which can inspire the further specialized design of quadruped guide robots.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2023can,
  author = {Qihe Chen and Luyao Wang and Yan Zhang and Ziang Li and Tingmin Yan and Fan Wang and Guyue Zhou and Jiangtao Gong},
  title = {{Can Quadruped Navigation Robots be Used as Guide Dogs?}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=0RwzDKW7oE},
}
Figure