Can Quadruped Guide Robots be Used as Guide Dogs?

Luyao Wang, Qihe Chen, Yan Zhang, Ziang Li, Tingmin Yan, Fan Wang, Guyue Zhou, Jiangtao Gong

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether quadruped robots can effectively substitute guide dogs for visually impaired individuals. Through indoor and outdoor experiments comparing quadruped and wheeled robots, the study found that current quadruped robots lag behind wheeled robots in usability and user trust, primarily due to their gait and noise. The findings offer crucial design insights for developing future guide robots that better meet the needs of the visually impaired community.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, millions suffer from visual impairments, making independent and safe travel a significant challenge. While guide dogs are an optimal solution, their high cost and limited availability, especially in developing countries, exclude many from their benefits. Quadruped robots, with their flexible locomotion and potential for emotional connection due to their bionic form, are seen as a promising alternative. However, there's a lack of empirical research involving visually impaired users to assess their practical usability and emotional impact compared to existing robotic solutions like wheeled robots. This paper aims to fill this gap by empirically evaluating quadruped guide robots and identifying their strengths and weaknesses for guiding visually impaired individuals.

Methods

The researchers conducted a within-subjects experiment with 23 participants (including sighted individuals simulating blindness and legally blind individuals) in both indoor controlled and outdoor real-world environments. They employed a "Wizard-of-Oz" method, where a human operator remotely controlled the robots to simulate realistic guiding scenarios.

The study compared two types of robots:

  • Quadruped Robots: Commercial models (Xiaomi Cyberdog indoors, Unitree outdoors) equipped with a guide harness similar to those used with guide dogs.
  • Wheeled Robots: A wheeled robot of similar dimensions to the Cyberdog indoors and a "Guiding Car" outdoors, also fitted with a guide harness and handrail.

Participants performed various walking tasks, including straight paths, turns, and obstacle avoidance, under different difficulty levels. Post-experiment, participants completed questionnaires assessing workload (NASA-TLX), usability (SUS), trust, and satisfaction. Semi-structured interviews were also conducted to gather qualitative feedback.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on empirical data collected from participant interactions with robots in controlled and real-world environments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Usability and Trust Discrepancy: Despite the inherent flexibility of quadruped robots, current commercial models are perceived as less usable and trustworthy by visually impaired users compared to wheeled robots. This challenges the initial assumption that bionic form alone guarantees user acceptance.
  • Gait and Noise are Major Drawbacks: The primary reasons for the lower usability and trust scores for quadruped robots were identified as their moving gait (perceived as less smooth and potentially risky) and the loud, unavoidable walking noise. This noise can be particularly disruptive for visually impaired individuals who rely heavily on auditory cues.
  • Emotional Connection is Not Automatic: While bionic forms can evoke emotional responses, the study suggests that the current quadruped robots did not automatically translate into the desired emotional support or companionship for the participants, with practicality often being prioritized over form.
  • Wheeled Robots Offer a More Reliable Baseline: The study highlights that wheeled robots, despite their limitations in terrain adaptability, currently provide a more stable and predictable guiding experience, leading to higher user satisfaction and trust.
  • Design Implications for Future Robots: The research provides concrete suggestions for improving quadruped guide robots, including developing smoother, more predictable gaits, reducing noise through material innovation, and incorporating more sophisticated "professional actions" akin to guide dogs (e.g., pausing before stairs).

Key Results

  • Workload: Participants reported significantly higher workload when guided by the quadruped robot compared to the wheeled robot, particularly in terms of temporal demand.
  • Usability (SUS): Quadruped robots received significantly lower usability scores, with a substantial percentage falling into the "bad" or "terrible" categories. Wheeled robots consistently scored higher across most SUS sub-scales.
  • Trust: Participants showed significantly more trust in the wheeled robot than the quadruped robot, especially in the outdoor environment.
  • Satisfaction: While not statistically significant, trends indicated higher satisfaction with wheeled robots.
  • Noise Levels: Quadruped robots generated significantly higher noise levels (average 80-82 dBA) compared to wheeled robots (average 65-70 dBA) in an indoor environment with ambient noise of 36 dBA.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Commercial Robot Limitations: The quadruped robots used were not specifically designed for visually impaired users, which might have influenced the results. Future research could focus on robots purpose-built for this application.
  • Novelty Effect: Participants had no prior experience with these robots, meaning the novelty effect could have impacted their initial perceptions. Long-term studies are needed to understand sustained user experience.
  • Sample Size and Diversity: While 23 participants were involved, a larger and more diverse sample, particularly with experienced guide dog users, would strengthen the findings.

Future work should explore:

  • The role of more realistic biological structure simulation in enhancing emotional connection and trust.
  • The potential of hybrid chassis (e.g., wheel-legged robots) that combine the advantages of different locomotion types.
  • Long-term studies to assess the integration of these robots into the daily lives of visually impaired individuals.
  • Investigating whether empathetic emotions can be fostered in BLV users with enhanced guide robot functionality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quadruped robots have the potential to guide blind and low vision (BLV) people due to their highly flexible locomotion and emotional value provided by their bionic forms. However, the development of quadruped guide robots rarely involves BLV users' participatory designs and evaluations. In this paper, we conducted two empirical experiments both in indoor controlled and outdoor field scenarios, exploring the benefits and drawbacks of quadruped guide robots. The results show that the nowadays commercial quadruped robots exposed significant disadvantages in usability and trust compared with wheeled robots. It is concluded that the moving gait and walking noise of quadruped robots would limit the guiding effectiveness to a certain extent, and the empathetic effect of its bionic form for BLV users could not be fully reflected. Based on the findings of wheeled robots and quadruped robots' advantages, we discuss the design implications for the future guide robot design for BLV users. This paper reports the first empirical experiment about quadruped guide robots with BLV users and preliminary explores their potential improvement space in substituting guide dogs, which can inspire the further specialized design of quadruped guide robots.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023can,
  author = {Luyao Wang and Qihe Chen and Yan Zhang and Ziang Li and Tingmin Yan and Fan Wang and Guyue Zhou and Jiangtao Gong},
  title = {{Can Quadruped Guide Robots be Used as Guide Dogs?}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/RSJ International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=0RwzDKW7oE},
}
Figure