A Study on Methane-Air Mixture Ignition in the Shock Tube

Takashi Shibuya, Toshiro IsobeJournal of the Mining and Metallurgical Institute of Japan 1984 · DOI

Abstract

The explosion of explosives and methane-air mixtures produces significant mechanical and thermal energy, transmitted via flames, high-temperature gases, particles, and shock waves. This study investigates the ignition of CH4-air mixtures using a standard shock tube apparatus. Experimental results demonstrate that reflected shock waves can reach temperatures of approximately 1,700K at Mach 3.0, providing sufficient energy for the auto-ignition of methane-air mixtures within a millisecond timeframe.

Introduction

In coal mining environments, methane gas explosions represent a persistent and catastrophic hazard. While traditional ignition sources like electrical sparks or open flames are well-documented, the role of shock waves as an independent trigger is often overlooked. A primary explosion can generate shock waves that travel through mine galleries, rapidly compressing stagnant methane-air pockets. This adiabatic compression can raise the gas temperature above its auto-ignition threshold. This research aims to isolate and quantify the shock wave's ability to initiate combustion using a controlled laboratory shock tube.

Experimental Methodology

The researchers employed a standard pressure-driven shock tube consisting of two main sections:

  • High-Pressure Vessel (Driver): 70 mm in diameter, 1 m in length, and 7 mm thick.
  • Low-Pressure Vessel (Test): 40 × 40 mm cross-section, 4.2 m in length, and 2 mm thick.

A 0.15 mm polyester film serves as the partition diaphragm. When the pressure difference between the vessels causes the diaphragm to rupture, a shock wave propagates into the low-pressure section.

Figure 1: Schematic of shock tube states (a), pressure and temperature profiles (b), and wave propagation x-t diagram (c).

The experiment focuses on the "reflected shock" state at the end of the tube. As the incident shock wave (region 2) hits the end wall, it reflects (region 5), creating a stagnant, high-temperature, high-pressure zone. Instrumentation included semiconductor pressure transducers (PMS-5) to measure shock velocity and pressure profiles.

Theoretical Framework

The physical characteristics of the shock wave were calculated using fundamental gas dynamic equations. The pressure ratio across the incident shock ($P_{21}$) and the reflected shock ($P_{51}$) are determined by:

  1. $P = 1 + \frac{2\gamma_1(M_1^2 - 1)}{\gamma_1 + 1}$
  2. $P_{51} = \frac{(2 + \alpha_1)P_{21} - 1}{\alpha_1 + P_{21}}$

Where $\alpha_1 = \frac{\gamma_1 + 1}{\gamma_1 - 1}$, $\gamma$ is the specific heat ratio, and $M_1$ is the Mach number. The temperature at the end of the tube ($T_5$) is derived from the pressure ratio $P_{21}$:

$T_{51} = \frac{[(2 + \alpha_1)P_{21} - 1][\alpha_1 - 1 + 2P_{21}]}{(1 + \alpha_1 P_{21})(\alpha_1 + 1)}$

Results and Discussion

Using Hydrogen ($H_2$) as the driver gas, the apparatus generated significant shock velocities and pressures:

  • At a driver pressure of 5 kg/cm², a Mach 1.7 shock wave produced a reflected pressure ($P_5$) of 10 kg/cm².
  • At 16 kg/cm², the velocity reached 900 m/sec (Mach 2.6) with $P_5 = 25$ kg/cm².
  • At 30 kg/cm², the velocity reached 1,100 m/sec (Mach 3.1) with $P_5 = 40$ kg/cm².

At Mach 3.0, the calculated temperature $T_5$ is approximately 1,700K. The duration of this high-temperature state is roughly 1 millisecond. In combustion chemistry, 1,700K is sufficient to initiate the radical chain reactions (involving $OH$ and $CHO$) necessary for methane oxidation within the available timeframe.

Conclusion

This study validates the shock tube as a reliable instrument for simulating the extreme thermal environments produced by mining explosions. The results confirm that shock waves alone, particularly upon reflection at gallery dead-ends, can generate the temperatures required to ignite methane-air mixtures. This identifies shock waves as a primary, independent factor in the propagation of mine disasters, necessitating further study into ignition delays and boundary layer effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

The explosion of explosives and methane-air mixture produce a great deal of mechanical and thermal energy. The energy produced in both cases will be transmitted not only by flames, high temperature gas and particles but also by shock waves.The studies described in this paper are the investigations on the ignition of CH4-air mixture using shock tube apparatusThe shock tube used in this experiment is a standard type. And it consists of high pressure vessel, (whose diameter, length and thickness are 70mm, 1m and 7mm, respectively), and low pressure vessel, (whose cross section, length and thickness are 40×40mm, 4.2m and 2mm, respectively).The partition diaphragm between both vessels is polyester film (0.15mm in thickness) and it will be broken by pressure difference of both vessels. And thus shock waves will be produced.For example, when using H2 as driver gas, the velocity and the pressure of generated shock wave are as follows;For example, when using H2 as driver gas, the velocity and the pressure of generated shock wave are as follows; When high pressure is kept at 5kg/cm2 and suddenly the partition film is broken, shock wave of 600m/sec (Mach 1.7) and P5=10kg/cm2 are recorded, the pressure being kept at 16kg/cm2, 900 misec (Mach 2.6) and P5=25kg/cm2 wave comes out, and pressure being kept at 30kg/cm2 is the pressure, it produces 1100m/sec (Mach 3.1) and P5=40kg/cm2 shock wave.Physical characteristics of shock wave are calculated by the following fundamental equations._??_(1)P=1+2γ1(M12-1)/(γ1+1).(2) P51=[2-α1P21-1]/(α1-P21).(3)where Pij=Pi/Pj, α1=(γ1+1)/(γ1-1), γ=Cp/Cv, M1=U/a1 are provided.Further more, temperature (T5) at the end of shock tube is calculated by equation (4) using P21 from equation (2).T51=[(2+α1)P21-1][α1-1+2P21]/(1+α1P21)(α1+1).(4)When velocity of shock wave is Mach 3.0, temperature T5 is near1y 1, 700°K and duration of this high temperature is about 1 milli-seconds or alittle less than 1 milli-seconds.Therefore ignition of CH4-air mixture is considered to be occurred in the shock tube.
BibTeX
@article{shibuya1984study,
  author = {Takashi Shibuya and Toshiro ISOBE},
  title = {{A Study on Methane-Air Mixture Ignition in the Shock Tube}},
  journal = {Journal of the Mining and Metallurgical Institute of Japan},
  year = {1984},
  doi = {10.2473/shigentosozai1953.100.1158\_651},
}
Figure