Abstract: From the analysis of the isentropic limit of weak compression shock waves, oblique shock waves in which the post-shock Mach number is larger than the pre-shock Mach number, named non-ideal oblique shocks, are admissible in substances characterized by moderate molecular complexity and in the close proximity to the liquid–vapour saturation curve. Non-ideal oblique shocks of finite amplitude are systematically analysed, clarifying the roles of the pre-shock thermodynamic state and Mach number. The necessary conditions for the occurrence of non-ideal oblique shocks of finite amplitude are singled out. In the parameter space of pre-shock thermodynamic states and Mach number, a new domain is defined which embeds the pre-shock states for which the Mach number increase can possibly take place. The present findings are confirmed by state-of-the-art thermodynamic models applied to selected commercially available fluids, including siloxanes and hydrocarbons currently used as working fluids in renewable energy systems.
Introduction
In classical gas dynamics, based on the perfect gas model, a compression shock wave always results in a decrease in the Mach number ($M$). This is because the shock increases the fluid's density and temperature, which in turn raises the local speed of sound while simultaneously slowing the flow velocity. Consequently, the post-shock Mach number is invariably lower than the pre-shock value ($M_B < M_A$).
However, this "ideal" behavior does not hold for all substances. Fluids with high molecular complexity—such as siloxanes and hydrocarbons used in Organic Rankine Cycles (ORC)—exhibit non-ideal thermodynamic behavior near their liquid-vapor saturation curve. In these regimes, the speed of sound can actually decrease upon compression. This paper investigates the existence and properties of "non-ideal oblique shocks," where the Mach number increases across the shock front ($M_B > M_A$).
Methodology and Theoretical Framework
The study employs the Rankine–Hugoniot relations to analyze the jump conditions across a shock wave for arbitrary equations of state. These relations ensure the conservation of mass, momentum, and energy across the shock front.
A central role is played by the fundamental derivative of gas dynamics, $\Gamma$, which characterizes the curvature of isentropes in the pressure-volume ($P-v$) plane. Non-ideal phenomena, including the possibility of Mach-increasing shocks, occur when $\Gamma < 1$. The authors derive a new non-dimensional parameter, $J = 1 - \Gamma - 1/M^2$, proving that $J > 0$ in the pre-shock state is a necessary condition for a Mach number increase in weak shocks. For finite-amplitude shocks, the researchers mapped the "Pre-shock Limit Locus" (PSLL) using the REFPROP library to identify the thermodynamic regions where these shocks are physically possible.
Thermodynamic Regimes and Fluid Selection
The analysis focuses on eight industrial fluids known for their complex molecular structures:
- Siloxanes: MDM (octamethyltrisiloxane) and MM (hexamethyldisiloxane).
- Hydrocarbons: Octane, Cyclopentane, Toluene, and Benzene.
- Refrigerants: R245fa and Sulfur Hexafluoride ($SF_6$).
These fluids often operate in the "retrograde" region, where the vapor phase is maintained during compression. This region provides the specific thermodynamic conditions—low $\Gamma$ values—required for non-ideal shock behavior.
Key Findings
The research demonstrates that the Mach number increases across a shock not because the flow accelerates, but because the local speed of sound drops more rapidly than the flow velocity decreases.
Key results include:
- Existence Domains: The authors successfully mapped the regions in the $P-v$ plane where $M_B > M_A$ is guaranteed for specific fluids like MDM at various pre-shock Mach numbers.
- Threshold Mach Number: There exists a minimum pre-shock Mach number ($M_{A,min}$) below which non-ideal shocks cannot occur, determined by the fluid's minimum fundamental derivative ($\Gamma_{min}$).
- Stability: Using D’yakov–Kontorovich conditions, the study confirms that these shocks are physically stable, though many are "neutrally stable," potentially emitting acoustic waves spontaneously.
- Molecular Complexity: The strength and extent of the non-ideal domain are directly related to molecular complexity, with siloxanes showing the most significant effects.
Conclusion and Engineering Implications
This work provides the first systematic proof that finite-amplitude, Mach-increasing shocks are possible in real-world industrial fluids. These findings are critical for the design of high-speed components in renewable energy systems, such as ORC turbines. Ignoring non-ideal shock effects could lead to significant errors in predicting flow behavior, resulting in suboptimal designs and efficiency losses. While experimental evidence is still needed, this study provides the necessary theoretical "map" for future experimental validation.
Summary updated