Exact solutions to non-classical steady nozzle flows of Bethe–Zel’dovich–Thompson fluids

Alberto Guardone, Davide VimercatiJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Steady nozzle flows of Bethe–Zel’dovich–Thompson (BZT) fluids—substances exhibiting non-classical gasdynamic behavior in a finite vapor-phase thermodynamic region near the liquid–vapor saturation curve—are examined. Non-classical flow features include rarefaction shock waves, shock waves with either upstream or downstream sonic states, and split shocks. Exact solutions for a mono-component single-phase fluid expanding through a conventional converging–diverging nozzle are determined within the quasi-one-dimensional inviscid flow approximation. This analytical approach elucidates the connection between the adiabatic flow field and underlying isentropic-flow features. Contrary to previous predictions, shock disintegration is found to occur even from reservoir states corresponding to a single sonic point. A classification of steady nozzle flows into 10 different functioning regimes is proposed, associating each regime with specific thermodynamic regions of reservoir states.

Introduction: The Non-Classical Regime

In classical gasdynamics, compression leads to shock waves while expansion is smooth. This behavior is governed by the fundamental derivative of gasdynamics, $\Gamma$. When $\Gamma > 0$, the fluid is considered "classical." However, complex organic fluids, known as Bethe–Zel’dovich–Thompson (BZT) fluids, can enter a region where $\Gamma < 0$ when operating near their liquid-vapor saturation point.

In this non-classical regime, physical behaviors are inverted: rarefaction shock waves can occur during expansion, and shocks can split into multiple structures. While these fluids have been studied for decades, previous nozzle flow analyses often relied on isentropic assumptions that ignored entropy changes across shocks. This paper addresses that gap by providing exact solutions that account for the entropy rise across non-classical shocks.

Analytical Framework and Methodology

The authors employ a quasi-one-dimensional inviscid flow approximation to model a single-phase fluid expanding from a reservoir into a stationary atmosphere through a converging-diverging nozzle.

Key technical components include:

  • Thermodynamic Modeling: The polytropic van der Waals (vdW) equation of state is used to qualitatively capture the essential physics of the $\Gamma < 0$ region.
  • Analytical Framework: The study relates the Mach number ($M$) and mass flux ($j$) to density ($\rho$), demonstrating how non-monotonic behavior in these variables leads to multiple sonic points.
  • Shock Fitting: Utilizing the Rankine–Hugoniot relations, the work accounts for the discontinuous rise in entropy across non-classical shocks, a critical factor previously overlooked.

Non-Monotonicity and Multiple Sonic Points

A defining characteristic of BZT fluids is that the Mach number does not always increase as density drops during expansion. Depending on the entropy levels, a fluid can exhibit up to three sonic points ($M=1$) instead of the single point found in classical fluids.

Variation of Mach number (a) and mass flux (b) along isentropes, showing non-monotonic behavior.

This non-monotonicity is the root of several non-classical phenomena. For instance, the discovery of "shock disintegration"—where shocks split or vanish—was found to occur even when the reservoir state suggests only a single sonic point, contradicting earlier theories that required more complex initial conditions.

Classification of 10 Functioning Regimes

The research moves beyond the simple "Type-1" and "Type-2" classifications of earlier literature, identifying a total of 10 distinct functioning regimes. These regimes are defined by the sequence of flow solutions encountered as ambient pressure is monotonically decreased. They range from classical ideal-gas-like behavior to complex regimes where rarefaction shocks appear in the converging or diverging sections of the nozzle.

Phase planes illustrating different isentropic patterns with one or three sonic points.

Each regime is associated with a specific thermodynamic region of reservoir states, providing a comprehensive map for engineers designing high-complexity fluid systems, such as those used in organic Rankine cycles (ORC).

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the van der Waals model provides essential qualitative insights, it may overestimate the size of the non-classical region compared to more complex models like Span-Wagner. Additionally, the quasi-1D assumption does not account for 2D/3D effects like oblique shocks or boundary layer interactions.

Future work will focus on experimental validation. Facilities such as TROVA (Politecnico di Milano) and FAST (TU Delft) are expected to provide the first direct experimental evidence of these non-classical nozzle flows, confirming the theoretical framework established in this study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Steady nozzle flows of Bethe–Zel’dovich–Thompson fluids – substances exhibiting non-classical gasdynamic behaviour in a finite vapour-phase thermodynamic region in close proximity to the liquid–vapour saturation curve – are examined. Non-classical flow features include rarefaction shock waves, shock waves with either upstream or downstream sonic states and split shocks. Exact solutions for a mono-component single-phase fluid expanding from a reservoir into a stationary atmosphere through a conventional converging–diverging nozzle are determined within the quasi-one-dimensional inviscid flow approximation. The novel analytical approach makes it possible to elucidate the connection between the adiabatic, possibly non-isentropic flow field and the underlying local isentropic-flow features, including the possible qualitative alterations in passing through shock waves. Contrary to previous predictions based on isentropic-flow inspection, shock disintegration is found to occur also from reservoir states corresponding to a single sonic point. The global layout of the flow configurations produced by a monotonic decrease in the ambient pressure, namely the functioning regime, is examined for reservoir conditions resulting in single-phase flows. Accordingly, a classification of steady nozzle flows into 10 different functioning regimes is proposed. Flow conditions determining the transition between the different classes of flow are investigated and each functioning regime is associated with the corresponding thermodynamic region of reservoir states.
BibTeX
@article{guardone2016exact,
  author = {Alberto Guardone and Davide Vimercati},
  title = {{Exact solutions to non-classical steady nozzle flows of Bethe–Zel’dovich–Thompson fluids}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1017/jfm.2016.392},
}
Figure