Ignition Experiments by Shock Waves

Takashi Shibuya, Toshiroo IsobeJournal of the Mining and Metallurgical Institute of Japan 1985 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the ignition of methane-air mixtures triggered by shock waves within a shock tube apparatus. By measuring shock wave velocity and the resulting pressure ratios, the temperature ($T_5$) at the tube's end can be calculated using adiabatic compression equations. Experimental results demonstrate that methane-air mixtures (3.5–20% concentration) can be ignited solely by the force of a reflected shock wave, typically occurring at velocities between Mach 2.3 and 3.1. Ignition is characterized by a secondary pressure rise and flame detection, with measured delay times ($ au$) ranging from 0.3 to 1.0 milliseconds at temperatures between 1,100K and 2,000K.

Introduction

In underground mining environments, methane gas (firedamp) poses a persistent explosion hazard. While safety measures traditionally focus on eliminating sparks and open flames, this research addresses a more subtle threat: can the pressure wave from a primary blast itself trigger a secondary methane explosion?

When a shock wave traverses a gas, it causes near-instantaneous adiabatic compression, leading to a significant temperature spike. If this temperature exceeds the ignition threshold of the surrounding methane-air mixture, combustion can occur without any external ignition source. This paper quantifies the specific conditions—pressure, temperature, and concentration—under which this "compression ignition" takes place.

Experimental Methods

The researchers utilized a standard shock tube setup consisting of a high-pressure driver section (Hydrogen) and a low-pressure driven section containing the methane-air mixture. The primary focus was the reflected shock wave at the end of the tube.

Figure 3: x-t diagram and pressure profile showing the interaction of incident and reflected shock waves at the tube end.

As shown in the wave diagram above, the gas at the stagnation point (the end of the tube) is compressed twice: first by the incident wave and then by the reflection. This dual compression reaches the peak temperatures ($T_5$) and pressures ($P_5$) necessary for ignition. To confirm ignition events, the team employed two detection methods:

  1. Pressure Transducers: To identify the "secondary pressure rise" indicative of chemical energy release.
  2. Photocells: To detect light emission (flame) from the resulting combustion.

Key Findings and Insights

Ignition was consistently observed when shock wave speeds exceeded approximately 750 m/s (Mach 2.2). The experimental data revealed a distinct signature in the waveforms during successful ignition events.

Figure 1: Oscilloscope trace showing the simultaneous secondary pressure rise and flame detection by the photocell, confirming ignition.

A critical observation was the ignition delay ($ au$), the brief period between the arrival of the reflected shock and the onset of combustion. This delay typically lasted between 0.3 and 1.0 milliseconds. Interestingly, the study found that shock waves could induce ignition in mixtures as rich as 20% methane—well beyond the standard flammability limit of ~15%—though these extreme concentrations required longer delay times.

Kinetic analysis using Arrhenius-style plotting suggested two distinct reaction regimes. High methane concentrations (12–20%) exhibited an activation energy of approximately 50 kcal/mol, while lower concentrations (5–12%) were closer to 23 kcal/mol. This indicates that different chemical chain-reaction mechanisms dominate depending on the mixture ratio.

Conclusion

The results confirm that adiabatic compression from shock waves is a viable ignition source for methane-air mixtures in confined spaces. While a shock tube provides a controlled environment, these findings have significant safety implications for mining. Even in the absence of sparks, a shock wave traveling through a gallery could trigger a secondary explosion if the geometry allows for wave reflection and concentration. Future work should investigate how complex tunnel geometries and heat loss to walls affect these ignition thresholds in real-world scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

The pressure of shock wave measured and calculated from its velocity is able to be estimated as described in former report.And also, temperature (T5) at the end of shock tube can be calculated using pressure ratio P21 in the following equation.T21=T5/T1=[(2+α1) P21-1](α1-1+2P21)/(1+α1P21)(α1+1)where P21=P2/P1, α1=(γ1+1)/(γ1-1) and P1, T1 areinitial pressure and temperature.The studies described in this paper is the investigation of ignition of methane-air mixture by shock wave using the shock tube apparatus.Reaction between methane and oxygen is considered to advance rapidly, when concentration of methyl group ([CH3]) exceeds a certain threshold value. The time elapsed before reaching to the threshold is called a delay time (γ) for ignition. And, in the experiment, practically ignition is recognized by ascending of pressure and flames sensed by a photo cell.Experimental conditions that are set up are as follows;(1)Velocity of shock waves: 2.3 Mach-3.1 Mach(2) Concentration of CH4 in the air: 3.5-20%(3)Ignition will be appeared only at the neighborhood of end of shock tube, wherethe shock waves are reflected back and turn their propagation direction.Results obtained from the experiments are(1) Ignitions of CH4-air mixture are sometimes yielded by shock waves(2) When the gas mixture is ignited, the delay time from excitation to ignition is usually between 0.3 and 1.0 milli-seconds, and ignition temperature is assumed also 1, 100 and 2, 000K.(3) I gnition will be produced by adiabatic compression of gas mixture.
BibTeX
@article{shibuya1985ignition,
  author = {Takashi Shibuya and Toshiroo ISOBE},
  title = {{Ignition Experiments by Shock Waves}},
  journal = {Journal of the Mining and Metallurgical Institute of Japan},
  year = {1985},
  doi = {10.2473/shigentosozai1953.101.1164\_55},
}
Figure