Abstract
The performance of superconducting qubits is degraded by a poorly characterized set of energy sources breaking the Cooper pairs responsible for superconductivity, creating a condition often called "quasiparticle poisoning." Both superconducting qubits and low threshold dark matter calorimeters have observed excess bursts of quasiparticles or phonons that decrease in rate with time. Here, we show that a silicon crystal glued to its holder exhibits a rate of low-energy phonon events that is more than two orders of magnitude larger than in a functionally identical crystal suspended from its holder in a low-stress state. The excess phonon event rate in the glued crystal decreases with time since cooldown, consistent with a source of phonon bursts which contributes to quasiparticle poisoning in quantum circuits and the low-energy events observed in cryogenic calorimeters. We argue that relaxation of thermally induced stress between the glue and crystal is the source of these events.
Introduction
Superconducting qubits are fundamental building blocks for modern quantum computing architectures. However, their operational fidelity is significantly limited by "quasiparticle poisoning." This phenomenon occurs when environmental energy breaks the Cooper pairs—pairs of electrons that flow without resistance—responsible for the superconducting state. The resulting quasiparticles cause decoherence and data loss.
While researchers have successfully mitigated many external noise sources, such as stray infrared radiation and cosmic rays, a persistent background of mysterious "burst-like" energy events remains. These bursts are also observed in ultra-sensitive dark matter detectors. A critical observation is that the rate of these events typically decays over time following the initial cooldown of the system. This study investigates whether mechanical stress induced by common mounting techniques—specifically the use of cryogenic adhesives—is the primary driver behind these phonon bursts.
Experimental Design
To isolate the effects of mechanical stress, the researchers conducted a controlled experiment using two functionally identical silicon crystals operated as calorimeters in a dilution refrigerator at temperatures below 10 mK. Both crystals were equipped with Transition Edge Sensors (TESs)—superconducting films that act as extremely sensitive thermometers capable of detecting energy deposits at the electron-volt (eV) scale.
As shown in the figure above, two distinct mounting schemes were compared:
- High Stress (HS) Setup: A crystal was glued directly to a copper mount using GE varnish, a standard cryogenic adhesive. Due to the mismatched thermal contraction rates of the glue and silicon during cooldown, significant mechanical stress is induced at the interface.
- Low Stress (LS) Setup: A second crystal was suspended by thin (50 µm) aluminum wires. This novel mounting scheme was designed to minimize mechanical strain while maintaining thermal contact.
Results and Analysis
The team monitored the energy spectra and time-dependent event rates for both devices over approximately 80 hours of continuous operation. The results revealed a stark contrast between the two mounting methods.
As illustrated in the energy spectrum, the glued (HS) crystal recorded a low-energy event rate (specifically in the 3–38 eV bin) approximately 100 times higher than the suspended (LS) crystal. This massive excess of events is directly attributable to the presence of the adhesive. Furthermore, the rate of these bursts in the HS crystal was observed to decrease over time with a time constant of 6–10 days. This decay matches the behavior of residual quasiparticles observed in other superconducting qubit experiments, strongly suggesting that stress relaxation is a universal mechanism behind the poisoning seen in these systems.
Discussion
The authors propose that as the system stabilizes at cryogenic temperatures, the thermally induced stress between the glue and the crystal relaxes through microscopic failures, or microfractures. Each tiny structural snap releases a burst of athermal phonons (lattice vibrations) into the crystal substrate. These phonons then travel to the superconducting components, breaking Cooper pairs and creating the observed quasiparticle poisoning.
Simulations based on these results estimate that stress-induced events in the HS setup produce a reduced quasiparticle density ($x_{qp}$) of roughly $5.0 \times 10^{-8}$. This density is high enough to be the dominant limiting factor for many current superconducting qubit designs. Interestingly, even the low-stress setup exhibited some residual events, leading the authors to hypothesize that internal stress within the thin metal films (aluminum and tungsten) of the sensors themselves may also contribute to phonon bursts.
Conclusion
This research identifies mechanical stress relaxation in cryogenic adhesives as a major source of phonon bursts and quasiparticle poisoning. By replacing traditional gluing methods with low-stress suspension techniques, researchers can reduce the low-energy event rate by two orders of magnitude.
Future work will involve testing other common adhesives like vacuum grease and epoxy to confirm if they exhibit similar behavior. Additionally, the team plans to investigate methods for reducing the inherent stress in superconducting thin films to further lower the noise floor for both quantum computing and dark matter detection applications.
Summary updated