A stress-induced source of phonon bursts and quasiparticle poisoning

Robin Anthony-Petersen, A. Biekert, R. Bunker, C. L. Chang, Y.-y. Chang, Luke Chaplinsky, E. Fascione, Caleb W. Fink, M. Garcia-Sciveres, R. Germond, Wei Guo, Scott Hertel, Z. Hong, Noah Kurinsky, Xinran Li, J. Lin, M. Lisovenko, R. Mahapatra, Adam Mayer, D. N. McKinsey, Siddhant Mehrotra, N. Mirabolfathi, Brian Neblosky, W. A. Page, P. K. Patel, Bjoern Penning, H. Douglas Pinckney, Mark Platt, M. Pyle, M. W. Reed, R. K. Romani, Hadley Santana Queiroz, B. Sadoulet, B. Serfass, Ryan Smith, Peter Sørensen, B. Suerfu, Aritoki Suzuki, Ryan Underwood, V. Velan, Gensheng Wang, Y. Wang, S. L. Watkins, M. Williams, V. Yefremenko, Jianjie Zhang

Abstract

The performance of superconducting qubits is degraded by a poorly characterized set of energy sources breaking the Cooper pairs responsible for superconductivity, creating a condition often called "quasiparticle poisoning". Both superconducting qubits and low threshold dark matter calorimeters have observed excess bursts of quasiparticles or phonons that decrease in rate with time. Here, we show that a silicon crystal glued to its holder exhibits a rate of low-energy phonon events that is more than two orders of magnitude larger than in a functionally identical crystal suspended from its holder in a low-stress state. The excess phonon event rate in the glued crystal decreases with time since cooldown, consistent with a source of phonon bursts which contributes to quasiparticle poisoning in quantum circuits and the low-energy events observed in cryogenic calorimeters. We argue that relaxation of thermally induced stress between the glue and crystal is the source of these events.

Introduction

Superconducting qubits rely on the formation of Cooper pairs—electrons bound together at cryogenic temperatures. However, these pairs are frequently broken by unknown energy sources, creating "quasiparticles" that cause decoherence and the loss of quantum information. This phenomenon, known as quasiparticle poisoning, has been a persistent challenge in the development of scalable quantum computing. Similarly, low-threshold dark matter experiments observe a mysterious "excess" of low-energy phonon events that limit their sensitivity. While researchers have previously considered infrared radiation or environmental radioactivity as culprits, these do not fully explain the burst-like nature of the noise or its temporal decay. This study investigates whether mechanical stress from mounting hardware is the hidden source of these disturbances.

Experimental Design: High Stress vs. Low Stress

To test the stress hypothesis, researchers conducted a head-to-head comparison between two functionally identical silicon crystals equipped with Quasiparticle-trap-assisted Electrothermal Feedback Transition Edge Sensors (QETs). These sensors detect athermal phonons with eV-scale resolution.

  1. High Stress (HS): The crystal was glued to a copper mount using GE varnish. Due to mismatched thermal contraction between the glue and silicon at millikelvin temperatures, this creates significant mechanical stress.
  2. Low Stress (LS): The crystal was suspended using 50 \mu m diameter aluminum wire bonds, allowing the materials to contract independently and minimizing stress.
Figure 3: (A) Schematic of the phonon generation mechanism where microfractures at the glue interface release athermal phonons. (B) The low-stress wire-bond suspension setup. (C) The high-stress glued mounting setup.

The Mechanism of Phonon Bursts

The study proposes that as the glue-silicon interface "settles" after cooling, it undergoes microscopic fractures. Each tiny snap releases a burst of athermal phonons into the crystal. These phonons travel to the superconducting films and break Cooper pairs, creating the quasiparticles that disrupt qubit coherence or trigger spurious detector events. This mechanism explains the "bursty" nature of the noise observed in many cryogenic experiments.

Results: A 100-fold Reduction in Noise

Data collected over 80 hours revealed a dramatic difference between the two mounting methods. In the primary energy range of interest (3–38 eV), the glued HS crystal exhibited an event rate more than two orders of magnitude higher than the suspended LS crystal.

Figure 5: Energy spectrum comparing the High Stress (red) and Low Stress (blue) calorimeters. The HS setup shows a massive excess of events in the 3-38 eV range, directly attributed to mechanical stress relaxation at the glue interface.

Key findings include:

  • Quantifiable Decay: The event rate in the HS crystal followed a clear exponential decay curve with a time constant of 6–10 days, matching the expected behavior of stress relaxation. In contrast, the LS crystal's rate remained low and stable.
  • Quasiparticle Density Impact: Simulations estimated that the stress-induced phonons in the HS setup produce a quasiparticle density ($x_{qp}$) of $\approx 5.0 \times 10^{-8}$, which is high enough to be a dominant error source in many current superconducting qubit architectures.

Discussion and Future Outlook

While this work identifies mechanical stress relaxation as a major source of noise, some questions remain. Even in the low-stress setup, a residual noise floor exists, possibly due to stress within the thin metal films deposited on the silicon. Future work will explore different substrates, alternative adhesives, and the effects of repeated thermal cycling.

Nevertheless, this research offers a clear engineering path to more stable quantum computers and more sensitive dark matter detectors. Transitioning to low-stress mounting techniques can reduce phonon-induced errors by a factor of 100, potentially overcoming a significant bottleneck in the scaling of superconducting quantum processors.

Summary updated

Abstract

The performance of superconducting qubits is degraded by a poorly characterized set of energy sources breaking the Cooper pairs responsible for superconductivity, creating a condition often called "quasiparticle poisoning". Both superconducting qubits and low threshold dark matter calorimeters have observed excess bursts of quasiparticles or phonons that decrease in rate with time. Here, we show that a silicon crystal glued to its holder exhibits a rate of low-energy phonon events that is more than two orders of magnitude larger than in a functionally identical crystal suspended from its holder in a low-stress state. The excess phonon event rate in the glued crystal decreases with time since cooldown, consistent with a source of phonon bursts which contributes to quasiparticle poisoning in quantum circuits and the low-energy events observed in cryogenic calorimeters. We argue that relaxation of thermally induced stress between the glue and crystal is the source of these events.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{anthonypetersen2024stress,
  author = {Robin Anthony-Petersen and A. Biekert and R. Bunker and C. L. Chang and Y.-Y. Chang and Luke Chaplinsky and E. Fascione and Caleb W. Fink and M. Garcia-Sciveres and R. Germond and Wei Guo and Scott Hertel and Z. Hong and Noah Kurinsky and Xinran Li and J. Lin and M. Lisovenko and R. Mahapatra and Adam Mayer and D. N. McKinsey and Siddhant Mehrotra and N. Mirabolfathi and Brian Neblosky and W. A. Page and P. K. Patel and Bjoern Penning and H. Douglas Pinckney and Mark Platt and M. Pyle and M. W. Reed and R. K. Romani and Hadley Santana Queiroz and B. Sadoulet and B. Serfass and Ryan Smith and Peter Sørensen and B. Suerfu and Aritoki Suzuki and Ryan Underwood and V. Velan and Gensheng Wang and Y. Wang and S. L. Watkins and M. Williams and V. Yefremenko and Jianjie Zhang},
  title = {{A stress-induced source of phonon bursts and quasiparticle poisoning}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-50173-8},
}
Figure