Abstract
Rock-Beds are generally considered to be the most suitable storage units for heating systems combined with air heated type of solar collector in cold regions. Thermal characteristics of rock bed storage tanks were investigated by experiments using inline and stagger brick's arrangement for storage units of sub-scale model and by numerical analysis for basic models corresponding to experimental condition. The effect of bricks aligned/stagger arrays and it's dimensions on thermal storage and convection behavior in charging/discharging process were discussed, and the stagger arrangement of the bricks was cleared to be the most effective in storage performance due to the convective heat transfer enhancement and the area increasing.
Introduction
Solar energy is a vast but intermittent resource. In cold regions, solar heating systems require efficient, low-cost thermal energy storage (TES) to bridge the gap between sunny periods and nighttime heating needs. Rock-bed storage—using bricks or stones as a medium—is a popular choice due to its low cost. However, the geometric arrangement (inline vs. staggered) and orientation (vertical vs. horizontal) of bricks significantly affect airflow, pressure drop, and overall heat storage capacity.
Methodology
The researchers employed a dual approach combining physical experiments with numerical simulations. A sub-scale model was constructed featuring a rock-bed tank, a centrifugal fan for air circulation, and a heater to simulate solar gain.
Four specific configurations using 27 bricks were tested to evaluate performance:
- Array 1: Vertical bricks in a 9x3 inline (grid) pattern.
- Array 2: Vertical bricks in a staggered (zigzag) pattern.
- Array 3: Horizontal bricks stacked in three layers (inline).
- Array 4: Horizontal bricks with the middle layer shifted (staggered).
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) was utilized to visualize streamlines and pressure distributions, providing a physical explanation for the experimental observations regarding heat transfer efficiency.
Key Insights and Numerical Analysis
Numerical simulations revealed that staggered arrangements promote air turbulence, which is critical for efficient heat transfer. In an inline grid, air tends to flow straight through channels, often missing the "back" of the bricks. In a staggered layout, the air is forced to "collide" with the bricks, ensuring that the entire surface area participates in heat exchange.
While staggered arrays increase pressure loss (approximately 1.5x higher than inline), they create a more uniform temperature distribution across the bed, leading to superior thermal performance. Vertical brick arrangements (Arrays 1 & 2) outperformed horizontal ones (Arrays 3 & 4) because vertical placement leaves more gaps for air to contact the brick faces, effectively increasing the convective heat transfer area.
Results
- Array 2 (Staggered Vertical) was the most effective configuration, reaching higher internal temperatures during charging and maintaining usable heat for the longest duration.
- Discharge Duration: Array 2 maintained an air output > 20°C for 125 minutes, compared to only 55 minutes for horizontal arrangements.
- Heat Recovery: The effective energy recovery ratio ranged from 80% to 92%, with staggered vertical layouts showing the most efficient utilization of stored energy.
- Pressure Loss: The maximum pressure drop for the staggered array was 0.035 Pa, compared to 0.024 Pa for the inline array.
Conclusion
The physical arrangement of bricks in a rock-bed thermal storage system significantly impacts its efficiency. A staggered vertical arrangement achieves superior heat exchange and longer discharge times, making it a more effective solution for solar heating in cold climates. Future work should investigate scale effects and the influence of storage tank dimensions on the timing of charging and discharging cycles to further optimize these low-cost systems.
Summary updated