457 Experimental Study on A Cross Flow Type of Heat Exchanger : Setting An Inserted Plate with Slit Holes in Ducts

Kazuhiko Sato, Himsar Ambarita, K. Ogawa, Hiroshi Kurotani, Jun Suzuki, Koki KishinamiThe Proceedings of the Symposium on Environmental Engineering 2005 · DOI

Abstract

Cross/counter flow types of heat exchanger seem likely to have superior characteristics in regard to design a large heat transfer surface area per unit volume by alternately laminating the elements. In this paper, a cross flow type of heat exchanger are examined by experiment, and inserted plate with/without slit holes setting in ducts are proposed to be up the exchanging heat performance from the view point of the enhancement of heat transfer coefficient and pressure loss decreasing, substituting the conventional heat transfer surface increasing technique. Experimental results for 4 cases (CFHE without inserted plate, and inserted plate with/without slit holes) are discussed as a relation of temperature effectiveness and number of heat transfer unit and exergy transfer, referred to the numerical results taking the effect of the inserted plate with/without slit holes on flow, heat transfer behaviors and pressure decreasing into consideration.

Introduction

In the field of thermal management, the primary objective is often to maximize heat transfer while minimizing the size, weight, and operational cost of the equipment. Traditionally, this is achieved by increasing the surface area through the addition of fins or plates. However, in applications characterized by low temperature differences—such as waste heat recovery—simply adding more material can lead to bulky and expensive designs.

An alternative strategy is to increase the heat transfer coefficient by inducing turbulence or disrupting the thermal boundary layer. While inserting plates into a duct is a known method for triggering this turbulence, it typically incurs a significant "pressure drop tax." High pressure drops force fans to work harder, consuming more energy and potentially offsetting efficiency gains. This paper investigates whether incorporating strategically placed "slit holes" into these inserted plates can offer a solution: high heat transfer performance with manageable pressure loss.

Experimental Methodology

The researchers employed a combination of physical experimental testing and numerical simulations (CFD) to analyze four specific duct configurations: a baseline standard duct, a duct with solid plates, and ducts with plates featuring 1.5mm and 3.5mm slits.

Schematic of the experimental apparatus used to evaluate the cross-flow heat exchanger.

The experimental rig utilized a cross-flow heat exchanger unit equipped with heaters, variable speed fans, and 12 Chromel-Alumel thermocouples to track temperature changes. The team measured temperature efficiency ($\eta_T$), the Number of Heat Transfer Units (NTU), exergy transfer, and pressure loss across various flow velocities ranging from 0.5 to 1.5 m/s.

Key Insights: Vortex Dynamics and Slit Geometry

Numerical simulations provided critical insight into the flow behavior within the ducts. Inserting plates creates large vortices that break up the stagnant boundary layer of air near the duct walls—the primary barrier to efficient heat transfer. However, solid plates often create large "dead zones" behind them, which contribute heavily to pressure loss.

The introduction of slits acts as a "pressure relief valve." By allowing a portion of the air to pass through the plate rather than forcing it entirely around the edges, the slits significantly reduce the size of these stagnant zones. While solid plates offer the highest absolute heat transfer coefficient, the researchers found that at high fan power settings, the 3.5mm slit plates moved more total heat ($Q$) because the lower pressure resistance allowed the fan to maintain a higher overall flow rate.

Results and Performance Analysis

The experimental results demonstrated that heat exchangers equipped with inserted plates achieved temperature efficiencies and heat transfer coefficients 1.5 to 2 times higher than the baseline configuration without plates.

Pressure loss (P) and heat transfer (Q) performance across different flow velocities for the tested configurations.

Crucially, the addition of slits successfully mitigated the pressure drop. The 3.5mm slit configuration reduced the pressure loss coefficient by 20% to 30% compared to solid plates while maintaining 85% to 115% of the heat transfer performance. These findings suggest that by using these inserts, a heat exchanger can achieve the same cooling capacity as a much larger unit, leading to significant savings in material costs and weight.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This study confirms that strategically placed slit holes in inserted plates can significantly enhance the performance of cross-flow heat exchangers. Although experimental pressure reduction did not fully reach the levels predicted by 2D numerical models—likely due to complex 3D flow effects—the overall efficiency gains are substantial. Future research will explore optimizing slit geometry (such as tapered or chevron shapes) and investigating the long-term durability and fouling resistance of these designs in industrial-scale heat recovery systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cross/counter flow types of heat exchanger seem likely to have superior characteristics in regard to design a large heat transfer surface area per unit volume by alternately laminating the elements. In this paper, a cross flow type of heat exchanger are examined by experiment, and inserted plate with/without slit holes setting in ducts are proposed to be up the exchanging heat performance from the view point of the enhancement of heat transfer coefficient and pressure loss decreasing, substituting the conventional heat transfer surface increasing technique. Experimental results for 4 cases (CFHE without inserted plate, and inserted plate with/without slit holes) are discussed as a relation of temperature effectiveness and number of heat transfer unit and exergy transfer, referred to the numerical results taking the effect of the inserted plate with/without slit holes on flow, heat transfer behaviors and pressure decreasing into consideration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sato2005experimental,
  author = {Kazuhiko Sato and Himsar Ambarita and K. Ogawa and Hiroshi Kurotani and Jun Suzuki and Koki Kishinami},
  title = {{457 Experimental Study on A Cross Flow Type of Heat Exchanger : Setting An Inserted Plate with Slit Holes in Ducts}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of the Symposium on Environmental Engineering},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmeenv.2005.15.531},
}
Figure