Retraction Note to: Self-assembly of N doped 3D porous carbon frameworks from carbon quantum dots and its application for oxygen reduction reaction

Chao Chen, Zexu Sun, Yueping Li, Liyuan Yi, Haoming HuJournal of Materials Science Materials in Electronics 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Overview

In 2021, the Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics formally retracted the 2017 study titled "Self-assembly of N doped 3D porous carbon frameworks from carbon quantum dots and its application for oxygen reduction reaction." This retraction serves as a necessary correction to the scientific record due to significant ethical violations identified post-publication.

Ethical Violations and Investigation

The decision to retract was reached following an investigation by the journal's Editor-in-Chief. The inquiry confirmed two major breaches of research integrity:

  • Significant Content Overlap: The article shared substantial material with a previously published paper by Jiang et al. (2017).
  • Simultaneous Submission: The authors submitted the manuscript to multiple journals concurrently, violating the fundamental agreement of exclusivity during the peer-review process.

These actions, often referred to as redundant publication or "salami slicing," undermine the principles of novelty and transparency that are essential to scientific progress.

Author Concurrence and Resolution

The lead author, Chao Chen, confirmed on behalf of all co-authors that they agreed with the retraction. By acknowledging these overlaps and the simultaneous submission, the authors have cooperated in the removal of the redundant work. The retraction note specifically references the conflicting works to guide researchers toward the legitimate primary sources of the data.

The Importance of Digital Integrity Tools

This case highlights the "long tail" of editorial oversight, where ethical breaches are corrected years after the initial publication. A key component of modern digital publishing is the ability to flag such changes to readers dynamically.

The "Check for updates" feature is a vital tool for ensuring researchers access the most current status of a publication.

The "Check for updates" icon is a critical mechanism for research integrity. It ensures that any researcher accessing the PDF is immediately alerted if the paper's status has changed—from a valid study to a retracted one—preventing the continued citation of unreliable or redundant data.

Conclusion

While the original research addressed the high-demand field of oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) catalysts for fuel cells, the ethical failures in its publication necessitated its removal. This retraction reinforces the commitment of academic journals to maintain a clean and honest scientific record, ensuring that only original and ethically submitted work remains part of the active literature.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{chen2021retraction,
  author = {Chao Chen and Zexu Sun and Yueping Li and Liyuan Yi and Haoming Hu},
  title = {{Retraction Note to: Self-assembly of N doped 3D porous carbon frameworks from carbon quantum dots and its application for oxygen reduction reaction}},
  journal = {Journal of Materials Science Materials in Electronics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s10854-021-05873-y},
}
Figure