In a significant move to preserve research integrity, the journal Engineering with Computers has formally retracted the 2020 study titled "Chaotic simulation of the multi-phase reinforced thermo-elastic disk using GDQM." This retraction highlights the critical role of editorial oversight in identifying self-plagiarism and peer-review manipulation within the engineering sciences.
Background of the Retraction
The decision to retract the article (originally published at https://doi.org/10.1007/s00366-020-01144-2) followed an extensive investigation by the journal’s Editor-in-Chief. The investigation concluded that the paper failed to meet the ethical standards required for peer-reviewed publication, leading to its formal removal from the scientific record.
Identified Ethical Breaches
The retraction note specifies two major violations of publication ethics:
1. Redundancy and "Salami Slicing"
The investigation revealed a "significant overlap" between the retracted paper and two previous publications by the same author group in Composite Structures and the European Journal of Mechanics - A/Solids. This practice, often called "salami slicing," involves fragmenting a single research project into multiple papers to artificially inflate a researcher's publication record. By presenting nearly identical findings across different venues, the authors compromised the principle of original contribution.
2. Subversion of Peer Review
Perhaps more concerning was the discovery of attempts to "subvert the peer review process." While the specific methods used were not detailed in the note, such subversion often involves the use of fake reviewer accounts or "peer-review rings" where authors collude to provide favorable reviews for one another. This breach undermines the fundamental quality control mechanism that ensures the validity of published research.
Methodological Context: GDQM
The original research utilized the Generalized Differential Quadrature Method (GDQM), a numerical technique commonly employed to solve differential equations in structural mechanics, particularly for plates and shells. The study aimed to model the chaotic vibrations and thermo-elastic behavior of multi-phase reinforced disks. However, the journal determined that the application of GDQM in this instance was too derivative of the authors' prior work to be considered a novel advancement in the field.
Author Responses and Institutional Implications
The retraction process revealed a divide among the authors. M.S.H. Al-Furjan, M. Habibi, H. Safarpour, and A. Tounsi formally disagreed with the retraction, while the remaining three authors did not respond to the journal's inquiries. This disagreement suggests a conflict between the editorial board's findings on originality and the authors' own interpretations of their work.
Conclusion
The retraction of this study serves as a cautionary tale for the engineering community. It reinforces the necessity for researchers to adhere to strict ethical guidelines regarding originality and peer-review integrity. As journals become increasingly sophisticated in detecting "salami slicing" and review fraud, the maintenance of a clean and honest scientific record remains a top priority for publishers like Springer Nature.
Note: This article is a summary of the official Retraction Note issued by Engineering with Computers.
Summary updated