Retraction Note: Adoption of human metabolic processes as Data Quality Based Models

Alladoumbaye Ngueilbaye, Hongzhi Wang, Mehak Khan, Daouda Ahmat MahamatJournal of Supercomputing 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Overview

The Journal of Supercomputing has officially retracted the 2020 article titled "Adoption of human metabolic processes as Data Quality Based Models." This retraction, finalized on July 15, 2024, follows an internal investigation that revealed significant integrity concerns, rendering the original findings unreliable for the scientific community.

The Springer logo, representing the publisher of the Journal of Supercomputing.

Integrity Issues and Red Flags

The decision to retract was driven by the discovery of several "red flags" indicative of low-integrity or potentially automated content generation. These issues undermine the core validity of the research:

  • Non-standard Phrasing: The paper utilized "tortured phrases," which often occur when authors use automated paraphrasing tools to evade plagiarism detection. This results in bizarre synonyms for established technical terms (e.g., changing "random forest" to "arbitrary bush").
  • Unsupported Citations: The investigation found numerous instances where citations did not support the accompanying text, a practice often referred to as "citation stuffing."
  • Image Irregularities: Visual data presented in the original work showed signs of potential manipulation or fabrication, further compromising the study's credibility.

Investigative Process and Author Response

The Editor-in-Chief initiated the investigation and ultimately lost confidence in the paper's results and conclusions. A critical factor in the formal retraction was the authors' lack of response to correspondence regarding these discrepancies. While the original paper listed affiliations with the Harbin Institute of Technology (China) and the University of N’Djamena (Chad), the publisher remains neutral regarding jurisdictional claims.

Conclusion and Future Implications

The formal removal of this paper from the scientific record highlights the necessity for more rigorous peer-review processes.

The 'Check for updates' icon, which identifies the current status of the research paper.

The scientific community must prioritize the detection of linguistic anomalies and verify citation relevance to prevent the infiltration of unreliable data into academic journals. The findings of the original 2020 study are officially deemed unreliable and should no longer be cited or utilized as a basis for further research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{ngueilbaye2024retraction,
  author = {Alladoumbaye Ngueilbaye and Hongzhi Wang and Mehak Khan and Daouda Ahmat Mahamat},
  title = {{Retraction Note: Adoption of human metabolic processes as Data Quality Based Models}},
  journal = {The Journal of Supercomputing},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s11227-024-06358-5},
}
Figure