Retraction Note: Exploring the role of TESOL and digital technology in attitudinal change and sustainable learning for students of higher education

Fu Chen, Yanhong Gao, Xin WangBMC 2025 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

This note announces the formal retraction of the article "Exploring the role of TESOL and digital technology in attitudinal change and sustainable learning for students of higher education," originally published in BMC Psychology (2023) 11:320. Following a publisher-led investigation into systemic failures in the peer review and editorial processes, the findings and conclusions of the original study are now considered unreliable and have been withdrawn from the scientific record.

Introduction

In May 2025, the publisher of BMC Psychology issued a formal retraction for a 2023 study that attempted to explore the intersection of Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages (TESOL), digital technology, and student attitudinal change. While the original paper aimed to contribute to the field of educational psychology, a post-publication investigation revealed that the integrity of the work was fundamentally compromised. This retraction serves as a corrective measure to address the presence of unreliable research in the academic literature.

Investigation and Findings

The retraction was the result of a comprehensive investigation by Springer Nature into a specific guest-edited issue. The inquiry uncovered a pattern of concerns typical of "paper mill" activity, which undermined the scientific validity of the publication. Key findings included:

  • Compromised Editorial Handling: The standard editorial oversight and gatekeeping processes were found to have been bypassed or manipulated.
  • Peer Review Manipulation: The process intended to ensure the quality and validity of the research was deemed unreliable, meaning the paper did not undergo rigorous scientific scrutiny.
  • Inappropriate Content: The article contained "inappropriate or irrelevant references" and content that fell outside the scope of the journal and the specific guest-edited issue.

Due to these systemic failures, the Editor-in-Chief and the publisher stated they "no longer have confidence in the results and conclusions" of the work.

Author Accountability

Author engagement during the retraction process was notably absent. One author, Xin Wang, did not explicitly agree or disagree with the retraction notice, while the remaining authors failed to respond to any correspondence from the publisher. This lack of responsiveness is a significant hurdle in addressing scientific misconduct and determining the exact nature of the original errors.

Conclusion and Future Implications

The formal retraction of this article (effective May 21, 2025) highlights a critical vulnerability in academic publishing regarding guest-edited or "Special Issues." For the research community, this note signals the necessity of excluding the retracted 2023 study from future literature reviews and meta-analyses to prevent the propagation of flawed data. The publisher is continuing to investigate other articles within the same guest-edited issue to ensure the integrity of the remaining academic record and to implement more robust oversight for future volumes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2025retraction,
  author = {Fu Chen and Yanhong Gao and Xin Wang},
  title = {{Retraction Note: Exploring the role of TESOL and digital technology in attitudinal change and sustainable learning for students of higher education}},
  booktitle = {BMC},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s40359-025-02874-y},
}
Figure