Retraction Note: Refining Parkinson’s neurological disorder identification through deep transfer learning

Amina Naseer, Monail Rani, Saeeda Naz, Imran Razzak, Muhammad Imran, Guandong XuNeural 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Summary

This document serves as a formal retraction of the 2019 study "Refining Parkinson’s neurological disorder identification through deep transfer learning," originally published in the journal Neural Computing and Applications. The retraction, finalized in April 2024, follows an investigation that revealed systemic failures in the editorial and peer-review processes for the guest-edited issue in which the paper appeared.

Background and Context

The original research aimed to address the technical challenge of identifying Parkinson’s disease using deep transfer learning architectures. While the identification of neurological disorders is a critical area of medical AI research, the validity of the specific methodologies and findings presented in the 2019 paper has been nullified by the publisher due to procedural compromises.

Reasons for Retraction

The Editor-in-Chief initiated the retraction after a post-publication review identified several red flags that undermined the study's credibility:

  • Compromised Editorial Handling: The investigation concluded that the peer-review process was not conducted with the necessary rigor, leading to a breakdown in the journal's standard quality control mechanisms.
  • Irrelevant Citations: The article contained "inappropriate or irrelevant references," a hallmark often associated with citation manipulation or "paper mill" activity intended to artificially inflate h-indexes.
  • Scope Misalignment: The paper was found to be outside the intended scope of the journal, suggesting it may have bypassed standard screening protocols.

Author Responses and Communication

The retraction process revealed a lack of consensus among the original research team. Authors Imran Razzak and Saeeda Naz formally disagreed with the retraction. Conversely, the publisher was unable to establish contact with Amina Naseer, Monail Rani, and Guandong Xu through their provided email addresses, and author Muhammad Imran did not respond to inquiries. This lack of communication further complicated the resolution of the investigation.

Conclusion and Significance

The primary result of this note is the formal removal of the study's findings from the body of reliable scientific literature. The Editor-in-Chief has explicitly stated a total loss of confidence in the paper’s results and conclusions.

For the broader research community, this case serves as a cautionary tale regarding the vulnerabilities of the "guest-edited" special issue model. It highlights the ongoing efforts by publishers like Springer Nature to retrospectively audit and "clean up" the scientific record, reinforcing the need for researchers to approach papers from compromised special issues with a high degree of skepticism.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{naseer2024retraction,
  author = {Amina Naseer and Monail Rani and Saeeda Naz and Imran Razzak and Muhammad Imran and Guandong Xu},
  title = {{Retraction Note: Refining Parkinson’s neurological disorder identification through deep transfer learning}},
  booktitle = {Neural},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s00521-024-09843-3},
}
Figure