Retraction Note: Towards high-quality energy development: role of trade liberalization

Xueyang Wang, Xiumei Sun, Mahmood Ahmad, Jiawei ChenEconomic 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

This paper serves as a formal retraction of the study titled "Towards high-quality energy development: role of trade liberalization," which was originally published in Economic Change and Restructuring (2024) 57:6. The decision to retract was made by the Publisher, Springer Nature, in conjunction with the journal's Editor-in-Chief following a detailed internal investigation.

The Investigation and Findings

The primary driver for this retraction was a failure in the "gatekeeping" process of scientific literature. The article was part of a guest-edited collection, a format that the investigation revealed to be vulnerable to compromised peer-review processes.

Upon review, the Publisher and Editor-in-Chief determined that the peer-review oversight was insufficient to guarantee the scientific integrity of the work. Consequently, the Publisher has explicitly stated they no longer have confidence in the results and conclusions presented in the original paper. This indicates that the flaws identified were not merely administrative but cast doubt on the substantive validity of the research itself.

Systemic Vulnerability in Academic Publishing

This case highlights a recurring challenge within academic publishing: the management of guest-edited collections. While these collections allow for focused exploration of specific topics, they can sometimes bypass the rigorous, standard peer-review oversight typically provided by a journal’s main editorial board. The retraction underscores the necessity for more robust mechanisms to ensure that all published research, regardless of the editorial path, meets the highest standards of scrutiny.

Author Responses and Disagreement

The retraction process revealed a lack of consensus among the original research team. Authors Mahmood Ahmad and Wang Xueyang officially recorded their disagreement with the retraction decision. The other two authors involved in the study did not respond to correspondence from the Publisher regarding the investigation or the subsequent retraction notice. Such disagreements are not uncommon in high-stakes retractions where authors may continue to stand by their findings despite institutional determinations of procedural or substantive failure.

Conclusion

As of this notice, the article "Towards high-quality energy development: role of trade liberalization" is officially retracted. It should no longer be cited as a valid source of scientific findings or used to inform policy or further research in the field of energy development and trade liberalization. This action reflects the commitment of the editorial board and the publisher to maintaining the integrity of the scientific record.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2024retraction,
  author = {Xueyang Wang and Xiumei Sun and Mahmood Ahmad and Jiawei Chen},
  title = {{Retraction Note: Towards high-quality energy development: role of trade liberalization}},
  booktitle = {Economic},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s10644-024-09764-0},
}
Figure