Modeling Early Universe Relic Abundances

20 concepts15 papers1 proposal

To understand why our universe looks the way it does today, cosmologists must answer a fundamental question: how did the hot, dense plasma of the early universe freeze out into the precise abundances of dark matter and baryonic matter we observe?

The answer lies in tracking the non-equilibrium thermodynamics of the expanding universe. As space expanded, the cosmic temperature dropped, and particle interaction rates fell. When the rate of an interaction dropped below the Hubble expansion rate, particles could no longer find each other fast enough to annihilate or transform. At this precise moment, their cosmic abundance "froze out," leaving behind a stable relic density.

To calculate these abundances, physicists use a hierarchy of transport equations. Depending on the complexity of the dark sector, these range from classical coupled Boltzmann equations to fully quantum transport frameworks.

The Core Engine: Coupled Boltzmann Equations

The mathematical foundation for relic density calculations is the Boltzmann equation. In an expanding universe, the time evolution of a particle species' number density $n$ is governed by a competition between the cosmic expansion rate $H$ and the thermally averaged interaction cross-section $\langle \sigma v \rangle$:

$$\frac{dn}{dt} + 3Hn = -\langle \sigma v \rangle \left( n^2 - n_{\text{eq}}^2 \right)$$

The $3Hn$ term represents the dilution of particles due to the stretching of space, while the right side tracks how particle annihilations push the system back toward its thermal equilibrium density $n_{\text{eq}}$.

When a theory introduces multiple interacting particles or hidden sectors, a single equation is no longer sufficient. Instead, we must solve a system of coupled Boltzmann equations. For example, Cheung et al. demonstrate how dark matter originating in a hidden sector requires tracking the simultaneous evolution of both visible and hidden sector densities as they exchange energy through freeze-out and decay mechanisms.

These coupled equations are also vital when tracking how different types of cosmic abundances influence one another. D’Eramo et al. utilize Boltzmann equations to model "dark matter assimilation," a process where heavy, quasi-stable particles interact with the early universe's baryon asymmetry to regulate the final dark matter number density. Similarly, Fonseca et al. solve coupled systems to simulate shared asymmetries, showing how an unstable mediator can dynamically link the generation of dark matter abundance directly to the baryon asymmetry of the universe.

Even within simpler dark sectors, the specific choice of annihilation channels dictates the freeze-out behavior. Nelson shows that scalar dark matter annihilating into sterile neutrinos can successfully regulate MeV-scale dark matter density while satisfying modern cosmic microwave background constraints. In more complex, strongly interacting dark sectors, Bernreuther et al. demonstrate that tracking specific dark pion annihilations ($\pi\pi \to \rho\rho$) within the Boltzmann framework is critical to determining the final dark matter freeze-out abundance.

The Compressed Regime: Co-Annihilation Dynamics

The standard freeze-out model assumes that dark matter annihilates only with itself. However, this picture changes dramatically if the dark sector contains multiple particle species with nearly identical masses—a scenario known as a degenerate or compressed mass spectrum.

When the mass splitting $\Delta m$ between the dark matter candidate and a heavier partner is small relative to the cosmic temperature ($T \sim \Delta m$), the heavier states are easily produced in the thermal bath. Because they are thermally accessible, the dark matter can scatter off these heavier partners, or the heavier partners can annihilate with each other. This collective behavior is called co-annihilation.

Standard Freeze-out:   [Dark Matter] + [Dark Matter]  ──> [Standard Model]
Co-annihilation:       [Dark Matter] + [Heavy Partner] ──> [Standard Model]
                       [Heavy Partner] + [Heavy Partner] ──> [Standard Model]

Co-annihilation acts as an efficiency booster for particle depletion. As Bertone et al. show in global fits of Minimal Universal Extra Dimensions, highly degenerate mass spectra trigger significant co-annihilation processes. Without accounting for these extra channels, models with weak individual interaction strengths would predict an overabundance of dark matter, violating cosmological observations.

The final relic density in these scenarios is exceptionally sensitive to the exact mass splitting. Blinov et al. demonstrate this sensitivity within the Inert Doublet Model, where the efficiency of the co-annihilation channels drops exponentially as the mass splitting widens. This sensitivity can be leveraged to evade experimental constraints; Hamaguchi shows that maintaining a narrow mass splitting of approximately 40 GeV between dark matter and heavier colored particles allows for efficient co-annihilation, matching the observed cosmic abundance while keeping the particles hidden from collider detection limits.

This mechanism applies broadly across diverse model architectures. Chen and Takhistov establish that when multiple dark matter flavors possess nearly identical masses, they undergo joint co-annihilation processes that fundamentally alter the relic density calculation compared to single-flavor models. Furthermore, Acaroğlu et al. demonstrate that even in "conversion-driven" freeze-out scenarios where dark matter couplings are incredibly weak, the presence of nearby co-annihilating partners completely dominates the evolution of the final cosmic abundance.

Non-Thermal Evolution and Entropy Dilution

The universe may not have always been a simple, radiation-dominated thermal bath. In many string theory and supergravity frameworks, long-lived scalar fields called moduli can dominate the energy density of the early universe. When these fields eventually oscillate and decay, they fundamentally alter the relic density landscape.

First, the decay of these heavy fields can directly produce dark matter particles outside of thermal equilibrium—a process known as non-thermal production. Acharya et al. simulate this evolution by solving coupled Friedmann and Boltzmann equations, demonstrating that non-thermal production from moduli decay can naturally yield the correct order-of-magnitude relic density for Wino-like dark matter.

Second, the decay of these massive fields dumps a massive amount of entropy into the surrounding plasma, a phenomenon called reheating. This sudden injection of entropy acts as a cosmic dilution mechanism, washing out the density of any particles that froze out prior to the decay.

Blinov et al. model this coupled energy density evolution to show how tracking the balance between decaying scalar fields, radiation, and stable particles can resolve the overproduction of the lightest supersymmetric partner.

This entropy dilution can also rescue models that would otherwise be ruled out by astrophysical data. Bae et al. demonstrate that when low-mass axinos are produced via a freeze-in mechanism, the subsequent entropy dilution from late-decaying fields creates a "colder" phase-space distribution. This lower temperature prevents the dark matter from washing out small-scale cosmic structures, reconciling the relic density requirements with Lyman-$\alpha$ forest observations.

Spatial Inhomogeneity and Quantum Transport

Standard Boltzmann equations assume that the universe is perfectly homogeneous and isotropic. However, during a first-order cosmological phase transition—such as the electroweak phase transition—this assumption breaks down. Instead, bubbles of a new vacuum state nucleate and expand through the plasma, creating highly localized, violent environments.

This spatial inhomogeneity is the birthplace of electroweak baryogenesis, the mechanism proposed to explain why the universe contains more matter than antimatter. As the bubble walls sweep through the plasma, particles scatter off the moving boundaries. If these interactions violate CP symmetry (Charge Conjugation + Parity), they generate a local asymmetry between matter and antimatter.

To model this accurately, classical Boltzmann equations are insufficient because they neglect quantum coherence and particle diffusion across the spatial boundary. Instead, physicists must use Quantum Boltzmann Equations or quantum transport equations.

  [ Symmetric Phase: Plasma ]  ──>  | Bubble Wall |  ──>  [ Broken Phase: Inside Bubble ]
  (CP-violating scattering occurs right at the boundary, driven by quantum transport)

Kozaczuk and Profumo employ these quantum transport equations to numerically model how CP-violating interactions and particle diffusion operate in the plasma near expanding bubble walls, mapping out the precise parameter space where the correct baryon-to-entropy ratio can be generated.

By tracking how these particle densities evolve and diffuse across the vacuum boundaries, Kozaczuk et al. demonstrate that resonant sfermion sources (such as tau sleptons) can mediate the transport of these asymmetries. This quantum transport framework allows researchers to directly connect the macroscopic baryon abundance of our universe to microscopic parameters testable at modern colliders.

Key Foundational Work

Global fits of the minimal universal extra dimensions scenario (2011) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.
Dark Matter Assimilation into the Baryon Asymmetry (2011) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.
Origins of hidden sector dark matter I: cosmology (2011) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.
History & citationVersion 1 · 2026-10-04

Current · Permanent link

View frozen version 1

Cite this direction

Latest version (a living page):

@misc{lacuna_relic_density_calculation_e7141570,
  title = {relic density calculation},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/relic-density-calculation/rdr_e7141570b6eb424abe0d21627f305621},
  note = {Latest version of a living research direction; cite a version for a fixed text. Accessed 2026-11-20},
}

This exact version (version 1, frozen text):

@misc{lacuna_relic_density_calculation_e7141570_v1,
  title = {relic density calculation},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/relic-density-calculation/rdr_e7141570b6eb424abe0d21627f305621/v/1},
  note = {Version 1, frozen 2026-10-04. Accessed 2026-11-20},
}
About

These directions overlap with this one through shared papers.

See something wrong? Report a mistake