Abstract
The inert doublet model relies on a discrete symmetry to prevent couplings of the new scalars to Standard Model fermions. This stabilizes the lightest inert state, which can then contribute to the observed dark matter density. In the presence of additional approximate symmetries, the resulting spectrum of exotic scalars can be compressed. Here, we study the phenomenological and cosmological implications of this scenario. We derive new limits on the compressed inert doublet model from LEP, and outline the prospects for exclusion and discovery of this model at dark matter experiments, the LHC, and future colliders.
Introduction
The Inert Doublet Model (IDM) is a minimal extension of the Standard Model (SM) that introduces a second scalar doublet. This doublet is odd under a discrete $Z_2$ symmetry, which prevents its coupling to SM fermions and renders the lightest inert state a viable dark matter (DM) candidate. While the IDM is well-studied, this work focuses on the "compressed" regime where mass splittings between the inert scalars ($H, A, H^\pm$) are small. Such a scenario is theoretically motivated and presents unique experimental challenges, as the decay products of heavier states are often too "soft" to be detected by standard collider triggers.
Theoretical Motivation: Natural Compression
A compressed mass spectrum in the IDM is not merely a fine-tuned choice of parameters but is often "technically natural." This compression is protected by approximate symmetries, such as $U(1)$ or $SU(2)$, which prevent large quantum corrections from widening the mass gaps.
As shown in Figure 1, the mass splitting $\Delta^\pm$ remains relatively stable under Renormalization Group (RG) evolution. This stability ensures that if the model exhibits compression at a high energy scale (e.g., the grand unification scale), this feature persists down to the electroweak scale, where it dictates the model's phenomenology.
Experimental Challenges: The Softness Problem
The primary experimental challenge in the compressed IDM is the "softness" of decay products. When a heavier inert state (like the pseudoscalar $A$ or the charged Higgs $H^\pm$) decays into the lightest state (the DM candidate $H$), the energy released is proportional to the mass difference $\Delta$.
Figure 2 illustrates how the lifetime $\tau$ of these states increases as the mass splitting $\Delta$ decreases. For very small splittings, the emitted leptons or quarks carry so little transverse momentum ($p_T$) that they fail to trigger standard LHC detectors. This "stealthy" behavior creates a blind spot for traditional searches, necessitating alternative strategies like mono-jet or mono-photon searches, where the entire inert system recoils against a single high-energy object.
Methodology and Results
The authors utilized a multi-pronged approach, combining theoretical RG analysis with experimental simulations. Key components included:
- Relic Density: Using
micrOMEGAsto calculate DM abundance, highlighting the dominance of coannihilation in the compressed regime. - LEP Recasting: Re-analyzing archival data from the OPAL experiment. The clean $e^+e^-$ environment at LEP provides superior sensitivity to soft particles compared to the high-background environment of the LHC.
- Collider Projections: Simulating future reaches for the 14 TeV LHC, a 100 TeV $pp$ collider, and the International Linear Collider (ILC).
Results indicate that LEP data still provides the most stringent limits for low-mass scalars, excluding masses up to ~90 GeV for $\Delta > 5$ GeV. For smaller splittings, the LHC currently has a significant blind spot. Future high-luminosity runs and next-generation colliders could push these limits significantly, potentially reaching masses up to 200 GeV.
Conclusion
The compressed Inert Doublet Model offers a compelling and natural explanation for dark matter that remains difficult to detect with current LHC strategies. While the "softness" of its signals allows it to hide in plain sight, a combination of re-analyzed legacy data and future high-precision collider experiments offers a path toward discovery. Closing the remaining mass gaps will require a concerted effort across collider physics and next-generation direct detection experiments.
Summary updated