Abstract: Moduli fields with Planck-suppressed couplings to light species are common in string compactifications. Decays of these moduli can reheat the Universe at a late time and produce dark matter nonthermally. For generic moduli fields motivated by string theory with masses similar to that of the gravitino and TeV-scale superpartners in the minimal supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM), the nonthermal production of the lightest superpartner (LSP) tends to create an unacceptably large relic density or too strong of an indirect detection signal. We call this the moduli-induced LSP problem of the MSSM. In this paper we investigate extensions of the MSSM containing new LSP candidates that can alleviate this tension. We examine the viability of this scenario in models with light Abelian and non-Abelian hidden sectors and symmetric or asymmetric dark matter. In these extensions it is possible, though somewhat challenging, to avoid a moduli-induced LSP problem. In all but the asymmetric scenario, the LSP can account for only a small fraction of the observed dark matter density.
Introduction
In string theory-inspired cosmology, the early universe is often dominated by "moduli"—scalar fields that characterize the geometry of extra dimensions. These fields are characterized by Planck-suppressed couplings, meaning they interact very weakly with the visible sector. As the universe expands, these moduli eventually decay, a process that "reheats" the universe and produces a significant population of particles. Among these decay products is the Lightest Supersymmetric Partner (LSP), a primary candidate for dark matter within the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM).
However, this nonthermal production mechanism introduces a severe theoretical tension. For typical moduli masses (approximately 100 TeV), the resulting relic density of LSPs is significantly higher than what is observed in our universe. Attempts to resolve this by increasing the particle annihilation rate—thereby reducing the density—lead to a secondary conflict: the annihilation signals (such as gamma rays) would be so intense that they should have been detected by current telescopes. This "catch-22" is known as the moduli-induced LSP problem.
The Moduli-Induced LSP Problem
The MSSM faces a crisis in the context of moduli-induced reheating. Standard candidates like the wino or higgsino are largely ruled out because they cannot simultaneously satisfy the observed dark matter density and the stringent limits set by indirect detection experiments. If the LSP is to survive as a dark matter candidate in a moduli-dominated early universe, the MSSM must be extended.
This research investigates whether "hidden sectors"—sets of particles and forces that do not interact via standard model gauge forces—can provide a solution. By moving the LSP into a hidden sector, physicists can potentially decouple the dark matter density from the problematic constraints of the visible sector.
Theoretical Extensions and Methodology
The authors evaluate three distinct extensions of the MSSM using theoretical modeling and numerical solutions of the Boltzmann equations to track the evolution of energy densities for moduli, radiation, and dark matter. The models include:
- Symmetric Hidden $U(1)_x$ Sector: An Abelian gauge group where the dark matter is a "hidden neutralino."
- Asymmetric Hidden $U(1)_x$ Sector: A model where an asymmetry between dark matter and its anti-particle is generated during moduli decay, preventing total annihilation.
- Hidden $SU(N)_x$ Sector: A non-Abelian sector where the dark matter candidate is a "hidden gluino."
To test these models, the study incorporates observational constraints from a wide array of datasets, including gamma-ray observations from Fermi-LAT and HESS, Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data from Planck, and direct detection limits from LUX and XENON10.
Key Findings
The Asymmetric Advantage
The most significant result of the study is that Asymmetric Dark Matter (ADM) is the only scenario capable of accounting for 100% of the observed dark matter density while remaining consistent with experimental limits. In this model, the density is determined by the generated asymmetry rather than the annihilation rate. This allows the model to avoid the massive gamma-ray signals that typically rule out symmetric dark matter candidates.
Limitations of Symmetric and Non-Abelian Sectors
While symmetric hidden sectors can avoid detection bounds by utilizing smaller gauge couplings, they generally fail to account for the bulk of dark matter. In most cases, the symmetric hidden LSP can only constitute a small fraction (often less than 10%) of the total dark matter density.
The non-Abelian $SU(N)_x$ models are even more restricted. In these scenarios, the dark matter remains kinetically coupled to hidden gluons for an extended period, creating "dark radiation." This pressure inhibits the clumping of matter, which is strictly constrained by our observations of large-scale structure formation and the CMB. Consequently, hidden gluinos can only contribute a few percent to the total dark matter abundance.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
While hidden sectors offer a viable path to resolving the moduli-induced LSP problem, they are not a panacea. Successful models require a "fortuitous conspiracy" of parameters, where hidden sector mass scales must be precisely balanced against the moduli decay rate. Furthermore, these models require "sequestering" to protect the hidden sector from high-energy supersymmetry breaking scales.
Future research must focus on finding more natural realizations of these hidden sectors within string theory frameworks. Additionally, the sub-GeV mass ranges suggested for these hidden sectors are currently the focus of a new generation of high-precision dark photon searches, which may soon provide experimental evidence for or against these theoretical extensions.
Summary updated