Strongly interacting dark sectors in the early Universe and at the LHC through a simplified portal

Elias Bernreuther, Felix Kahlhoefer, Michael Krämer, Patrick TunneyJournal of High Energy Physics 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores a specific type of "dark sector" – a hidden realm of particles interacting strongly among themselves, but only weakly with our familiar Standard Model. The authors propose a model where this dark sector can explain dark matter and predict unique signatures at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), such as "dark showers" that manifest as semi-visible jets. They analyze existing LHC data and suggest new search strategies to find these elusive particles.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nature of dark matter remains one of the biggest mysteries in physics. While the standard "WIMP miracle" (Weakly Interacting Massive Particles) has been a leading paradigm, experimental searches have so far come up empty. This has motivated exploring alternative dark matter models. One such avenue is the concept of "strongly interacting dark sectors" (SIDS). These models propose that dark matter particles are not isolated but are part of a richer, self-interacting dark sector, analogous to how protons and neutrons are part of the strong nuclear force sector (QCD). These self-interactions can help explain cosmological observations on small scales that are challenging for simple collisionless dark matter models. However, SIDS also predict unique signatures at particle colliders like the LHC, which require dedicated search strategies. This paper aims to bridge the gap between the cosmological viability of a specific SIDS model and its observable consequences at the LHC, proposing how to search for it.

Methods

The authors employ a "simplified model" approach. They consider a dark sector with two types of dark quarks that interact via a strong force similar to QCD. These dark quarks can bind into composite particles, specifically dark pions and rho mesons. The interaction between this dark sector and the Standard Model is mediated by a generic vector boson, a Z' particle.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Chiral Effective Field Theory (EFT): To describe the interactions of the dark pions and rho mesons at low energies, they use a chiral EFT, a standard tool in particle physics for describing the low-energy behavior of strongly interacting systems.
  • Cosmological Freeze-out Calculations: They calculate the relic abundance of dark matter by simulating the process of "freeze-out" in the early Universe, where dark matter particles stop interacting and their abundance is fixed. They identify a specific annihilation process (ππ → ρρ) as crucial for this.
  • Direct Detection Constraints: They analyze how their model would interact with ordinary matter in direct detection experiments, calculating the expected scattering cross-section and comparing it to existing experimental limits.
  • LHC Phenomenology Simulation: For LHC searches, they use sophisticated simulation tools (PYTHIA 8) to model the production of the Z' mediator and its subsequent decay into "dark showers." They then use analysis frameworks (CHECKMATE, MADANALYSIS 5) to "recast" existing LHC searches and estimate the sensitivity of new proposed searches.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it reinterprets existing experimental results from:

  • Direct Detection Experiments: Data from experiments like CRESST-III, CDMSLite, DarkSide-50, PICO-60, PandaX, and XENON1T are used to constrain the model.
  • LHC Searches: Existing LHC exclusion limits from searches for di-jet resonances and missing energy (mono-jet searches) are reinterpreted. They also consider prospective searches for semi-visible jets, referencing analyses from ATLAS and CMS.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dark Pions as Dark Matter: The model proposes that stable dark pions are the dark matter candidates, with their abundance determined by a specific annihilation process in the early Universe.
  • Dark Showers at the LHC: The decay of the Z' mediator into dark quarks leads to "dark showers" – cascades of dark mesons. Since most of these mesons are stable, these showers appear as "semi-visible jets," where a significant fraction of the energy is invisible.
  • Displaced Vertices: The rho mesons, while unstable, can be long-lived due to their weak coupling to the Standard Model. This can lead to displaced vertices at the LHC, a signature distinct from prompt decays.
  • Complementarity of Searches: The paper highlights that existing LHC searches are not optimized for these dark shower signatures. While di-jet resonance searches and missing energy searches provide some constraints, dedicated searches for semi-visible jets and displaced vertices are crucial for fully exploring the parameter space.
  • DarkSide-50 Sensitivity: The authors critically re-evaluate the sensitivity of the DarkSide-50 experiment to low-mass dark matter, suggesting that its claimed exclusion limits might be overly optimistic due to assumptions about the ionization yield.

Key Results

  • Cosmological Viability: The model can be made cosmologically viable, reproducing the observed dark matter relic abundance for a specific range of dark pion and rho meson masses.
  • Direct Detection Constraints: Direct detection experiments place strong constraints on the Z' mediator's coupling strength, favoring either heavy mediators or weak couplings.
  • LHC Constraints: Existing LHC searches for di-jet resonances and missing energy provide constraints, particularly for parameter regions where the rho mesons decay promptly.
  • Sensitivity to Semi-Visible Jets: A dedicated analysis for semi-visible jets shows the potential to probe larger Z' masses than missing energy searches and can be competitive with searches for visible decays.
  • Systematic Uncertainties are Crucial: The sensitivity of the proposed semi-visible jet search is highly dependent on systematic uncertainties, requiring them to be below 1% for significant improvements over existing searches.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Model: The paper uses a simplified model for the Z' mediator. A more complete model might include additional interactions or a more complex dark sector structure.
  • Prompt Decay Approximation: For LHC searches, the analysis often assumes prompt decays of rho mesons. The paper acknowledges that for smaller couplings, these decays can be displaced, and a dedicated analysis for displaced vertices is needed.
  • Systematic Uncertainties: The sensitivity of proposed LHC searches is heavily impacted by systematic uncertainties. Future work should focus on detailed studies of these uncertainties to obtain more realistic sensitivity estimates.
  • Neural Network Searches: The authors suggest that neural networks could be trained to identify dark showers, potentially offering better discrimination against QCD backgrounds than current methods.
  • Low-Mass Z' Searches: The MT search is not optimized for low-mass Z' bosons, and further studies are needed for this regime, potentially requiring high-pr photons from ISR to suppress backgrounds.
  • DarkSide-50 Robustness: The paper raises concerns about the robustness of DarkSide-50's exclusion limits for low-mass dark matter, suggesting further theoretical and experimental work is needed to validate the assumptions made.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We study the cosmology and LHC phenomenology of a consistent strongly interacting dark sector coupled to Standard Model particles through a generic vector mediator. We lay out the requirements for the model to be cosmologically viable, identify annihilations into dark vector mesons as the dominant dark matter freeze-out process and discuss bounds from direct detection. At the LHC the model predicts dark showers, which can give rise to semi-visible jets or displaced vertices. Existing searches for di-jet resonances and for missing energy mostly probe the parameter regions where prompt decays are expected and constrain our model despite not being optimised for dark showers. We also estimate the sensitivity of dedicated analyses for semi-visible jets and emphasize the complementarity of different search strategies.
BibTeX
@article{bernreuther2020strongly,
  author = {Elias Bernreuther and Felix Kahlhoefer and Michael Krämer and Patrick Tunney},
  title = {{Strongly interacting dark sectors in the early Universe and at the LHC through a simplified portal}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep01(2020)162},
}
Figure